›

Bloody Mary is Faith

SmallGoodTigerSmallGoodTiger
edited May 2014 in The Wolf Among Us
Both say See ya around and hold out two fingers whilst they part ways. Marisa caught it and will most likely talk about it in the next episode

Comments

  • DragonButterDragonButter
    We will see... I just can't bear the anticipation. Tension, tension everywhere!
  • Flog61Flog61
    no

    NOOOOO
  • PuhChewyChompPuhChewyChomp
    So Bloody Mary let the Woodsman beat her up? I call bullshit.
  • SmallGoodTigerSmallGoodTiger
    edited May 2014
    Or at least she pretended to be Faith in your first encounter with her.The next episode is called wolf in sheeps clothing. More like B**ch in Donkey skin. She was only with the woodsman in the first episode to get that axe which is enchanted. The beheaded victims all have cuts that appear to be caused by "Magic or something sharp" and considering the fact she can teleport between mirrors, that makes for an easy escape from the open arms hotel when she killed lily.
  • SmallGoodTigerSmallGoodTiger
    I wish I could upload the pics I have I took screen caps of them both doing that with subtitles but you can't post pics in the threads I guess. Or I just can't find the option ha
  • DragonButterDragonButter
    Our lovable psycho, 'tis can't be true!
    Flog61 posted: »

    no NOOOOO

  • SmallGoodTigerSmallGoodTiger
    http://s1264.photobucket.com/user/Starke3/media/Mobile%20Uploads/image_zpsbd94175b.jpg.html?filters[user]=140305958&filters[recent]=1&sort=1&o=1 here are the images
  • SmallGoodTigerSmallGoodTiger
    Nope that didn't work either, probably cause I'm posting from my phone
  • Off_GroundOff_Ground
    Hmm. I don't think it's a coincidence, but I also seriously doubt that the Faith we met was Bloody Mary in disguise. In my impression, BM just isn't refined or subtle or empathic or even intelligent enough to pull that off. Also, the Crooked Man seems to be looking for information about Faith, if he'd had the opportunity to have BM impersonate her already from the first episode, I don't see why he would need to. Any alternate theories?
  • PiggsPiggs
    Maybe Bloody Mary wasn't Faith, but spied on the conversation between Faith and Bigby. She sensed some intimacy between the two; that Bigby might've valued Faith as a person. So, she left Faith's head at Bigby's doorstep, just like she did with the fake Snow head. If that were the case, she'd be mocking Bigby with the that two fingered salute. It'd be yet another demonstration of her dominance in that scene.

    I mean, that leaves a lot of things unexplained on its own, but it's a possibility.
  • SmallGoodTigerSmallGoodTiger
    Well I don't think she was that subtle, she didn't hesitate to grab that axe from the apartment and bury it in the woodsmans head, and then grind it into him while he was down. From what I gathered the crooked man was looking for her donkey skin and a compromising picture of crane, Im assuming he got the picture at least because bigby finds it at the crime scene in the open arms, which I'm sure they planted on purpose. Also when the mirror refuses her location after she was supposed to be dead doesn't add up. I definitely see your point but Doubt the phrasing and hand gesture of both women is to be ignored especially after narrisas reaction right after it. I dunno nothing adds up yet, but I don't think faiths story is done quite yet.
    Off_Ground posted: »

    Hmm. I don't think it's a coincidence, but I also seriously doubt that the Faith we met was Bloody Mary in disguise. In my impression, BM ju

  • SmallGoodTigerSmallGoodTiger
    Yeah she could just be f***ing with him, but my gut says otherwise...I dunno can't wait to find out, and especially to find out who the butcher is and possibly the "jersey devil" the new popular internet theory of another baddie in the game because of telltales cryptic tweets
    Piggs posted: »

    Maybe Bloody Mary wasn't Faith, but spied on the conversation between Faith and Bigby. She sensed some intimacy between the two; that Bigby

  • papai46papai46
    I'm okay with it, both girls are hot.
    DragonButter posted: »

    Our lovable psycho, 'tis can't be true!

  • DragonButterDragonButter
    Agreed, they must work out a lot.
    papai46 posted: »

    I'm okay with it, both girls are hot.

  • Off_GroundOff_Ground
    I'm not saying that Faith and BM are too unalike for one to portray the other, I'm saying that Faith seemed fairly authentic and genuine, and BM strikes me as a terrible actress. She completely messed up her own presentation, for crying out loud. You're right that the gesture and phrasing has to be a clue if it isn't just BM jerking our chain, and that there's something fishy about Faith's coat having been stashed away and the mirror keeping mum about her even after she's supposedly dead, but it still doesn't feel right.

    And why frame Crane if they were just going to nap him from Bigby's custody anyway? I find it more logical that another party placed the picture, and they therefore took him, thinking he was the actual killer and had the information about Faith they were looking for, since he was at least involved with the girls and had become Bigby's prime suspect.
    SmallGoodTiger posted: »

    Well I don't think she was that subtle, she didn't hesitate to grab that axe from the apartment and bury it in the woodsmans head, and then

  • HealozHealoz
    If that happens, omg. But idk kinda seems unlikely. Maybe Telltale thinks that's how people leave, by holding out two fingers.
  • HealozHealoz
    Oh yeah. That's so true. Forgot to consider that. :)
    PuhChewyChomp posted: »

    So Bloody Mary let the Woodsman beat her up? I call bullshit.

  • Mary5Mary5
    edited May 2014
    It's true that the way she said "see you around" to Bigby reminded me of Faith but I don't think it's her. Don't forget that Faith is supposed to be Donkeyskin and we have proof of that. There's the coat, the ring and we even met her husband. She can't be two fables at once.
  • BobitBobit
    edited May 2014
    Bloody Mary is on the rag..... Which is why she hasn't been auditioning at the Puddin n Pie... Bloody Mary is not Faith. Doubtful Mary is the killer, she may get killed though obviously bloody
  • AhmedAli1AhmedAli1
    *Nerissa not Marisa
  • SmallGoodTigerSmallGoodTiger
    Yeah good point but I had a feeling they wanted craned dethroned and after he was a suspect in the murders "take care of him" because he knew too much. I don't know but in a week or so we get to find out!!
    Off_Ground posted: »

    I'm not saying that Faith and BM are too unalike for one to portray the other, I'm saying that Faith seemed fairly authentic and genuine, an

  • ackwellackwell
    I find it more likely that Bloody Mary was spying on them during that whole encounter with Faith, and is subtlety taunting Bigby with that quote.
  • VinceOrKennyVinceOrKenny
    What if I told you no.

    Anyway who da heck is marisa?
  • SmallGoodTigerSmallGoodTiger
    The little mermaid, I spelled her name wrong
    VinceOrKenny posted: »

    What if I told you no. Anyway who da heck is marisa?

  • SmallGoodTigerSmallGoodTiger
    Maybe but that seems to subtle for her
    ackwell posted: »

    I find it more likely that Bloody Mary was spying on them during that whole encounter with Faith, and is subtlety taunting Bigby with that quote.

  • SmallGoodTigerSmallGoodTiger
    I thought it was more likely Bloody Mary impersonated her at the beginning of ep.1
    Mary5 posted: »

    It's true that the way she said "see you around" to Bigby reminded me of Faith but I don't think it's her. Don't forget that Faith is suppos

  • kenlilleementinebenykenlilleementinebeny
    Oh my god...OF COURSE!it all makes sense now..
  • Off_GroundOff_Ground
    ...How do you figure?
    kenlilleementinebeny posted: »

    Oh my god...OF COURSE!it all makes sense now..

  • Nat01Nat01
    no she is not. how can that be. her head was cut off. mary clearly has hers still on
  • AzlynAzlyn
    That's probably because they reused the animation or something.
  • MagnusLupusMagnusLupus
    A good question would be, who is she not? lol! First the 'theorists' said that she was Brannigan, now she is Faith. Next she will either be that Red headed guy, or an emo-Snow White military experiment... sigh...
  • nusi2nusi2
    There are theories that she is Greenleaf`s daughter too. That one is the most possible. Bloody Mary might have been around and saw Bigby and Faith. It`s unlikely for her to be glamoured like Faith, i don`t think she could have been that patient with Woody.
    MagnusLupus posted: »

    A good question would be, who is she not? lol! First the 'theorists' said that she was Brannigan, now she is Faith. Next she will either be that Red headed guy, or an emo-Snow White military experiment... sigh...

  • SmallGoodTigerSmallGoodTiger

    Well I was super wrong

  • kenlilleementinebenykenlilleementinebeny

    Yeah!and snow white is bufkin!

    obvioussarcasm

  • Free_DeadFree_Dead

    Alt text

  • koban4maxkoban4max

    If blood mary sounds like you...then you must be bloody mary...right?

  • Kirbinator93PCKirbinator93PC

    I think Bigby is Beast who is Crane who is Crooked Man who is BLUE BEARD :0

  • JimDaBombJimDaBomb

    When she says "See ya around, Wolf." the voice changes to Bloody Mary's voice.. you can tell that's BM's voice when she says wolf.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.