›

Mystery solved: Someone close to the murder victim is always the suspect

RosemaryTWDFanRosemaryTWDFan
edited May 2014 in The Wolf Among Us
So someone close or knew Lily and Faith is the murderers

People close to Lily and Faith:

Vivian

Narrissa

Hans

Gorge

Prince Lawrence

Holly

Woodsman

Grendel

These are prime victims who know what happened and involved somehow

Here are the prime suspects:

Jersey Devil ( Unknown yet)

Bloody Mary

Dee/Dum

Crooked Man

Jack

Green leaf

Cinderella ( Unknown yet)

Tiny Tim ( Unknown yet but he was the driver of the car Crooked Man was in which makes him a suspect)

The taxi driver ( Seems suspicious in episode 1)

Bigby ( Plot twist Bigby finds out that he's responsible for the crimes in part 5) I think that's why episode 5 is called Cry Wolf

Crane ( possible but unlikely)

Woodsman

Mundy police department cop ( Probably someone on the Mundy police force did it)

The Butcher

Comments

  • Clem_is_awesomeClem_is_awesome Banned
    edited May 2014
    So basically almost every single character in the game is a suspect for you. Thanks, that will lead us far in this investigation
  • DragonButterDragonButter
    She needs to take some pointers from Phelps, Bekowsky even.
    Clem_is_awesome posted: »

    So basically almost every single character in the game is a suspect for you. Thanks, that will lead us far in this investigation

  • Eddie_MaidenEddie_Maiden
    The Woodsman is so suspicious he's on there twice.
    Clem_is_awesome posted: »

    So basically almost every single character in the game is a suspect for you. Thanks, that will lead us far in this investigation

  • TheDeadAmongUsTheDeadAmongUs
    Well, Bigby might be responsible, but probably indirectly. He CAN"T be the killer. The killer has a vendetta against Bigby, so that's the only was he can be held accountable.
  • pudding_piepudding_pie
    I'm not sure who this 'Gorge' is but maybe he's the one that did all this...DUN DUN DUN! :0
  • pudding_piepudding_pie
    edited May 2014
    Stupid computer! Post twice!!! XD
  • RosemaryTWDFanRosemaryTWDFan
    I play LA Noire so I got enough tips from them lol
    DragonButter posted: »

    She needs to take some pointers from Phelps, Bekowsky even.

  • TheDeadAmongUsTheDeadAmongUs
    YES, THE CULPRIT IS FOUND! BEST DETECTIVE WORK YET! XD
    pudding_pie posted: »

    I'm not sure who this 'Gorge' is but maybe he's the one that did all this...DUN DUN DUN! :0

  • ChuckTheLizardChuckTheLizard
    That's fucking stupid Ben.
  • VinceOrKennyVinceOrKenny
    Episode 5 is called cry wolf because : Gingee guy= cryer= the boy who cried wolf.

    Also, you could have just wrte; Suspects: Everyone.
  • VinceOrKennyVinceOrKenny
    edited May 2014
    Sorry, double post
  • BobitBobit
    edited May 2014
    Nonsense, to this thread titled comment. "Someone close to the murder victim is always the suspect". The blunt statement almost works here when all the fables are from a secret society. They all came from imagination land, knowing each other, and are in the fable records.

    You do realize? 10-20% of murders. Are not committed with any victim being known, to a sociopath or psychopath. Often murder can be opportunity, victim's being within the wrong place at the wrong time, accidental to any occurrence or to circumstance.

    Although that is not the case here. The victim's were obviously known to the killer, when they were used to implicate when making a statement to the fable community. Read all about it, the fairytale herald, "heedless horse, has been murdered".

    I like Mundie theory. A punter who hate fables has been chopping them up, leaving them outside Fable parliament to create a scandal, getting them all evicted. Doesn't work in this game, because they wouldn't stop with hooking.

    Suspects entering into late game are what is known as development to the settings, sure they are all linked to this crime investigation, as everybody in the community has had a part in this tale. The crime investigation murder case has shown many aspects of its investigation to many other linked crimes. Most involvement has been circumstantial proving absolutely nothing when introducing yet another toon.

    However, we really would be watching a video not playing a game, if the killer has only been leaving us poop to find. Then we finally get to unmask the serial shitter, whom was introduced in later episodes.
  • MosesARoseMosesARose
    Isn't Bloody Mary the killer? She has the axe after all.
  • CodPatrolCodPatrol
    Yeah, get Phelps and Nahman Jayden up in here.
    RosemaryTWDFan posted: »

    I play LA Noire so I got enough tips from them lol

  • BobitBobit
    edited May 2014
    Unless you have played episode 4 and there is massive evidence outside of her psychotic circumstances, when holding a potential murder weapon.

    An absurd assumption naming Bloody Mary, which you have likely followed this theory. Episode one, the Tweedles. Episode two, Bluebeard, or vice a verse. Episode three, Bloody Mary.

    There is a lack of evidence supporting Mary. Jokingly on previous threads at the ridiculousness of naming any girl "Bloody". Circumstances: All the Fables mostly have been circumstantial to this case without any real motives. The Crooked Man employs Mary. If Mary was the killer, she would have killed Bigby, game over. Because Mary would have gotten away with murder at the point, proving your theory. You are assuming that Mary is bulletproof? Is that what you are saying, when making that assumption?

    Mary may still might be the killer, but it would be so lame after letting Bigby live. She isn't immune and won't run away after taking Crane.
    MosesARose posted: »

    Isn't Bloody Mary the killer? She has the axe after all.

  • MosesARoseMosesARose
    edited May 2014
    Okay I just asked a simple yes or no question, I didn't ask for an entire essay explaining why my opinion is wrong. That's awesome that you don't believe Mary is the murder. But I do. It's absurd to just dismiss her as the murderer simply because she didn't kill Bigby or she works for CM, as I see it you think she's immune. If I remember correctly she was about to kill Bigby until Snow said stop and told her she could have Crane. At that point Mary looks to CM to see if that's alright, and CM accepted. After all they came for Crane in the first place, not to kill Bigby.

    Mary could still be the murderer, but it's up to CM who she kills and when she kills. He could be the orchestrating everything. There's evidence supporting the axe as the murder weapon. Episode 1 Bigby said something either very sharp or something with magic attached to it had cut off Fath's head. Then later you find that the axe was blessed by a Druid. Now the axe is in Mary's possession, and when she was about to kill Bigby she was going for his head, just like every murder victim.
    Bobit posted: »

    Unless you have played episode 4 and there is massive evidence outside of her psychotic circumstances, when holding a potential murder weap

  • AzlynAzlyn
    Thank you for this insightful thread.
  • MasterStoneMasterStone
    I'm ruling Cindy out.
  • MagnusLupusMagnusLupus
    Well, I'm going to go out on a limb and say Jack can be removed as a suspect *cough* comics *cough*. The Jersey Devil, well we have not even been introduced to such a character yet, all we have is speculation that that character will even be included...
  • NaturalPineappleNaturalPineapple
    EF, BEE, EYE
    CodPatrol posted: »

    Yeah, get Phelps and Nahman Jayden up in here.

  • CaptainGreasepalmsCaptainGreasepalms
    May I ask how this makes the mystery solved ?
  • Blind SniperBlind Sniper Moderator

    Please behave and play nice in this thread. Thanks.

    (Hooray for the new flag system!)

  • Gavin34Gavin34

    Finally bobit got banned

    Bobit posted: »

    Unless you have played episode 4 and there is massive evidence outside of her psychotic circumstances, when holding a potential murder weap

  • Raging_BladesRaging_Blades

    You called me?

    CodPatrol posted: »

    Yeah, get Phelps and Nahman Jayden up in here.

  • AscariAscari

    Okay. My bad.

    Blind Sniper posted: »

    Please behave and play nice in this thread. Thanks. (Hooray for the new flag system!)

  • ZyphonZyphon

    ....Is there anyone you don't suspect?

  • CthulhuTheGreatCthulhuTheGreat
    edited June 2014

    I think I'm about to open a bottle of single malt to celebrate.

    Gavin34 posted: »

    Finally bobit got banned

  • Faye_KaneFaye_Kane

    The only story I ever saw where the killer is the detective was the fourth Hellraiser movie.

    -flk

    TheDeadAmongUs posted: »

    Well, Bigby might be responsible, but probably indirectly. He CAN"T be the killer. The killer has a vendetta against Bigby, so that's the only was he can be held accountable.

  • CthulhuTheGreatCthulhuTheGreat

    There are Colin and Bufkin.

    Zyphon posted: »

    ....Is there anyone you don't suspect?

Sign in to comment in this discussion.