Somethings not right
After playing episode 5, i decided to replay all of the episodes. I think that after ep1 they changed the plot, a lot of it. It all wasnt supposed to be about punishing Faith and Lilly for stealing a photo at first. It was about a serial killer (as it was mentioned in ep2 official trailer at the end of the ep1). It all just doesnt fall in places. I really paid attention to details in episode 1.
I dont understand Faith being Nerissa/Nerissa being Faith. In ep1 Faith smokes her own ciggarettes, which arent the brand that Nerissa is smoking (its clearly shown in the ep3 i guess). They aren't slim cigs. I know, just details, but Telltale really pays attention to such small things..
Also. Faith mentioning something about Bigby should arrest her now because she's not going to do "THIS" anymore soon. So that might be OK for the plot after change of plans, but still, I think she was going somewhere else with this.
At the end, when we ask Nerissa about torn piece of fabric Bigby found on the crimescene, she says she cut her leg. She's wearing damn dress (not denim at all) all the time when she's a hooker and also in ep2 when we go to Puddin'n'Pie she doestn have any open wounds, and even healing ones (as Woodsman has a big bandage over his head after being hurt, and there were a lot of blood on the scene, shouldnt she at least have a little scratch?).
And the most bothering thing. Holly says her sister been missing for weeks in first ep, and in second suddenly she knows that she was hooking. So why didnt she ever thought about just going to the Puddin'n'Pie and looking for her? If she knew, its just so strange, no one who loves someone just leaves the case while having a clue, and waits till the government deals with it. I guess they weren't planning Lilly being Snow.
I dont think that blaming things on Georgie and Crooked Man was planned from the beginning. Something doesnt feel right about the whole story, and i guess we wont ever know what the real plan was.. And i dont think that stealing one photo of Crane and Lilly would've been such a big deal. In ep2 we can find a whole folder filled with them photos and so what?
Its just bothering me really badly. Playing the game again after you know whole plot makes you look at it in the whole new perspective.
Comments
Nice observation about Nerissa not having any wounds in her legs when we see her naked on stage. If she cut her leg she should have bandages. I guess the girl on stage either isn't the same girl we talk to in the ending or she was lying. I say she may not be the same girl because I believe there's a possibility that Faith and Nerissa (and even maybe Lily) are alive, and the girls have been plotting together. The final line she delivers before walking away may be because she knows what Faith said because they have talked about it.
"These girls and their preposterous schemes" -I. Crane