Lilly? (spoilers)
I'm not sure if this has been discussed here before, but I'm still confused as to what happened with Lilly's crime scene. We know that Georgie was the one who killed her/pulled her ribbon and then dumped her body into the river where she was later discovered by TJ. We also know she was glamoured as Snow at the time she was killed, and had been reported missing a week or two prior.
There are also a bunch of other weird connections with Lilly's murder. So, at the Open Arms, you walk into the room and see what is a pretty obvious crime scene. There's blood everywhere, meaning that Georgie killed her in that room. But why was Lilly in that room in the first place? Well, if you remember back to the first episode, Crane has snow call Vivian to cancel his "appointment" with Lilly (meaning she was alive at this point). Vivian fails to scratch this off from the books though, because in Episode 2 her name is still there when Nerissa/Faith gives us the book. In the last episode, Nerissa/Faith mentions also that Lilly "wasn't with her scheduled appointment" when she tried to warn her about Georgie.
This leads me to believe that Nerissa/Faith went looking for Lilly and then found the blood stains and staged the scene of the crime. This is evident in a couple different ways. First off is the flowers. They don't have blood one them and were rather placed over the blood. Next and probably the biggest piece of evidence is the photograph. The whole reason either of them were murdered was for the photograph, and Faith was the only one who could have the photo of them. So then why lead Bigby to Crane rather than Georgie? I'd have to say it's because Georgie is set in his ways and loyal to TCM, while Crane is fearful and would eventually lead Bigby to TCM and his crew.
Sorry that a lot of this is just rambling haha. Thoughts?
Comments
if nerrisa was the one putting the heads on bigby's doorstep wouldn't she also but the one who put the blood all over that room since she had access to both faith and Lillys bodies
think about it she was the one who gave you that key and made sure your found room 207 plus why would crane or georgie be stupid enough to leave that "picture" in a room full of blood as evidence lol
nerrisa wanted to motivate bigby to stop the crooked man so staging a fake crime scene and then planting the picture of crane and Lilly would have pointed bigby at crane and eventually the crooked man
That's exactly what I'm saying: That Faith staged it and left the pictures there for Bigby to find.
That being said, I do not think she put the blood all over the room, and I think Lilly truly was murdered there. Too much blood would have been already spilled if she had been murdered in a different place. Plus, she didn't have access to Lilly's body, because Georgie took it and dumped it into the river, and even if she did, I don't think she could drag a decapitated corpse into a hotel without raising suspicion haha.