Yeah but it wouldn't be Minecraft and even fans of it are more about open world than anything else. Playing a Minecraft game about story feels awkward. I wouldn't want to play a GTA story based game.
How do you think new stories are created? They all start from scratch. Only in Telltale's case, depending on what elements they use for the IPs, they may have some characters etc. established.
The Minecraft setting will just give them the building blocks. Zombies attacking, building, mine exploration (and possibly more, as I'm not familiar with Minecraft). They'll take Minecraft's elements and, as an assumption, build an amusing and fun based narrative (meaning comedy).
PS: Upon seeing your reply above, there are minecraft stories being sold. Then there are popular videos on Youtube. 700 - 800 thousand views, I'm talking about. It stands to reason if you like Minecraft, you might like a game with puns and humor based on it as well.
Well there is a clear difference between TWD and Minecraft. TWD had an amazing amount of story potential as seen with the comics and show. Minecraft doesn't have any of this. It was never meant to be a story
Yeah but it wouldn't be Minecraft and even fans of it are more about open world than anything else. Playing a Minecraft game about story feels awkward. I wouldn't want to play a GTA story based game.
I don"t know it would be like a shark without its teeth something would be missing. People only play Minecraft to build and explore the open world. No one is really interested in a story.
This is a perfect example of why people shouldn't be worrying about the Minecraft community coming to the forums - childish people like you are already here.
If you want to get technical about it, one could argue this company fell apart when Sean Vanaman and Jake Rodkin jumped ship. Every game Telltale has made since then has just been kind of meh.
Wolf Among Us certainly was not a bad game.
Jake and Sean were not the corner piece of every important Telltale game. As Vain kinda touched upon, Sam and Max: The Devil's Playhouse was also my favorite Telltale season. Sure, in terms of Walking Dead, I feel Season 1 was more sentimental and bittersweet whereas Season 2 was more nihilistic, but I don't feel that assessing every current Telltale game by the absence of Jake and Sean is an accurate way to judge a game's quality.
If you want to get technical about it, one could argue this company fell apart when Sean Vanaman and Jake Rodkin jumped ship. Every game Tel… moreltale has made since then has just been kind of meh. They can still start series off with a bang, but they have a hard time carrying that spark through their series anymore. With the direction Telltale has been heading in since TWD Season 1, can't say I blame them for leaving.
...and if Telltale cancels Walking Dead: Season 3 because Minecraft failed, Game of Thrones will become Telltale's new flagship franchise to spite the Walking Dead fans for not buying Minecraft! The horror! Muhahahaha!
Yes, it's true. All Walking Dead fans are obliged to buy a copy of Minecraft or there will never be a Season 3 of TWD. They will have brought it upon themselves!
...and if Telltale cancels Walking Dead: Season 3 because Minecraft failed, Game of Thrones will become Telltale's new flagship franchise to spite the Walking Dead fans for not buying Minecraft! The horror! Muhahahaha!
I have no problem with the idea. It's very unusual and it's the last thing that I think Telltale would do. I'm not going to judge their new project until the first episode is released.
I don"t know it would be like a shark without its teeth something would be missing. People only play Minecraft to build and explore the open world. No one is really interested in a story.
No, it won't fail but inside i secretly laugh my ass off because of the absurdness of the choice. Why this why not ANYTHING Else? Please i want someone to explain the reasoning behind this choice in logical manner. I am a reasonable man, sometimes.
Why not TTG Breaking Bad
Why not TTG Anything with a story
Why not TTG Comic Storyline
Why not TTG Horror Game.
We get minecraft. Why? I don't understand and as a Vulcan I can't live with the fallacies of the logic!
My major problem with this and more really the way Telltale is going is that it feels like it's just about the money and less about care and detail now.
1) The gameplay - It's only QTE and dialogue responses, before Walking Dead it was long episodes with lots of gameplay, not much dialogue variety or choices, then Walking Dead, around the same length with less gameplay but dialogue and choice re-activity, and now it's no gameplay, barely any choice re-activity and just QTE's. They don't even need the episode system anymore really it's likely just used as a money grab. I'm wasting my time trying to politely tell people logical reasons why many people are upset with modern telltale because the likelyhood is most of you will still buy this and it's season pass even if it's 1 hour long and it's choices don't even pretend to matter...oh wait thats Season 2 of WD.
TL;DR - The reasons this exists is because you people keep buying these hoping for something as good as season 1, but they won't bother because they aren't losing money.
Wolf Among Us actually was pretty good. I enjoyed Tales so far, and I personally don't mind modern Telltale as long as the story and characters are good.
My major problem with this and more really the way Telltale is going is that it feels like it's just about the money and less about care and… more detail now.
1) The gameplay - It's only QTE and dialogue responses, before Walking Dead it was long episodes with lots of gameplay, not much dialogue variety or choices, then Walking Dead, around the same length with less gameplay but dialogue and choice re-activity, and now it's no gameplay, barely any choice re-activity and just QTE's. They don't even need the episode system anymore really it's likely just used as a money grab. I'm wasting my time trying to politely tell people logical reasons why many people are upset with modern telltale because the likelyhood is most of you will still buy this and it's season pass even if it's 1 hour long and it's choices don't even pretend to matter...oh wait thats Season 2 of WD.
TL;DR - The reasons this exists is because you people keep buying these hoping fo… [view original content]
No, it won't fail but inside i secretly laugh my ass off because of the absurdness of the choice. Why this why not ANYTHING Else? Please i… more want someone to explain the reasoning behind this choice in logical manner. I am a reasonable man, sometimes.
Why not TTG Breaking Bad
Why not TTG Anything with a story
Why not TTG Comic Storyline
Why not TTG Horror Game.
We get minecraft. Why? I don't understand and as a Vulcan I can't live with the fallacies of the logic!
Fall of Telltale was sloppy, empathyless and showing lack of care Walking Dead season 2 followed with humorless Tales from Borderlands and "grab the money and run while TV show still hasnt jumped the sharks" Game of Thrones.
This is just another step down the same road of meaningless commercialism.
Fall of Telltale was sloppy, empathyless and showing lack of care Walking Dead season 2 followed with humorless Tales from Borderlands and "… moregrab the money and run while TV show still hasnt jumped the sharks" Game of Thrones.
This is just another step down the same road of meaningless commercialism.
Oh, what ridiculous bullshit are you spewing out now? Tales was fine, your whole bullshit money complaint was rebuttled long ago, and I could say the same thing about Walking Dead and Jurassic Park being the road to meaningless commercialism, this isn't the first time. God, you're annoying.
Fall of Telltale was sloppy, empathyless and showing lack of care Walking Dead season 2 followed with humorless Tales from Borderlands and "… moregrab the money and run while TV show still hasnt jumped the sharks" Game of Thrones.
This is just another step down the same road of meaningless commercialism.
Tales is fine, if you compare it to Borderlands Pre Sequel, worst title in Borderlands serial or Telltale games like Strong Bad.
Im soon to finish Borderlands 2, chronologically the last and then I will play and dissect Tales of Borderlands once again. But, so far I can tell that in major parts it lacks atmosphere of Borderlands serial and quality of first two games.
Oh, what ridiculous bullshit are you spewing out now? Tales was fine, your whole bullshit money complaint was rebuttled long ago, and I coul… mored say the same thing about Walking Dead and Jurassic Park being the road to meaningless commercialism, this isn't the first time. God, you're annoying.
Tales is fine, if you compare it to Borderlands Pre Sequel, worst title in Borderlands serial or Telltale games like Strong Bad.
Im soon … moreto finish Borderlands 2, chronologically the last and then I will play and dissect Tales of Borderlands once again. But, so far I can tell that in major parts it lacks atmosphere of Borderlands serial and quality of first two games.
Fall of Telltale was sloppy, empathyless and showing lack of care Walking Dead season 2 followed with humorless Tales from Borderlands and "… moregrab the money and run while TV show still hasnt jumped the sharks" Game of Thrones.
This is just another step down the same road of meaningless commercialism.
lacks atmosphere of Borderlands serial and quality of first two games.
Well, that'll be interesting, as you may be the only person to ever say that Tales fails to live up to the Borderlands name, which probably is just you being ridiculous again, but can't wait to laugh at you once more.
Tales is fine, if you compare it to Borderlands Pre Sequel, worst title in Borderlands serial or Telltale games like Strong Bad.
Im soon … moreto finish Borderlands 2, chronologically the last and then I will play and dissect Tales of Borderlands once again. But, so far I can tell that in major parts it lacks atmosphere of Borderlands serial and quality of first two games.
You probably stopped reading game reviews ages ago, too, because its apparent Borderlands Pre Sequel nowhere near rates of Borderlands 1 and 2.
So, not just my opinion but opion of majority of true gamers.
lacks atmosphere of Borderlands serial and quality of first two games.
Well, that'll be interesting, as you may be the only person t… moreo ever say that Tales fails to live up to the Borderlands name, which probably is just you being ridiculous again, but can't wait to laugh at you once more.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NIgfiSzCy1o
Sure, you have your own opinions, but try to back your reasons up with solid arguments instead of ridiculous and silly ones. LOL, "money shouldn't work this way." "I know what you're saying, but I still can't listen to it, because I can't accept that I messed up."
Well, even if I'm not "true fan" I have my own opinions. Unlike YOU.
In my book it goes something like this:
Borderlands 2 >> Borderlands 1 >> Tales of Borderlands >> Borderlands Pre Sequel
You are still getting too personal when you in lack of arguments. But I got used to it and dont expect it from you anymore. Can't say it. If you know what I mean..
Well, my arguments may be ridiculous and silly but in comparison to have no arguments at all, just being personal and insult, they are quite strong, in fact.
Sure, you have your own opinions, but try to back your reasons up with solid arguments instead of ridiculous and silly ones. LOL, "money sho… moreuldn't work this way." "I know what you're saying, but I still can't listen to it, because I can't accept that I messed up."
You are still getting too personal when you in lack of arguments. But I got used to it and dont expect it from you anymore. Can't say it. If you know what I mean..
Well, my arguments may be ridiculous and silly but in comparison to have no arguments at all, just being personal and insult, they are quite strong, in fact.
And you keep telling yourself you have opinion even if you dont have any arguments to back it up. Ever. And keep waiting for "true fans" to do battles for you.
You should know, that I deleted that comment because it was dumb, and I think you really are not seeing the big picture, I have arguments, you have ones that are downright silly and laughable.
And you keep telling yourself you have opinion even if you dont have any arguments to back it up. Ever. And keep waiting for "true fans" to do battles for you.
You're giving him/her exactly what they want. Attention.
When someone can't understand why anyone would want 10 million cash, especially on Pandora where it's a backwater planet and there are psychos (as well as the wildlife) everywhere that make life expectancy low, that's when you don't try very hard to explain things because nothing's going to work.
You should know, that I deleted that comment because it was dumb, and I think you really are not seeing the big picture, I have arguments, you have ones that are downright silly and laughable.
Comments
Well there you say "I GREW UP." you are lucky for me it bad I GREW DOWN.
(
Yeah but it wouldn't be Minecraft and even fans of it are more about open world than anything else. Playing a Minecraft game about story feels awkward. I wouldn't want to play a GTA story based game.
How do you think new stories are created? They all start from scratch. Only in Telltale's case, depending on what elements they use for the IPs, they may have some characters etc. established.
The Minecraft setting will just give them the building blocks. Zombies attacking, building, mine exploration (and possibly more, as I'm not familiar with Minecraft). They'll take Minecraft's elements and, as an assumption, build an amusing and fun based narrative (meaning comedy).
PS: Upon seeing your reply above, there are minecraft stories being sold. Then there are popular videos on Youtube. 700 - 800 thousand views, I'm talking about. It stands to reason if you like Minecraft, you might like a game with puns and humor based on it as well.
I'm pretty sure you can still tell the story of a GTA game and get its satire across without the open world.
They have 20 years to work with. It being a prequel means nothing.
I don"t know it would be like a shark without its teeth something would be missing. People only play Minecraft to build and explore the open world. No one is really interested in a story.
I'm wasn't being childish .I am venting .
Wolf Among Us certainly was not a bad game.
Jake and Sean were not the corner piece of every important Telltale game. As Vain kinda touched upon, Sam and Max: The Devil's Playhouse was also my favorite Telltale season. Sure, in terms of Walking Dead, I feel Season 1 was more sentimental and bittersweet whereas Season 2 was more nihilistic, but I don't feel that assessing every current Telltale game by the absence of Jake and Sean is an accurate way to judge a game's quality.
Here's one of the choices I think would be in the game.
DID YOU TRADE 7 EMERALDS FOR A SADDLE OR DID YOU KILL THE VILLAGER?
X% TRADED 7 EMERALDS FOR THE SADDLE.
X% DECIDED TO SHOOT THE VILLAGER WITH A BOW TO DEATH.
...and if Telltale cancels Walking Dead: Season 3 because Minecraft failed, Game of Thrones will become Telltale's new flagship franchise to spite the Walking Dead fans for not buying Minecraft! The horror! Muhahahaha!
"cock-ride"
Nice choice of words, and I think you also complained about "blocky" graphics in another thread.
Some people that didn't know the walking dead hated the idea
http://www.telltalegames.com/community/discussion/22918/a-petition-and-protest-against-this-game
I have no problem with the idea. It's very unusual and it's the last thing that I think Telltale would do. I'm not going to judge their new project until the first episode is released.
wat.
And your point is?
Its not going to make them "fall" one game has little potential to do that
No, it won't fail but inside i secretly laugh my ass off because of the absurdness of the choice. Why this why not ANYTHING Else? Please i want someone to explain the reasoning behind this choice in logical manner. I am a reasonable man, sometimes.
Why not TTG Breaking Bad
Why not TTG Anything with a story
Why not TTG Comic Storyline
Why not TTG Horror Game.
We get minecraft. Why? I don't understand and as a Vulcan I can't live with the fallacies of the logic!
My major problem with this and more really the way Telltale is going is that it feels like it's just about the money and less about care and detail now.
1) The gameplay - It's only QTE and dialogue responses, before Walking Dead it was long episodes with lots of gameplay, not much dialogue variety or choices, then Walking Dead, around the same length with less gameplay but dialogue and choice re-activity, and now it's no gameplay, barely any choice re-activity and just QTE's. They don't even need the episode system anymore really it's likely just used as a money grab. I'm wasting my time trying to politely tell people logical reasons why many people are upset with modern telltale because the likelyhood is most of you will still buy this and it's season pass even if it's 1 hour long and it's choices don't even pretend to matter...oh wait thats Season 2 of WD.
TL;DR - The reasons this exists is because you people keep buying these hoping for something as good as season 1, but they won't bother because they aren't losing money.
Wolf Among Us actually was pretty good. I enjoyed Tales so far, and I personally don't mind modern Telltale as long as the story and characters are good.
Dunno why anyone would call this the "fall" of Telltale since they're working on the second episode of GOT and TFTBL and currently developing TWD S3.
Well for that one the story if about walt (from what I know) its not really set in an special environment. Its just the U.S.
Fall of Telltale was sloppy, empathyless and showing lack of care Walking Dead season 2 followed with humorless Tales from Borderlands and "grab the money and run while TV show still hasnt jumped the sharks" Game of Thrones.
This is just another step down the same road of meaningless commercialism.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ztVMib1T4T4
Oh, what ridiculous bullshit are you spewing out now? Tales was fine, your whole bullshit money complaint was rebuttled long ago, and I could say the same thing about Walking Dead and Jurassic Park being the road to meaningless commercialism, this isn't the first time. God, you're annoying.
Tales is fine, if you compare it to Borderlands Pre Sequel, worst title in Borderlands serial or Telltale games like Strong Bad.
Im soon to finish Borderlands 2, chronologically the last and then I will play and dissect Tales of Borderlands once again. But, so far I can tell that in major parts it lacks atmosphere of Borderlands serial and quality of first two games.
"Borderlands Pre Sequel, worst title in Borderlands serial "
Stopped listening there and laughed
Well, that'll be interesting, as you may be the only person to ever say that Tales fails to live up to the Borderlands name, which probably is just you being ridiculous again, but can't wait to laugh at you once more.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NIgfiSzCy1o
You probably stopped reading game reviews ages ago, too, because its apparent Borderlands Pre Sequel nowhere near rates of Borderlands 1 and 2.
So, not just my opinion but opion of majority of true gamers.
Still an annoying little.......can't say it, but you know what I mean
Well, even if I'm not "true fan" I have my own opinions. Unlike YOU.
In my book it goes something like this:
Borderlands 2 >> Borderlands 1 >> Tales of Borderlands >> Borderlands Pre Sequel
Sure, you have your own opinions, but try to back your reasons up with solid arguments instead of ridiculous and silly ones. LOL, "money shouldn't work this way." "I know what you're saying, but I still can't listen to it, because I can't accept that I messed up."
You are still getting too personal when you in lack of arguments. But I got used to it and dont expect it from you anymore. Can't say it. If you know what I mean..
Well, my arguments may be ridiculous and silly but in comparison to have no arguments at all, just being personal and insult, they are quite strong, in fact.
I already gave you an argument back on your ridiculous thread, and yet, you still didn't get it.
Keep telling yourself that.
And you keep telling yourself you have opinion even if you dont have any arguments to back it up. Ever. And keep waiting for "true fans" to do battles for you.
You should know, that I deleted that comment because it was dumb, and I think you really are not seeing the big picture, I have arguments, you have ones that are downright silly and laughable.
J,
You're giving him/her exactly what they want. Attention.
When someone can't understand why anyone would want 10 million cash, especially on Pandora where it's a backwater planet and there are psychos (as well as the wildlife) everywhere that make life expectancy low, that's when you don't try very hard to explain things because nothing's going to work.
The person is rather amusing though, if annoying.