The Most Hated TWAU Characters (Round 1) (CLOSED)

edited January 2015 in The Wolf Among Us

Hey there guys and girls, this is armis37 speaking. We've had a poll about hottest characters of TWAU, male and female, and that was one intriguing match! Now, since I have a lot of free time, I've decided to make my first poll. This one will be about The Most Hated Characters of TWAU. Hope you will enjoy the matchups and won't try to rig it :)

A bit of rules : in this poll, when you're voting for something, you're saying that you hate that person more, not vice versa. The one with more votes will advance to the next round of "hatery".

You don't necessarily need to hate some character, just vote for the one you like less :)

Bigby vs Bloody Mary

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422332

Beast vs Beauty

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422339

Bufkin vs Flycatcher

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422345

Aunty Greenleaf vs Johann

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422349

Bluebeard vs Jersey Devil

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422351

Hans vs Lawrence

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422365

Colin vs Toad

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422378

Crooked Man vs Crane

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422382

Cryer vs Tiny Tim

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422386

Faith vs Nerissa

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422389

Georgie Porgie vs Vivian

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422390

Gren vs Woodsman

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422391

Grimble vs Brannigan

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422395

Gwen vs Swineheart

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422397

Holly vs Jack

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422400

Lily vs Magic Mirror

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422401

Snow White vs Toad Jr.

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422407

Dee vs Dum

Alt text Alt text
http://strawpoll.me/3422410

Comments

  • edited January 2015

    Ok armis; here's my list:

    • Bloody Mary (How can you hate Bigby!? Plus she tried to kill him... @TheZorkij sorry bro but I gotta stick with Biggs on this one)
    • Beauty (She's annoying... At least Beast can be helpful)
    • Bufkin (NOBODY can hate Flycatcher for anything... Bufkin can't keep secrets)
    • Johann (I'm sorry but as much as I try and be nice at The Cut Above, Johann's stonewalling ALWAYS makes me wanna hit him!)
    • Bluebeard (He's the biggest prick in Fabletown, at least Jersey can be humorous)
    • Lawrence (I just found him to be a weak character, Hans helped you anyways...)
    • Toad (He's an asshole. Colin is funny)
    • Crane (Sick creep wanting to bang Snow when that's Bigby's right!!! Crooked Man had a certain charm about him...)
    • Tiny Tim (He knows what the CM did to Bigby in the alley and yet he STILL works for him... Cryer is a leftover from the original plot :P)
    • Faith (Her tough attitude got kinda boring; Nerissa is lovely)
    • Georgie Porgie (He's a class A prick and deserved to die; Vivian was a tragic character...) Apologies to @pudding_pie :/
    • Gren (Woody turned out ok when he was sober; but Gren's attitude gets very annoying very quickly)
    • Brannigan (Grimble's awesome in the comics! Brannigan's a Mundy who doesn't know anything :P)
    • Gwen (I know she didn't do anything but I can't hate Swineheart for fixing up Bigby...)
    • Jack Horner (Easy decision, he's a real scum-bag and Holly is just trying to get by)
    • Magic Mirror (All those rhymes...)
    • TJ (You are a real bastard for making me choose this! I love Snow and TJ was always the same)
    • Dee (He was more annoying than Dum)

    So there we have it; my choices for your list XD

  • Wasnt so sure what to do with the guys who didnt talk lol

  • What; Lily, Gwen and Grimble? :P

    Poogers555 posted: »

    Wasnt so sure what to do with the guys who didnt talk lol

  • Yeah :P

    HazzatheMan posted: »

    What; Lily, Gwen and Grimble? :P

  • Nice contest, good job Armis. Definetly will vote when I get home. :D

    Also This reminds me @HazzatheMan do you still want to do that fables thing? We can work on that while this contest is going on, if you want.

  • I thought you were gonna abandon me there bro :D

    Let's do it!

    Nice contest, good job Armis. Definetly will vote when I get home. Also This reminds me @HazzatheMan do you still want to do that fables thing? We can work on that while this contest is going on, if you want.

  • Thanks, I tried my best :)

    Nice contest, good job Armis. Definetly will vote when I get home. Also This reminds me @HazzatheMan do you still want to do that fables thing? We can work on that while this contest is going on, if you want.

  • Hehe, I knew that TJ vs Snow would be hard as hell :P

    HazzatheMan posted: »

    Ok armis; here's my list: * Bloody Mary (How can you hate Bigby!? Plus she tried to kill him... @TheZorkij sorry bro but I gotta stick

    1. Bloody Mary
    2. Beauty
    3. Flytrap (I like them both, but I just like Bufkin more)
    4. Greenleaf
    5. Bluebeard
    6. Hans
    7. Toad
    8. Crane
    9. Tiny Tim
    10. Faith
    11. Georgie
    12. Gren
    13. Grimble
    14. Gwen
    15. Jack
    16. Lilly
    17. Toad Jr.
    18. Dee
  • edited January 2015
    1. Uh шhaт? Bigby vs Bloody Mary??? You must be kidding... Anyways, I'll probably be the only one here to do that, but I have to pick Bigby... I will NEVER vote against Mary, nononono.

    2. Probs Beast, but they both were really annoying, if you ask me.

    3. Bufkin. 'Catcher is easily the most sympathetic character in the entire game.

    4. Aunty Greenleaf. Yes, I understand her reasoning and even feel bad for her in some way, but I simply couldn't stand her attitude, especially on the trial.

    5. Jersey Devil. Sorry, Jersey fans, but I really hate the guy. Besides, Bluebeard is rather charismatic, in my opinion.

    6. Prince Lawrence. Can't say I care about either of them, but I found Lawrence kinda boring, that's all.

    7. Mr. Toad. Goes without saying.

    8. Ichabod Crane. A creep and a corruptionist, nuff said.

    9. Tiny Tim. Literally what @HazzatheMan said.

    10. Faith. She didn't seem that likeable to me, if I'm honest.

    11. Georgie Porgie. He was hilarious, but that still doesn't change the fact that he's also a huge douchebag.

    12. Grendel. That remark about the bar fight, when he accuses Bigby and claims that he "didn't do shit wrong" made me want to punch him so badly.

    13. Grimble. Sleeping while on duty is very irresponsible of him. XD

    14. Gwen. We almost never see her, but Swineheart saved Bigby's life after all, so picking him over a prostitute is just... wrong.

    15. Jack Horner. A no brainer, again.

    16. Lily. Well, Magic Mirror is helpful at least.

    17. Sorry Hazza, but I have to pick Snow White... Her character in the game didn't impress me all that much.

    18. Tweedle Dee. He seemed more of a scum than his brother, imo.

  • edited January 2015
    1. Cannot believe you went with this one first. Gotta say Bloody Mary though. First of all, she was only loyal to the Crooked Man because he allowed her to do whatever she wanted and she was complete psychopath. Bigby could be complete A-hole depending on how you play him but at least he can be compassionate when he needs to. (the game was a good demonstration that he had changed from his old 'Big Bad' days)
    2. I have to go with Beast. Beauty did lie to him but it was because she was ashamed about her line of work (she atleast didn't need to wear those ribbons, thank god) But Beast, when you don't tell him about where Beauty is going, shows his inner monster is still there and he can be jealous but only because he cares. I honestly don't hate either of them but that is just me.
    3. Bufkin. I don't hate either of them but Bufkin can be a fuck-up at times and FlyCatcher is honestly a complete victim in the game (I really felt bad for him when I came AFTER BlueBeard left) and he really is just a sympathetic character that I couldn't bring myself to hate.
    4. Johann. I think its mainly because Aunty Greenleaf redeemed herself somewhat during the trial in Episode 5. Johann I don't hate him really but the fact that he was being so damn evasive when we met him in Episode 4 got annoying to me really fast. Him not saying anything during the trail didn't help either.
    5. Jersey Devil. BlueBeard can be an complete douche but is he also has a mix of charm and aggression. Despite the fact he was being uncooperative, he was also wanted the killer just as much as Bigby and Snow did. Jersey is an asshole and will stay that way. (His final form was badass though)
    6. Hans. I don't hate either of them. But there was more development with Lawrence then Hans and besides the guy may have been pathetic but he was a victim in this game like many. He died in my first playthrough as well so that didn't help. :(
    7. Mr. Toad. Do we really need to go into this? Toad from Episode 1, was a complete and total asshole to even his son TJ when he is angered and complains about virtually anything. Colin had a few moments too but the fact is, he and Bigby are still friends despite their somewhat conflicted past.
    8. Ichabod Crane. Where to start? Ichabod had a few sympathetic moments in Episode 2 and I actually felt he was victim really in Episode 3. However, Ichabod was someone whom I couldn't bring myself to like. He was a coward, he was a liar, and he was bastard for not only lusting after Snow, but he was doing for the Crooked Man and the Fables of FableTown as Deputy Mayor. The Crooked Man may have been the one behind the murders, but he was a gentleman and had a very unique charm that Crane clearly lacked.
    9. Tiny Tim. Cryer was cut out of the plot entirely and Tim was aware of what the Crooked Man was doing and still supported him regardless. Nothing more needs to be said.
    10. Faith. I felt like Nerissa was just a victim in this whole mess because of what Faith had started. Nerissa despite the fact that she had lied about her testimony in the trial, I ultimately think she did the right thing. Faith could be a bitch at times but I never hated her. This decision was based on who I liked less.
    11. Georgie Porgie. I feel like I need to make a comparison here of what Georgie and Vivian were to this story. Think of Georgie like a gun and Vivian as a bullet. Who wields the gun? The Crooked Man. Who ordered the killings of Faith and Lily? The Crooked Man. Georgie was the trigger to that and Vivian may have been the cause but she had no say in the matter. Vivian, like the girls, was a victim and Georgie may have loved her, but the guy was complete bastard to the end.
    12. Grendel. Woody may have been a drunk bastard in Episode 1 but the guy was someone dealing with his own issues and Bigby and him develop a grudging respect for each other. Grendel, from start to finish, was a prick. He still had people he cared about and I don't completely hate him (even though I enjoyed beating the crap out of him in that bar fight) but he had alot of problems.
    13. Grimble. I don't hate Grimble at all, but I felt like Brannigan was a character that I feel like was a cop who wanted answers and she kinda lost them. Literally. Plus Grimble sleeping on the job is never a good thing.
    14. Gwen. I never got to see much of her but Swineheart I can't pick over her because without him, Bigby would be six under right now.
    15. Jack Horner. I always felt bad for Holly after losing Lilly and Jack was never really a character that we could get along with considering he had no complains about stealing from Crane, working with Jersey and giving Holly a hard time. This one is a no-brainer.
    16. Lilly. She got herself into drugs and though she may have been a victim of The Crooked Man, The Magic Mirror was one of the most helpful characters in the game. (plus he is voiced by Gavin Hammon! :D) I don't hate Lilly but this was not an easy choice really.
    17. Snow White. BEFORE you start raging on me, Snow in Episode 3 went alittle too far with wanting to burn Greenleaf's tree down, although Greenleaf was being a pain in the ass, burning her tree, which was her source of income, was little overkill. TJ was just a kid who simply got involved in this whole thing and I don't hate Snow at all here (she is one of my favorite characters in this whole game) but TJ I just can't hate at all.
    18. Tweedle Dee. Guy was the brains of the operation and he clearly was working with the Crooked Man from the start. Dum was complete bastard too but Dee was worse.
  • Thanks for detailed responses :)

    * Cannot believe you went with this one first. Gotta say Bloody Mary though. First of all, she was only loyal to the Crooked Man because he

  • You are very welcome. :D

    armis37 posted: »

    Thanks for detailed responses

  • Grimble. Sleeping while on duty is very irresponsible of him. XD

    He's always asleep at his desk in the comics :P In spite of this, Grimble always knows what's going on around him. A brilliant comment he says to a character that is lying to him in the comics is "People think I don't notice anything, I notice everything!"

    TheZorkij posted: »

    * Uh шhaт? Bigby vs Bloody Mary??? You must be kidding... Anyways, I'll probably be the only one here to do that, but I have to pick Bigby..

  • Well, here is my list:

    1. Wow this was tough and I had to sit back and really think about this. Although I hate doing this to you, Bloody Mary has to be my 1st pick. Bigby was only doing his job and Mary sure loved to push his buttons and have a hand at the power. Love her though. (sorry Mary) :(

    2. Both annoyed me, especially after the 3rd episode but I'll have to go with Beast on this one. He attacked me in the Open Arms because he assumed I was banging his wife. Really? And you won't listen to EITHER of us? Someone needs a shot of Jack Daniels....

    3. Bufkin simply because I can't hate on Flycatcher.

    4. This was tough, too but in the end, Auntie Greenleaf has to take the fall.

    5. Bluebeard Sorry, I hate this guy with every fiber of my being. Jersey at least made me laugh with not only that 70's pornstar look but his douche attitude. Bluebeard made me want to toss my laptop into the air and smash with a hammer.

    6. Hans I don't hate him; he actually helped out with the book thing but that's all I know; I honestly think he had something to do with it but we'll never know....

    7. Toad Nothing more to say.....gobshite prick

    8. Ichabod Crane pissed me off since episode one and after finding out about him and Lily, plus that fantasy about Snow, sorry...the Crooked Man is evil, yes but damn.....at least he seems like he KNOWS he's a dick.

    9. Cryer I can't hate Tim. :)

    10. Oh man....I can't do this but Faith has to take the shot.

    11. Oh no....no, no, no, no....I gotta pick, huh? I'm sorry but Georgie Porgie get's my vote. He and Vivian were indeed being pulled along on strings by the CM but somewhere along the way, one of Georgie's strings snapped and he had a moment of freedom....they were BOTH involved but Georgie had more involvement than Vivian. Sorry, Georgie. I still love ya', though. :)

    12. Sorry @JJwolf but Gren has to take this. I didn't DO anything in the 1st episode....I wanted to glass him, too.

    13. Grimble Wake...up....WAKE UP!!

    14. Gwen all because we have no other information about this girl and Swineheart did a lot more throughout the game

    15. Jack He annoyed me, too

    16. Lily Don't hate either but someone has to fall....

    17. Snow White Before anyone begins tossing the tomatoes as me, I was fin with Snow until the 3rd episode; the way she spoke to me, wanted to burn the tree and talked down to me, I lost what respect I had for her as a gamer.

    18. Dee Wish I could vote for both....

  • Oh, I didn't know that... Well, he's off the hook then. :D

    HazzatheMan posted: »

    Grimble. Sleeping while on duty is very irresponsible of him. XD He's always asleep at his desk in the comics :P In spite of this, G

  • I hate snow white and toad thats about it

  • Wth, Woody vs. Gren, I can't choose. ;_;

    And whoa, why is mirror so hated? :D

  • edited January 2015

    I had a hard time with this one, as I can't say I truly "hate" any characters, but there are some with personalities I would dislike if I came into contact with them. I had to choose Bloody Mary for the first one, even though I think she's a great villain. I guess I hate Beast more because of his temper, but I don't hate either of them. I voted for Flycatcher, mostly because he's not around for very long and I didn't get the chance to learn more about him whereas I find Bufkin entertaining, and wish he had some lines in the comics I'm reading. Johann was my pick for the next one, because he's a spineless pushover. Both Bluebeard and the Jersey Devil are jerks, so that one was a tougher decision, but Bluebeard funds Fabletown and the Jersey Devil barely qualifies as a character as his role is solely that of henchman number four.

    Hans and Lawrence? Neither has much of a role, so I'm neutral on them both, but I voted for Hans anyways. Colin and Toad was a tough one since I love them both, but I like Colin's brand of condescension and pointing out Bigby's past a little bit more, so I voted for Toad. I voted for Ichabod in the next one, since he's also a spineless loser, and at least the Crooked Man gave out loans, even if the interest was high. I was near the fence on the next one as neither is a major character, but I like Tim, so I voted for Cryer. I'm close to neutral on the next one too, but I love Nerissa so I voted for Faith. Georgie got my next vote for obvious reasons. The next one was tough too, but since the Woodsman has the sympathetic side of being down on his luck and Gren didn't get as much development, I voted for Gren. I guess Brannigan gets my vote, but neither is a major character, and I like Grimble's tendency to sleep on the job.

    Gwen's not much of a character either, but I guess Swinehart got my vote, if only because he suggests Bigby should hold back, even though he's just doing his job. Ummm...Jack, I guess? He cons, cheats and steals, so yeah. A character who's never seen alive vs. an awesome take on the magic mirror? Neither deserves hate IMHO, but I'll go with the dead character. Snow is by the book and tries to do her job justly, but that doesn't always make her the most sympathetic and TJ is just a kid, so Snow got my vote even though she's one of my favorite female characters, alongside Nerissa and Bloody Mary(it's so hard to decide between them). I think Dee's the one I had to chase and deal with the most, so he got my vote.

  • Snow White and Toad Jr are tied?

    Alt text

    Alt text

  • I ain't hatin' on ya' pie. He was kind of a dick in the 1st episode. (A sexy prick at that...xD)

    pudding_pie posted: »

    Well, here is my list: * Wow this was tough and I had to sit back and really think about this. Although I hate doing this to you, Blood

    1. Bloody Mary
    2. Beauty
    3. Bufkin
    4. Auntie Greenleaf
    5. Bluebeard
    6. Hans
    7. Toad
    8. Crooked Man
    9. Tim
    10. Faith
    11. Georgie
    12. Gren
    13. Grimble
    14. Gwen
    15. Jack
    16. Magic Mirror
    17. Snow
    18. Dee
  • Gimme round 2!

  • Bump, this will be ending soon enough :)

  • This match is finished, moving on to the 2nd round :) Any votes here after this comment won't be counted.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.