Post Your Episode 4 Choices

2

Comments

  • dojo32161dojo32161 Moderator

    As Golden said it was the opposite for me.

    Yeah I liked him He told Frostfinger that Gared started it and murdered Britt.

  • Welp. I hope revealing Sera's secret won't bite me in the ass. 8D; I've been so kind to Sera best I could so far, it would suck if she hated me because of a mistake on my part.

    TMLC posted: »

    My ignorance of Game of Thrones lore got the best of me, though, because I didn't think the lord would do a whole 180 on his feelings for Sera. Bastards aren't looked highly upon? No, they are kind of not. :P

  • Man… you were kind to her and backed off when it mattered most?!? Cold. :P

    She should not like you much after that. You mostly ruined her best chance for a goo wedding (unless, somehow, he gets back with her I you tell the truth and leave her forever if you lie and he finds it later… can happen).

    fayescarlet posted: »

    Welp. I hope revealing Sera's secret won't bite me in the ass. 8D; I've been so kind to Sera best I could so far, it would suck if she hated me because of a mistake on my part.

    • Brought Finn along.
    • Showed Gryff mercy.
    • Didn't reveal Sera's secret.
    • Left the Glenmores at Ironrath.
    • Let Beskha kill her master
  • I certainly feel bad about it. 8D; Almost enough to redo the episode, but it would break a "live with the choices you make" playstyle I'm trying out, as other people have done. OTL Once all the episodes come out I can fix it, eheh...

    TMLC posted: »

    Man… you were kind to her and backed off when it mattered most?!? Cold. :P She should not like you much after that. You mostly ruined her

  • edited May 2015
    1. Brought Finn - of course.
    2. Showed mercy to Gryff.
    3. Kept Sera's secret - with everything she's done for me, I wouldn't be a good friend if I didn't.
    4. Brought Glenmores to Highpoint.
    5. I didn't let Beshka kill her master - After seeing the preview for episode five, it doesn't look like I'll be getting my army despite all my efforts to "stick to the plan." I regret this decision and will replay this part on another save. Beshka will have her revenge (or justice)!
  • i felt so sorry for him as well, his story and oh man now i want to go back and reply it so it won't be that harsh. He still deserved a beating by Rodrik anyways. I think that Ryon is safe, he would be foolish to start a war, i must say he felt nice to say "fuck you" and an Tyrant

    God, I maimed Gryff and I regret it a lot. He's blind now, and after having heard what Gwyn had to say about Gryff as a kid, I realize that

  • edited May 2015
    • I brought Finn
    • I maimed Gryff
    • I kept her secret
    • I kept the Glenmore soldiers in Ironrath
    • I let Beshka kill her master
  • So, this time... I brought Finn along. Felt like the story would be fun with the three of us paling around in a frozen hell. I maimed Gryff, then reloaded and maimed him again. Then I reloaded, and maimed him until my mother got in the way. Finally, I reloaded and showed him mercy :P He is a bargaining chip, later on I will burn them (Burn them all). I kept Sera's secret. I'd have to just be the worse person to betray Sera after she helped me out twice in quick succession right before i had the chance to spill the beans. Brought the guards to Highpoint (Oh the look on Ludd's stupid face) As a side note, I reloaded the attack order over and over before bluffing Ludd into submission. Arrow to the head you jerk. I killed Beshka's master, which didn't make her or Croft happy. For the minor choices... Royland came to Highpoint (He is my sentinel after all) I kissed Elaena, didn't kill the wilding food thief, and I acted like the most caring person in the world to use the info from Tarwick to get Lyman to talk.

  • edited May 2015
    1. Brought Finn
    2. Showed Gryff mercy (after punching him exactly once. Come on, it had to be done. You'd need inhuman restraint to be Rodrik and not get in one good hit).
    3. I kept Sera's secret. Didn't see any point in revealing it when she helped me. She'll have to make that bed sooner or later anyways because if she really plans on sticking around with Tarwick, the truth will come out eventually. Not my place to tell that truth, though.
    4. I left the Glenmore soldiers in Ironrath. Figured I had protagonist immunity unless Rodrik is meant to die, in which case the choice wouldn't matter and he'd die either way. Might as well leave the men to protect the homestead. Even if it meant nothing, damn Ramsay.
    5. Let Beshka kill her master. I had a feeling Daenerys would screw us anyways and hey, letting Beshka have her revenge was exactly what Daenerys wanted; the slaves of Meereen to dole out justice to those who wronged them. Bing bang boom, it all worked out. I wonder if we'll have a chance to say that to her or if Beshka will step in and say it.
  • What does it take to not encounter Finn? Be super sneaky or something?

  • I can't believe I'm saying this but I actually feel for Gryff if he gets maimed. The way he was talking about how he can't see and then the back story later in the episode is heart breaking. Glad I didn't maim him, though I did get some shots in lol.

  • I brought Finn along. He's good in a fight and surprisingly easy to get along with if you know what to say.

    I showed Gryff mercy. I hit him once, but through a combination of being a bit of a softy personally, realizing that he's more valuable as an un-maimed hostage, and accidentally right-clicking, I let him go with only one punch.

    I kept Sera's secret. It's going to turn out badly for Tarwick, but Mira is going to have to lie a bit more to undo some of the horrendous fucking-up that's been going on in King's Landing.

    I brought the soldiers to Highpoint. I sure as hell don't trust Ludd.

    I stopped Beshka from killing her slave master. Asher really, REALLY needs Khaleesi on his side, and disobeying both her orders and the orders of one of her commanders is not going to turn out well.

    On a more minor note, I shot the Wildling running away because she had our food. Yes, she was no longer a threat, but I didn't want to starve to death.

  • I brought Finn along. He's good in a fight, and getting along with him is rather easy if you know what to say.

    I showed Gryff mercy. I hit him once, but through a combination of being a bit of a softy personally, realizing that he's more valuable as an un-maimed hostage, and accidentally right-clicking, I let him go with only one punch.

    I kept Sera's secret. It's going to turn out badly for Tarwick, but Mira is going to have to lie a bit more to undo some of the horrendous fucking-up that's been going on in King's Landing.

    I brought the soldiers to Highpoint. I sure as hell don't trust Ludd.

    I stopped Beshka from killing her slave master. Asher really, REALLY needs Khaleesi on his side, and disobeying both her orders and the orders of one of her commanders is not going to turn out well.

    On a more minor note, I shot the Wildling running away because she had our food. Yes, she was no longer a threat, but I didn't want to starve to death.

  • edited May 2015

    I hope they got my future wife out of there.. NO MORE LOVE INTEREST DEATHS!!

    telltale characters need love too.. serious face (speaking from past games) Lol.

    If they even saved just 1 person on their retreat leaving them was a good thing. cause i totally enjoyed talking shit to ludd absent any backup with all his soldiers behind him, and calling his bluff :D

    1 concern from that though.. May the gods help rhyon if ramsay got hold of gryff.. Seeing how i let that slide in convo whilst calling his bluff.. oooo o.O

    P.S. I hope they killed a lot of Ramsay's men..

    Poogers555 posted: »

    Yikes, that doesnt sound good, then again, where is literally everyone?

  • I brought Finn. (Well, he looks like a good friend!)

    I maimed Gryff. (Was waiting to do this. 100% chance that i would do it again.)

    I kept Sera's secret. (Keeping her secret would allow me to blackmail her later. I don't like her anyway. :/)

    I bought the soldiers with me. (My plan was to kill everybody in there and leave with my brother. :/ But it was good, if people is saying that they disappear.)

    I killed the slave master. (Wow, nobody did that? I didn't wanted to stop her because the master really deserved it, but didn't wanted to fuck everything with Khaleesi, so i thought doing it myself would please both. Kinda backfired. No one was happy. lol)

  • I didn't hit Gryff once. Listened to his babbling, realized he's child trying to play Lord and hitting him will do nothing, spat on him and turned my back to his cries. If he wants being beaten so badly, he can go to his older brothers for all I care, and I don't want to give Whitehill any reason to maim MY brother Ryon.

    Rynna posted: »

    * Brought Finn * Showed Gryff mercy (after punching him exactly once. Come on, it had to be done. You'd need inhuman restraint to be Rodrik

  • Being enemies\not friends with him. I think.

    gray6 posted: »

    What does it take to not encounter Finn? Be super sneaky or something?

    • Brought Finn
    • Maimed Gryff
    • Kept Sera's secret
    • Told guards to stay at Ironrath
    • Let Beskha kill her master

    Telltale Account Choices

    • Brought Royland to Highpoint (not my Sentinel)
    • Kissed Elaena (who wouldn't?)
    • Did not kill the wildling food thief
    • Used sympathy to get Lyman to talk
  • -Brought Finn.
    -Showed Gryff mercy.
    -Kept Sera's Secret.
    -Brought the Glenmores to Highpoint.
    -Killed the slave master myself.

    ClemRanger posted: »

    * Brought Finn * Maimed Gryff * Kept Sera's secret * Told guards to stay at Ironrath * Let Beskha kill her master Telltale Account C

  • Brought Finn along. Probably wouldn't have if he hadn't stood up to Frostfinger for me, but he did and was in trouble for it. He wants to desert alongside me, let him. Besides, having a big tough guy like Finn could come in handy on the other side of the Wall- even as a meatbag.

    Didn't maim Gryff. That would be against the Rodrik I'm roleplaying, who is far too proud and honorable to beat a guy held by two other men. Mess Gryff up in a fair fight- I'm all up for it But I'm not going down to his level by beating up people who can't fight back.

    I kept Sera's secret. As far as I care, that's on her, not me. Truth will out eventually, if they do get married, and if she does want to marry a man based on a lie, who am I to stop her? Her lies, her responsibility. I just wish there was an option to tell a smarter lie, which would have been retelling what Sera supposedly told ME about her family, as opposed to pretending that I've met her. In that case, when the truth is found out, I can absolve myself off all responsibility, since it's entirely possible that Sera simply lied to me as well. Bad move, Mira, bad move. But this is simply the game causing us to choose one of two absolutes, and not a smarter, middle decision, that an intelligent person would think of. I'll just write it off as Mira not being cunning enough.

    I brought the Glenmore guard with me. Another silly absolute decision. Why can't I split the men 50/50, keeping some in Ironrath and some coming with me as my personal escort? Besides, if you do bring them along, you don't actually get to bring the whole guard into Ludd's keep, only, like, 5 or 6 of 'em. When there were, what, 20 to begin with? Either way, not like they protect Ironrath worth shit if you leave them. A poorly implemented choice, from a gameplay perspective.

    Lastly, I let Beshka kill her master. The slaves were going to kill the masters anyway, what the fuck does it matter if we kill one along the way? And in the trailer, it shows Daenerys spouting bullshit like "the justice was for the slaves to deliver, not you". Well, how's a former slave dispensing "justice" sound? Glad to see the "mhysa" is just as much of a hypocritical idiot as she is on the show. Captured the character brilliantly, Telltale, well done on that.

    • Didn't encounter Finn.
    • Didn't maim Gryff.
    • Kept Sera's secret.
    • Left the Glenmores at Ironrath.
    • Stopped Beskha from killing slave master.

    That's for my main playthrough. Reverse them for my secondary.

  • I tried playing episode 4 with random choices in my third save, Finn for some reason witnesses against me and I don't meet him when escaping, so I guess that you have to be a real asshole to him the whole time so to not meet him. This is also a proof that some dialogue choices actually matter.

    Gapaot posted: »

    Being enemies\not friends with him. I think.

  • edited May 2015

    Brought Finn along. He told the truth about what happened with Britt, so I owe him for that.

    Showed mercy to Gryff. I will not let our enemies dictate our behaviour, Rodrick will not stoop to their level of barbarity.

    Kept Sera's secret. Again, she did me a favour so I returned it.

    Ordered the soldiers to remain at Ironrath. Figured they'd be massively outnumbered at Highpoint anyway, whereas Ironrath would be defensible. Figured wrong.

    Stopped Beshka from killing the master. Didn't want the mission to be all for naught if Croft tells Dany that we disobeyed his orders.

  • So does anyone know if you can mess up in the final meereen part? Can the guards start the fire?

    Also I know there is a game over but can you mess up at the whitehills can ryan get hurt

    Also what does eleana do if you didnt win her trust and what does ryon do if you dont kiss the ring? Do they act any different

    • Didn't Encounter Finn
    • Showed Gryff mercy (gave him one good right hook, told him he's lucky he didn't get worse. For now, anyway)
    • Told Lord Tarwick Sera's secret (taking the chance she won't find out I was the one who spilled the beans)
    • Kept the soldiers at Ironwrath (brought Royland with me, figured it might be enough)
    • Let Beskha kill the Slave Master
  • Sorry for my english:

    • I brought Finn along - he stood up for me and I like him, to be honest. He's my buddy as well as Cotter.. I think.
    • I showed mercy to Gryff - I didn't even know I made a choice. I wanted to hit him 3 times and then leave him be, but the game decided for me somehow. But I'm good with it, I didn't want to hurt him too much. I split on him of course.
    • I kept Sera's secret - I usually don't do things like this.. but I didn't help her when she asked me to and she still helped me after that. She said I owe her.. I think we're even now. :P
    • I took Glenmore soldiers with me to Highpoint - I almost left them at Ironrath, because I was too slow with my answer, so my Sentinel made the choice for me. I thought that I can't always put myself in danger, besides Ser Royland told me that his men are strong enough to hold Ironrath while we're gone. I figured they'll have better chances with him, so I brought Duncan with me. I called Whitehill's bluff.
    • I let Beskha kill the Slave Master - I was thinking about killing him myself, but that was not what Beskha wanted. She wanted "justice". I let her kill him so she could focus on our damn mission.

    Well, that's it. Again, sorry for my bad english, it's not my native language. Can't wait for episode 5 though. I still want to know who's the traitor - Maester or (more likely) Mother.

  • edited May 2015
    • I brought Finn along, cause he did tell the truth about what happened.
    • I did not maimed Gryff, I hoped that it'd be easier for us to strike a deal if he is not harmed...but now that Ramsay freaking Snow is in the mix...arrgh.
    • I kept Sera's secret, at least it seemed like I get the info and still keep Sera as sort of ally...for now.
    • I left the soldiers at Ironrath
    • Let Beshka kill the master, I don't understand Daenerys' logic in the preview, saying justice should be left in the hands of people of Meereen, or something like that. Beshka was one of the Meereen, I think it's fair for her to revenge. I guess Mother of Dragon is gonna keep her army anyway...
  • Hmmm hope these don't burn me later.

    Alt text

  • Sure they make you feel bad about maiming Gryff. But don't forget he was beating the SHIT out of the maester. He beat the shit out of you and he pushes talia to the ground and makes fun of Ethans death. He's a little bitch fourthborn who needed to be taught a lesson. (I do feel a little bad for him obviously....but my family comes first!)

    God, I maimed Gryff and I regret it a lot. He's blind now, and after having heard what Gwyn had to say about Gryff as a kid, I realize that

  • I even punched him two times and it still said I showed mercy :D

    Sméagol posted: »

    Just wanted to point out you can still punch Gryff, without going to far. I "showed mercy", but I punched him exactly once.

  • For the first time in my telltale gaming history I feel happy with my choices and feel like I made the best decisions given the situations.

    **I brought Finn along with me **- I did everything in my power to not kill Britt, and Finn stuck up for me.

    **I didn't lay a finger on Gryff **- He's a sniveling child, but I still feel sympathetic to his character. I refused to stoop to his level, and when I called Ludd's bluff I felt even better about not hurting Gryff. Ludd's still going to be a douche, but at least he can't try and make me feel bad for mistreating his son.

    **I kept Sera's secret **- She got me into the party and she distracted Margaery, so it was the least I could do.

    **I ordered the Glenmore soldiers to stay in Ironrath **- I figured taking them to Highpoint with me would be seen as an act of aggression. I was hoping to negotiate a truce with Ludd.

    **I let Beskha murder her old slave master **- She didn't want to go into the city to begin with. After telling me her story I figured she'd earned the right to carry out her own justice since he made her kill other children.

  • loveyoucarleyloveyoucarley Banned
    edited May 2015
    1. Brought Finn.

    2. Showed mercy to Gryff.

    3. Kept her secret. (I don't know what kind of a person with some decency would rat her out)1.

    4. Soldiers remained at Ironrath.

    5. I killed the master.

  • edited May 2015

    You and 8% didn't encounter fin.
    I couldn't bring Finn. I pissed him of so bad in the last episodes he accused me of murder. So I had no option here really.

    I and 62% maimed Gryff (hell yeah!!)

    I and 85% kept Sara's secret

    I and 29% ordered the soldiers to Highpoint (kept them alive that way)

    I and 39% stopped Beshka

    You and 49.9% brought Royland to Highpoint.

    You and 93.2% kissed Elaena.

    You and 80.9% did not kill the Wildling food thief. (I hoped to aim better!!)

    You and 63.4% revealed Lord Andros' betrayal to make Lyman talk.

    serlX posted: »

    Hmmm hope these don't burn me later.

  • edited June 2015

    image

    Me And 90.7% Brought Finn Along.

    Me And 38.4% Showed Mercy To Gryff (Punched Him 3 Times Then Stopped)

    Me And 14.7% Revealed Sera's Secret To Lord Tarwick

    Me And 29% Ordered The Glenmore Soldiers To Come To Hightpoint

    Me And 35.8% Killed The Slave Master

  • I have a horrible feeling the maester is trying to screw me over, so it didn't bother me he was being beaten. Could have set the whole thing up to force my hand.

    Wigams posted: »

    Sure they make you feel bad about maiming Gryff. But don't forget he was beating the SHIT out of the maester. He beat the shit out of you

Sign in to comment in this discussion.