The choices where the plot makes the most sense

I always have fun playing my second playthrough making the choices where the plot makes the most sense.

Mira ends up in jail and accused of murder, so it makes most sense that:
-She kills the guard
-She keeps the knife
-She is nice to Sera until the very last moment when she backstabs her (nice last episode plot twist)
-She asks Margery for help

Any opinions on the other characters?

The Sentinel treason makes more sense (in my opinion) if Royland is the Sentinel and Malcolm betrays the family to ensure not getting attacked.

Comments

  • edited November 2015

    Roderik lives and Asher dies.

    Asher came to Westeros knowing he was going to die. Essos was a place he was thriving and living but he had to come back for his family. Asher had no one waiting for him but his family but Roderik was the Lord and had Lady Glenmore.

    Asher knew his brother had someone who loved him and would carry on the family name.

    It was right he die for his house.

    Roderik went after Ludd because he did his duty. He wouldn't let emotions get in the way of his duty the same way Asher would.

  • Duncan makes zero sense as the traitor so Sentinel needs to be Duncan . I feel like so much of Mira's story amounted to nothing . asking for help or not from Margery,The key , The seal, The decree,The friendship with Cersi . Staying as Margery's hand maiden or getting dismissed. Keeping the knife or not, The army Ludd was supposed to get he got anyway it appeared. The people Tom was working for. Same with Gared and Malcolm. I thought either the north grove or a dragon would save our house but nope just some bastards and you don't see Malcolm or hear from him at all in ep 6.

    It makes more sense I guess to let Rodrik kill Ludd according to the rules set forth by Roose, but personally I did not just spend the entire game getting Asher home only to let him die. Lady Forrester dies no matter what . Ryon lives no matter what the pit fighters all die.

  • I actualy felt Royland made no sense as traitor, but whatever, both of them are ridiculous.

  • I agree. I kept thinking that it was going to be the Maester.

    I actualy felt Royland made no sense as traitor, but whatever, both of them are ridiculous.

  • edited November 2015

    I'll agree that neither made sense but more so Duncan the one who sent his nephew to certain death to find the North grove . Gregor's most trusted man . I thought the Maester or Lady Forrester made most sense or even Malcom who IMO is responsible for Lady Forrester's death by abandoning her during the siege.

    I actualy felt Royland made no sense as traitor, but whatever, both of them are ridiculous.

  • The plot that makes sense: Mira doing run around errands to end up dead.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.