Regrettable decisions
The title kinda says it, but are there any decisions you wish you didn't make?
I personally regret kissing Ludd's ring... Just didn't feel like the Rodrik I wanted, but oh well.
I apologize if this discussion already exists.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
I regret leaving Tom to Damien.
I regret not killing Duncan. Now I'm stuck with him and Royland's dead.
And worst of all is that sentinel's survival is based on whether you killed the traitor or not, which doesn't make sense.
My only regret is telling the maester and lady forrester about the north grove, and i pressed that one on mistake. (I found out that rewinding was possible after I had finished episode 2) But hey, on my save everyone who knows about it is now dead except Gared and Rodrik
I regret betraying Sera. It was one of those choices I really hated myself for.
I am pretty conflicted about marching south to Ironrath. The North Grove didn't seem as well defended as I hoped, and I mostly believe Gregor wanted us to find it so that the bastards weren't lost not necessarily the grove itself. Although I realize that now the Forresters have no home at all, neither Ironrath or North Grove. I hope this works out.
Pre-ordering the game.
Not promising Sera that I would keep her secret (even though I didn't told it to Tarwick), lying to Margaery and get Sera dismissed, marrying Mira to Morgryn and bringing Finn with me.
Wat?
Saving Asher. I like him, but his dishonored actions made me feel like Forresters deserved the defeat.
I meant Sera. Sorry...
I'm guessing he's talking about the Sera choice in Episode 6.
The first thing that came to my mind
Yeah, yeah. My bad
I have no regrets.
Well, you can call off the plan, so...
Letting Elaena stay, and I guess leaving the North Grove.
I thought of The Walking Dead Game at first, haha.
Not hitting Morgryn harder with the torch!
Seriously though, I think leaving the North Grove. I think I will change that.
Me too
But the scene is too badass to change
It does not matter, House Forrester has no honor if Asher survives.
You think they wouldn't do that if they had the option in Rodrik's part of the story?
I regret pretending loyalty to Joffrey over Margaery. She somehow decides to take offense even though it was exactly what she asked me to do and the only thing that would get the queen off her back, but staying in good stead with her is more important than keeping Cercei happy, at least come season 2, and I wish I'd made more of an effort.
I also regret going after Gryff instead of Ludd. Killing Gryff gets the Forresters exactly nowhere in the power struggle, whereas killing Ludd might make a difference in the future.
I don't regret killing Cotter painfully for the undead soldiers, that was a no-brainer, but I do wish Gared had thought to throw a blanket over his massacred chest before presenting him to his sister. Could've made that a win-win situation just by being a little more sensitive.
Rodrik almost died because Freys did that.
But that's the game's own fault, not Asher's. They should've given you the option to (really) accept Ludd's deal, to try to fool Ludd (the canon one) or just tell him to fuck of (and that would've followed the same path Rodrik's plot did).
Same as the OP. Kinda regret kissing the ring. But I know it amounts to nothing now since Rodrik is dead.
I regret not taking the Glenmores with Rodrik to Highpoint.
I kinda regret not having Rodrik tell Elaena to go home. It just... y'know... would have been a completely dickish thing to say, even if I have been made aware that not doing so could get her raped and brutalised.
I sorta regret not being honest with Tyrion in the dungeon... but I thought that he might have had the wits to understand that the guard is listening to everything Mira is saying. Damned petty, stupid depiction of Tyrion. Did he honestly expect her to be completely honest with him when she had been explicitly told not to? Still whatever. If there are no consequences for being honest, I'd rather have done so. Telling such transparent lies bothers me.
But most of all... I regret that there was no viable option to kill Ramsay Snow the few times when it would have been entirely plausible (but for his plot-armour). Even that point with the knife to his throat. Imagine how easy it would have been at that point to jab ANOTHER knife in his stomach. If only Rodrik had the wits to bring it with him (y'know, since he brought it to his death-scene later with Asher).
I also sorta regret that Mira had to outright lie about Sera (so obvious), rather than telling a half-truth and blaming it on her alcoholism. There should have been an option to say Sera was completely wasted and dragged Mira to the party in a fit of drunken incompetence.
[Edit]: I'm also kinda bothered that Mira is so antagonistic towards Morgryn... and to some extent that he is absolutely set on being a maximum cunt about everything since his "big reveal". Mira just keeps scowling, and though I'm trying to go along with whatever he wants, even the closest option to that always involves Mira being reluctant and Morgryn trying to be even more malevolent. The whole thing would play out quite differently if I was in free reign of Mira's actions rather than picking from a selection of exclusively crappy choices.
I know but whether we like it or not, Asher decide for US. Saving him for that to happen was not good
I don't really regret anything. I'm not sorry for leaving Bowen because he was too dang slow on the uptake and my duty was to protect my lord, I told Sera's secret and lied to Margaery to get her dismissed because girl was on my shiiiiiet list, I respected Elaena and her spirit too much to tell her what to do so yeah she was dragged away, and I don't even regret cutting Cotter's heart out even though I was sorry for how much that had to hurt. If I was to pick one thing I wish I could change it would be telling Talia to act as lord while Rodrik was at Highpoint. I mean Ramsay came in and muffed up their shiznit and killed poor Arthur so what if she takes that personally and feels responsible for all of it?
Poor girl.
No. No regrets!
Saving Malcolm instead of beskha. Truly regretful. The look and dialogue that comes out of this from beskha makes it seems that Asher doesn't care for her.
Kissing Ludd's Ring
None of the choices were regrettable