Hardest choice?

TaleTellFan

What choice was the hardest one? The one where you didn't know what to do. Where you waited forever before you could decide, or if you had a limited amount of time, just had to go by pure instinct. Whereas the Asher/Rodrik choice was hard because It's tough to click on the one you're going to leave behind, the one I had the toughest time deciding on was whether or not to use Cotter for bloodmagic. I'd like to hear your thoughts.

I_Am_The_Traitor

Royal or Duncan for sentinel. They were made hard because of the arguments made by each person you visit before deciding and I spent a while thinking on what each person said. If your wondering, I chose Royland in the end.

MetallicaRules

Probably choosing whether to use Cotter for the blood magic ritual or not.

Lewsblake23

Whether to accept the marriage proposal with Mira or not.

First time I actually paused the game when making a choice.

Kateis

Choosing to stay or leave The North Grove. It took me over a minute to decide.

With a close second and third being the Poison or Ambush and Butchering Cotter or not. They both took me 50 seconds to decide.

AronDracula

Rodrik or Asher, Duncan or Royland as sentinel and poison or butch Cotter.

A-IBRAHIM0702

1.

(I chose Duncan)

2.

(My Rodrik stayed behind)

3.

(I TRIED to poison Ludd)

TheAutisticGamer

1.

(I made Rodrik stay)

2.

(I chose Royland)

3.

(I originally spared him, but then I went back and killed him to NOT piss off Talia, AND to save Royland)

kurishioo

• Choosing life but, downside, being a baby making slave for Morgryn or dying with honor (Mira)
• Choosing Rodrik or Asher to live
• Choosing whether to kill Ludd or Gryff
• Choosing whether to use Cotter for the blood ritual or let him die peacefully
• Choosing to be loyal to the King or Margaery (I didn't want to get on Cersei's bad side but I didn't want to humiliate Margaery either)

Bluebirdo

Hmm, depends on the definition of "hardest" I guess.

Made me feel the worst while picking and afterward: Accepting the marriage proposal knowing it meant Tom's execution.

Made me pause the longest because I was torn between the two: Choosing Rodrik over Asher, and Asher was my favorite playable character, nay, one of my favorite characters. But House Forrester needed their lord...

RhysAndLee

• Choosing Royland or Duncan. (I ended up choosing Royland.)
• Choosing if Rodrik or Asher perishes. (I left Asher. I miss his grin.)
• Giving Cotter a peaceful death or RIPPING HIS HEART OUT (I chose peaceful death.)
• Killing Ludd or Gryff (As Rodrik) (I chose murdering Gryff, to get Ryon.)
• (And during my opposite choice Asher...) Poison or Ambush Ludd. (I chose Poison.)
• Stopping Lady Forrester from poisoning herself or not. (I actually never made a choice. I ran out of time before I could make a choice.)
• Helping Beskha or Malcom. (I helped Malcom, mainly because of panic.)

MrEggplant

What is happening when you don't decide when lady forrester is trying to poison herself?

ed1190

The longest choice that I recall was definitely the sentinel one. It honestly took me a long while to decide.

Also, letting Ethan decide the punishment for the guy that tried to steal also took me a while.

RhysAndLee

The same thing as letting her poison herself I think.

MrEggplant

oh, ok