Which performances in movies did you like better?

  • Batman: Michael Keaton, Christian Bale or Ben Affleck?
  • Alfred: Michael Caine or Michael Gough?
  • Commissioner Gordon: Gary Oldman or Pat Hingle?
  • Joker: Jack Nicholson or Heath Ledger?
  • Catwoman: Michelle Pfeiffer?
  • Two-Face: Aaron Eckhart or Tommy Lee Jones?
  • Bane: Tom Hardy or Jeep Swenson?

Comments

  • CathalOHaraCathalOHara Moderator
    edited May 2016
    1. Batman: Michael Keaton > Ben Affleck >>>>> Christian Bale
    2. Alfred: Jeremy Irons > Ian Abercrombie > Michael Caine
    3. Gordon: Gary Oldman > Pat Hingle
    4. Joker: Heath Ledger > Jack Nicholson
    5. Catwoman: Michelle Pfeiffer > Anne Hathaway
    6. Two-Face: Aaron Eckhart
    7. Bane: I honestly have never liked how Bane has been done in film.
    • Batman- Michael Keaton.
    • Alfred- Jeremy Irons.
    • Commissioner Gordon- Gary Oldman.
    • The Joker- Jack Nicholson.
    • Catwoman- Michelle Pfeiffer.
    • Two-Face- Aaron Eckhart.
    • Bane- Tom Hardy, although like Cathal, I've yet to see a Bane portrayal do the character justice.
  • heath nuff said nuff said

  • Both Joker's were great. I don't dislike either one.

    Keaton and Pfeiffer all the way.

  • michelle is a goddess

    Johro posted: »

    Both Joker's were great. I don't dislike either one. Keaton and Pfeiffer all the way.

    • Batman: Ben Affleck
    • Alfred: Michael Caine
    • Commissioner Gordon: Gary Oldman
    • Joker: Heath Ledger, but i cant wait to see Jared Leto
  • Affleck, Jeffrey Irons, Oldham, Ledger, Hathaway, Neither ( 2 Face) is a bad villain to portray in live action, Hardy.

  • edited June 2016
    • Batman: Ben Affleck. I sincerely believe that Ben's version of Batman has the potential to be the best of his predecessors.
    • Alfred: Michael Caine
    • Commissioner Gordon: Gary Oldman
    • Joker: Heath Ledger?
    • Two-Face: Aaron Eckhart
    • Bane: Tom Hardy
  • edited June 2016

    I think Ben Affleck was the best Batman. He seemed to be the most human. Unlike Bale, Affleck's Batman was clearly suffering from Shell Shock, (AKA Post Traumatic Stress disorder ), as a result of seeing his parents killed right in front of him.

    I think Gary Oldman is the best actor to have ever played Jim Gordan. His Jim Gordan was very down to earth, and aside from his training in law enforcement, he seemed like an average Joe who was trying to do his job to the best of his ability, and who was working with what he had.

    I think that Michael Cain was the best Alfred. He exuded a real warmth to his character. He seemed more of a father figure to Bruce Wayne, than Jeremy Iron's did.

    As far as the Joker - Heath Ledger. That man was pure evil. If the Devil were to ever take human form, and walk among us, Ledger's Joker is one of the forms he would take.

    As far as Catwoman: I think that Ann Hathaway did a very nice job.

    As far as Two Face: I loved Tommy-Lee Jones version of the character in Batman Forever. But for a more tortured soul, I'd go with Aaron Eckhart.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.