Wink to the Cartoon?

I doubt their meant to be the same character, but in the episode of the Cartoon series from the 90s, where Doc and Marty go back in time to the civil war to rescue Verne, the Tannen in that episode was named Beauregard Tannen. I wonder if his character was meant to be a small *wink* to fans who watched the cartoon series.

Comments

  • It seemed that while they didnt consider the series canon, they did acknowledge it where possible. I could have swore I already knew Georges fathers name was Arthur before the game.
  • edited June 2011
    It seemed that while they didnt consider the series canon, they did acknowledge it where possible. I could have swore I already knew Georges fathers name was Arthur before the game.

    Yeah same here, and I never watched the cartoon series.
  • edited June 2011
    I think Arthur was mentioned in an early script draft or the novelization of part 1...perhaps both, but I remember hearing that name somewhere as well. I was waiting for someone to say "Sarah Lathrop" when Emmett and judge Brown mentioned Doc's mom
  • edited June 2011
    I thought the name Bouregard Tannen sounded familiar. Also, suddenly Doc and Clara have a home in 1986. While I don't consider the cartoon to be canon, the ending seems to set the stage for it.

    Then again, Bob Gale says this isn't canon either. Personally, with all due respect to awesome Bob, I don't really see the point of that. It's kind of like how there's actually two Star Wars universes, one that just contains the movies and one that contains everything. If the latter has the same stuff as the first one AND more, then why have two universes? It's the same thing here. In my head at least, this IS BttF 4.
  • edited June 2011
    They also kept the trait of Verne liking video games.

    IMO, I think the game is a little too cartoon-y to really be considered canon. I mean, where does Marty carry his extensive inventory when walking around?
  • edited June 2011
    Where the sun don't shine
  • edited June 2011
    bttf4444 wrote: »
    They also kept the trait of Verne liking video games.

    IMO, I think the game is a little too cartoon-y to really be considered canon. I mean, where does Marty carry his extensive inventory when walking around?

    Well, where does Max keep his inventory?

    Granted, Marty's continuous inventory is fairly small. Things like the tire iron and hoverboard are limited to the scenes you find them in.
  • edited June 2011
    can i has a link to bob gale saying this is non cannon? so far i have been considering this game cannon.
  • edited June 2011
    bttf4444 wrote: »
    They also kept the trait of Verne liking video games.

    IMO, I think the game is a little too cartoon-y to really be considered canon. I mean, where does Marty carry his extensive inventory when walking around?

    Where do any video game characters keep their respective extensive inventories? I mean, just look at Link from The Legend of Zelda.
  • edited June 2011
    ELB1985 wrote: »
    can i has a link to bob gale saying this is non cannon? so far i have been considering this game cannon.

    http://www.webcitation.org/5vIJAusGZ
    Only the movies are canon. Everything else fits into the 'what-if?' category, or might be canon in some alternate universe.

    Actually, this one says it better.
    It's a different medium, and for the fans who wonder whether it's canon or not canon, I would say no -- let's not call it canon. Let's just say it's like taking an existing melody and doing our own riff on it.
  • edited June 2011
    bttf4444 wrote: »
    They also kept the trait of Verne liking video games.

    IMO, I think the game is a little too cartoon-y to really be considered canon. I mean, where does Marty carry his extensive inventory when walking around?


    Psh, I played a Point and click series where the hero has put a ladder, a tall metal pole, and a plank taller than he is in his pants.

    As the narrator says, he must have plenty of room in there.
  • edited June 2011
    Any question on canon is pretty irrelevant. Canon only matters inasmuch as future works will abide by the claims made in the earlier work. Since there will be no future Back to the Future movies, this is never going to be put to the test one way or the other.
  • edited June 2011
    Nekoai-kun wrote: »
    Psh, I played a Point and click series where the hero has put a ladder, a tall metal pole, and a plank taller than he is in his pants.

    As the narrator says, he must have plenty of room in there.

    A series I hope to see Telltale revive after King's Quest!
  • edited June 2011
    Where do any video game characters keep their respective extensive inventories? I mean, just look at Link from The Legend of Zelda.

    Who cares what other games do. This is essentially a continuation of a movie series that grounded its characters and situations in realism, even though it was sci-fi. And they turned it into a goofy cartoon.
  • FloFlo
    edited June 2011
    I think Gale's responses are a bit evasive. Neither he nor Zemeckis actively wrote for the cartoon or any of the games, so of course they would consider their own work to be derivative, or, as Gale himself puts it "re-imaginations".

    It's a credit to Telltale that they brought him in at all. Looking at past adaptations of Universal properties, it's obvious that they are (or were) not particularly concerned with staying true to the source material.

    I'd put it down to "writer's pride" that, despite his involvement, he doesn't want to acknowledge the game as canon. It leaves the (albeit unlikely) option open for sequels that don't have to incorporate or even acknowledge the game's story.
  • edited June 2011
    Flo wrote: »
    I'd put it down to "writer's pride" that, despite his involvement, he doesn't want to acknowledge the game as canon. It leaves the (albeit unlikely) option open for sequels that don't have to incorporate or even acknowledge the game's story.

    I think it would be interesting to have some other gaming companies tackle BTTF. They wouldn't be able to include anything from Telltale games, due to copyright restrictions.
  • edited June 2011
    Then again, Bob Gale says this isn't canon either. Personally, with all due respect to awesome Bob, I don't really see the point of that. It's kind of like how there's actually two Star Wars universes, one that just contains the movies and one that contains everything. If the latter has the same stuff as the first one AND more, then why have two universes? It's the same thing here. In my head at least, this IS BttF 4.

    Because later star-wars films and tv shows dont have to obay everything in the expanded universe cannon.

    Cannon flows from films>>other mediums, but not visa-versa if you like.

    That said, Lucas did include some expanded universe stuff in the prequals, but he got to pick-and-choose stuff, rather then needing to obay it all.
    (even if that was possible, with about a bazzlion books, how could he hope to even have read them all ? :P)
  • edited June 2011
    Wasn't Beaurgaurd Tannen briefly mentioned in the 3rd film in relation to buford tannen?
    Or atleast in the BTS stuff on the bluray.

    Beaurguard sounded familar to me atleast and I only know the films, so did Arthur Mcfly; fairly sure in one of the films George mentions his fathers name or mentioned martys grandfathers name
  • edited July 2011
    Emo Hoe wrote: »
    Wasn't Beaurgaurd Tannen briefly mentioned in the 3rd film in relation to buford tannen?
    Or atleast in the BTS stuff on the bluray.

    Beaurguard sounded familar to me atleast and I only know the films, so did Arthur Mcfly; fairly sure in one of the films George mentions his fathers name or mentioned martys grandfathers name

    Nope neither were mentioned.
  • Emo Hoe wrote: »
    Wasn't Beaurgaurd Tannen briefly mentioned in the 3rd film in relation to buford tannen?
    Or atleast in the BTS stuff on the bluray.

    Beaurguard sounded familar to me atleast and I only know the films, so did Arthur Mcfly; fairly sure in one of the films George mentions his fathers name or mentioned martys grandfathers name

    The only tannens or mcfly's who are mentioned but not seen in the trilogy are gertrude tannen (Biffs grandmother) and the 'other' Martin McFly.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.