›

Case 4. Hmmm.

PlatypussPlatypuss
edited October 2007 in CSI: Gaming Discussion
Didn't like this one bit - seemed far too artificial and staged. I can think of two primary reasons why this seemed illogical, and I'm sure there are more:

Why did the wheely-bin with tape suddenly appear outside the house later?

In real life the left-handed/right-handed assailant evidence would have been decided straight after processing the crime scene - it was horribly manufactured to leave the reveal right until the end.

Hoping that Case 5 is more realistic.

Comments

  • DesignerGregDesignerGreg
    edited October 2007
    The trash bin was logical - The left/right hand - I would call it a more "artistic" use of logic - we all miss important details sometimes. Here's a brief explanation!
    The wife wheeled out the bin in order to get rid of some evidence. She apologizes for it, but it's clear later that she was covering up many of her actions.

    As you noticed, most real CSI's would indeed have decided the left/right handedness first. But notice how before the reveal Grissom says "even the best of us miss important details sometimes." So it made a slightly more dramatic story to have that key evidence come out later. I guess it didn't work for you. Good catch on the artistic use of logic.
  • LenyLeny
    edited October 2007
    About the left/right hand: how can a blind woman solve a crossword?? It should have been more logical when the daughter had solved it right handed....
  • MarkDarinMarkDarin Former Telltale Staff
    edited October 2007
    Leny wrote: »
    About the left/right hand: how can a blind woman solve a crossword?? It should have been more logical when the daughter had solved it right handed....

    Exactly! How can a blind woman do a crossword?
    But the evidence clearly indicates that she did indeed do a crosswrod puzzle. She uses her blindness as an alibi, but in fact she is exagerating her condition. The evidence however, never lies.
  • Blotched BloggerBlotched Blogger
    edited October 2007
    sigh...
  • davech1987davech1987
    edited October 2007
    Tee women was not 100% blind she could make ou things with light and dark senses and see but very very poorly i noticed alot of people dislike this case due to it not making sense about the womens blindness personally i really like this case it is one of my favs in the game and the end was really cool also
Sign in to comment in this discussion.