What if Faith is the killer?

I know I know, that can't be, Faith was the first victim. but in the land of glamour and mysticism, quite literally everything is possible. maybe she needed Lilly dead, so in order to make it seem plausible she first staged her own death, then had Lilly killed to make it seem like there was a serial killer. yes, I know, it seems unlikely. But as time goes on it seems more and more likely to me. maybe I'm just crazy. I guess we'll find out.

Comments

  • edited April 2014

    It pretty hollow but in this world it's plausible.

  • it's obv it'sthe crooked man hiring crooks like bloody marry and 'the butcher' to go kill others.

    We already know he decapitates, since marry was about to chop off bigby's head with an axe like faith's.

  • I figured Crane wasn't the killer. Its obvious that he wouldn't go around beheading women and leaving them on the front stoop. Instead think about the beginning. Who was in everyway of the puzzle. A man who happens to bump into you when a woman is found dead, who was there when you chase after someone like Dee, and the same person who walked in front of the same cab going towards the trip trap the night Lily died. The same man wh couldn't stand laughter after scaring toad junior. None other the crooked man is Jekyll and Hyde. Instead of asking who, but for what reason all the victims were working girls? (Theory in general)

  • I was think that Faith could be the killer.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.