What's the right choice?
What do you think is the right choice to do with the Crooked Man? I personally think it's trowing him down the well, but that's just my opinion. Also what do you think about killing him before the trial? Does that make Bigby still the Big Bad Wolf? Is it the right thing to do? I'm not even talking about ripping his head off because that's just... this one obviously makes Bigby still the Big Bad Wolf. And for inprisoning him, I think that's just too easy for someone like him. He caused too much pain for many fables. Like Bigby said, he was destroying this town. But anyway, what do you guys think?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
I think imprisoning him is the best punishment. He has to live the rest of his life as a crow in a cage, and fables live a very long time.
People can easily free the Crooked man. I think ripping his head off is the best option. Side note: I like Violence.
Imprisoning him is the best option, he can sit there in a cage and think about what he's done for the next hundred years.
Down the well, or rip his head off. Snow likes both. The worst option is imprisonment which is against the law.
I did not trust Greenleaf to keep him imprisoned.
Absolutely. What reason do we have to trust Greenleaf?
Down the well he went in my story.
No one should.
Imprisoned him. Hey, I've already wiped out his crew and effectively neutralized his threat, no real need to kill the bugger.
Besides, sod's a bird now. He can go peck me.
Killed him way back before trial, that's the BOSS way.
I ripped his head off. He showed his true colors right at the last moment when he grabbed Bigby by the throat.
What everyone here is not taking in to consideration was back in the ally when Bloody Mary could have killed Bigby off, the Crooked Man spared him. Bigby could of easily been killed off right there. To be perfectly fair we don't really know if the Crooked man really meant for Georgie to kill the girls off or not.
Despite what Faith/Lily/Nerissa did, they were making money for the Crooked man. If the Crooked man is a business man why would he want to kill off a money making business and draw attention to himself. People are going to notice after awhile that people are missing. Punishing them is one thing, but to kill off a money source doesn't seem to benefit the Crooked man in any way.
In one play through I threw him down the wishing well, the second I spared him and imprisoned him.
You may have the loosest definition of business man in history. If he was just a business man he would have let the girls leave the job knowing the ribbons would stop them from ever talking. If he was just a business man he wouldn't have someone chained up in the back room of a butcher shop. If he was just a business man he wouldn't have hired thugs shooting government officials in the first place.
You thought Bigby was going to die easily? Even if Bloody Mary swinged that Axe, Bigby would turn into that uncontrollable gigantic monster and kill everyone.
Personally, I think the the proper thing to do is to throw the Crooked Man down the witching well. At least it fits the canonical justice, as represented in the comics.
I ripped his head off, I played through the entire game trying to be a good guy, spared dum, reasoned with Georgie ect. And when I realised I could've just been a massive dick and there would've been no difference, I just lost it
Down the well with him. The murders and slavery already justified it, and trying to kill the sheriff again before the verdict was even passed didn't exactly help his situation.
I imprisoned him - because I felt he was powerless, and he wanted Fabletown to hate me for killing him. Did the exact opposite of what he wanted.
I imprisoned him and let him think about what he did for the next few centuries, while being a crow that doesn't do anything.