Thing is, no matter who you take with you to highpoint, and no matter wether they're sentinel or not, either of them (Duncan/Royland) gladly kill Ludd. Which either means that it's Ortengryn (unlikely after the shit Gryff did) or, what I find most likely, Duncan with good inentions (trying to encourage the Whitehills to make peace or something like that).
Gwyn said "There's a traitor in your council" and we've met everyone in the council. She also says something that one would only know if they were present at said council.
Duncan was there with Ethan if you chose him as Sentinel, Duncan is ALSO willing to kill Ludd in episode 4, and Gwyn can't be bullshitting because she said something that you straight up planned with the small council.
Come on, guys. It's obvious.
It's either the damn Maester or Duncan. They are just..so suspicious. They act like they doesn't even want to … morebe in this fucking House and yet here goes everyone over thinking the traitor.
I may be wrong but who got beaten up? The Maester.
Who is "He" in the Episode 5 preview? I doubt that it is Ser Royland.
"He" is the traitor. Which crosses Lady Forrester out.
And the only "Traitors" remain are Duncan, Ser Royland or The Maester.
Ser Royland would die for Rodrik as seen in Episode 4, but it isn't Canon but it shows that Ser Royland would DIE.
So that crosses Ser Royland out. He doesn't seem to be suspicious at all.
Ser Royland was there when Ethan died, when Rodrik became the new Lord. And where was Duncan? probably was fapping in the Woods.
And now we get to Duncan..he seems just as suspicious as The Maester and we even see him selling Ironwood to the Night's Watch for "Better defence against… [view original content]
I actually really hope it's Lady Forrester so I won't have to take any heads. Atleast her reason would be totally understandable for Ryon's … moresake. But if it's someone else then so be it, their head will be detached and they'll get replaced by whom(One of the other playables) returns to Ironrath. Valar Morghulis.
But what if Gryff doesn't know they (The Whitehills) have a fox in the hen-house? Given Gryff's actions/demeanor, would you trust someone like that with such sensitive information? That could easily still mean the Maester is a valid option.
Thing is, no matter who you take with you to highpoint, and no matter wether they're sentinel or not, either of them (Duncan/Royland) gladly… more kill Ludd. Which either means that it's Ortengryn (unlikely after the shit Gryff did) or, what I find most likely, Duncan with good inentions (trying to encourage the Whitehills to make peace or something like that).
I was replaying the game yesterday, and I noticed something I hadn't before. In episode 3 after you plan on rescuing Ryon or getting rid of Gryff, Ducan says "Handle things right with Gywn and she may even help us at Highpoint.... When the time comes."
Highpoint huh? He means the "meeting that happened in episode 4"?? Duncan knew about the meeting, and knew it was coming!
I like those theories about the Meister. I dont think he is Ludd's son, but he can be a friend of his son or something else.
Actually, I think there's probably a shocking secret to be revealed that will lead us to the traitor.
If you havent noticed, there's something really interesting about Lady Forrest and the Meister. In episode 1, Gared can reveal the North Grove secret to her and the Meister or not. Also, in episode 3, after meeting Gwyn, Rodrick can also reveal to her the discussion about the traitor. Why is she always there? I dont believe in coincidences and this can lead to the identity of the traitor.
I was replaying the game yesterday, and I noticed something I hadn't before. In episode 3 after you plan on rescuing Ryon or getting rid of … moreGryff, Ducan says "Handle things right with Gywn and she may even help us at Highpoint.... When the time comes."
Highpoint huh? He means the "meeting that happened in episode 4"?? Duncan knew about the meeting, and knew it was coming!
I was thinking the Maester was getting beat because he was the traitor and wasn't giving Gryff all the information he knew, maybe the Maester was having second thoughts about betraying the Forresters.
If the theory that the Maester is the older brother of Gryff (the one who went to the citadel) was true, than he could be the traitor. The b… moreeating can be explained by the fact that Gryff doesn't like his older brothers (according to the Whitehill daughter), so perhaps he was having some revenge for past time bullying?
I was thinking the Maester was getting beat because he was the traitor and wasn't giving Gryff all the information he knew, maybe the Maester was having second thoughts about betraying the Forresters.
Comments
Thing is, no matter who you take with you to highpoint, and no matter wether they're sentinel or not, either of them (Duncan/Royland) gladly kill Ludd. Which either means that it's Ortengryn (unlikely after the shit Gryff did) or, what I find most likely, Duncan with good inentions (trying to encourage the Whitehills to make peace or something like that).
Gwyn said "There's a traitor in your council" and we've met everyone in the council. She also says something that one would only know if they were present at said council.
Duncan was there with Ethan if you chose him as Sentinel, Duncan is ALSO willing to kill Ludd in episode 4, and Gwyn can't be bullshitting because she said something that you straight up planned with the small council.
I hope it's Lady Forrester so I can take her head. I really don't like her at all.
But what if Gryff doesn't know they (The Whitehills) have a fox in the hen-house? Given Gryff's actions/demeanor, would you trust someone like that with such sensitive information? That could easily still mean the Maester is a valid option.
I was replaying the game yesterday, and I noticed something I hadn't before. In episode 3 after you plan on rescuing Ryon or getting rid of Gryff, Ducan says "Handle things right with Gywn and she may even help us at Highpoint.... When the time comes."
Highpoint huh? He means the "meeting that happened in episode 4"?? Duncan knew about the meeting, and knew it was coming!
I like those theories about the Meister. I dont think he is Ludd's son, but he can be a friend of his son or something else.
Actually, I think there's probably a shocking secret to be revealed that will lead us to the traitor.
If you havent noticed, there's something really interesting about Lady Forrest and the Meister. In episode 1, Gared can reveal the North Grove secret to her and the Meister or not. Also, in episode 3, after meeting Gwyn, Rodrick can also reveal to her the discussion about the traitor. Why is she always there? I dont believe in coincidences and this can lead to the identity of the traitor.
Actually that comes up if you planned to go to highpoint and rescue Ryon, thus referring to the possibility that Gwyn would help get Ryon back.
I was thinking the Maester was getting beat because he was the traitor and wasn't giving Gryff all the information he knew, maybe the Maester was having second thoughts about betraying the Forresters.
I think you've a point
My guess is Ortengryn.