›

What if this decision was in season 1 instead? (Spoilers)

tauertauer
edited May 2014 in The Walking Dead
I just thought of something gut wrenching..

The whole Carver forces Carlos to hit his daughter situation... suppose this happened in season 1, but with Lee and Clem instead and you had to choose what to do? The thought alone makes me sick to my stomach..

What would you guys have done? I don't know if I could have done it.

Comments

  • Sillium83Sillium83
    Huhh... That would be a horrible decision.
  • nickybellonickybello
    daaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaamn i dunno but i'm glad that didn't happen though
  • TWD_1992TWD_1992
    Lee would have told him to fuck off. No way Lee would hit Clementine.
  • KladeosKladeos
    edited May 2014
    Then someone like Troy would do it. Still think he'd let that happen?

    It's like youre saying Carlos should tell Carver to fuck off.
    TWD_1992 posted: »

    Lee would have told him to fuck off. No way Lee would hit Clementine.

  • tauertauer
    I agree, but remember Carver threatened to have Troy hit Sarah instead.. but harder :(
    TWD_1992 posted: »

    Lee would have told him to fuck off. No way Lee would hit Clementine.

  • OzzyUKOzzyUK Moderator
    I felt enough anger when Andy St. John grabbed her hair, i would probably flip my shit if someone made me hit her.
  • TWD_1992TWD_1992
    If Lee had absolutely no other choice than to hit her, he wouldn't have knocked her to the ground like Carlos did. I thought to myself, "fuck man, Carlos that was a bit much".
    Kladeos posted: »

    Then someone like Troy would do it. Still think he'd let that happen? It's like youre saying Carlos should tell Carver to fuck off.

  • Clem_is_awesomeClem_is_awesome Banned
    Just thinking about it disgusts me. I don't think Lee would have ever done that since he isn't submissive like most of the cabin group is. Hell, it's funny how if you put the season 1 group in the truck they would all be trying to find out a way out of there. But if Lee were to actually hit Clem in that situation Clem(both 8 and 11 years old) would have taken it much better than Sarah did.
  • KladeosKladeos
    He did that because otherwise Carver would say it wasnt enough and then Sarah would just get another slap, even worse than what Carlos gave her.
    TWD_1992 posted: »

    If Lee had absolutely no other choice than to hit her, he wouldn't have knocked her to the ground like Carlos did. I thought to myself, "fuck man, Carlos that was a bit much".

  • TWD_1992TWD_1992
    edited May 2014
    True. But he could have tried hitting her softer hoping that would've been enough. I would never be able to hit my daughter as hard as Carlos hit Sarah.
    Kladeos posted: »

    He did that because otherwise Carver would say it wasnt enough and then Sarah would just get another slap, even worse than what Carlos gave her.

  • KladeosKladeos
    edited May 2014
    Maybe, but I am sure he had an idea of what Troy was capable of. Don't forget how he hit Clem with the gun if she tries helping Kenny from Carver, I bet Carlos knew Troy wouldnt mind doing that to Sarah.

    I feel the "No way Lee would hit Clementine" kinda implies Carlos is a worse human being than Lee and i dont agree with that. Both characters are human, with both their qualities and flaws.
    TWD_1992 posted: »

    True. But he could have tried hitting her softer hoping that would've been enough. I would never be able to hit my daughter as hard as Carlos hit Sarah.

  • tauertauer
    You're right, the cabin group does seem like they don't have balls like our beloved season 1 group did... except Ben of course.

    About Sarah, I think it's obvious that she's either suffering from some sort of low autism or she's just generally mentally under-developed. And it doesn't really help that Carlos has kept pretty much everything going on a from her. I don't really get some of the hate I see for her, I feel sorry for her. Especially now.
    Plus, I think she gives Clem some great character development. It's like Carver and Kenny give Clem survival, hardcore development. Whereas Sarah gives her some human development. I think Clem will be a balanced survivor, capable of doing what needs to be done and knowing when to be sympathetic, and Sarah is a part of that.
    Clem_is_awesome posted: »

    Just thinking about it disgusts me. I don't think Lee would have ever done that since he isn't submissive like most of the cabin group is. H

  • cameroncr95cameroncr95
    I could just imagine the stranger saying: "You hit that little girl in the face!"
  • tauertauer
    I think I'd go all Kenny on his face if he did that..
    cameroncr95 posted: »

    I could just imagine the stranger saying: "You hit that little girl in the face!"

  • TWD_1992TWD_1992
    edited May 2014
    You make a pretty good point. But Carlos is not as good a human being as Lee in my opinion because I don't think Lee would have left an injured little girl to sleep in a shed over night. Or at least the Lee I played as wouldn't have done.
    Kladeos posted: »

    Maybe, but I am sure he had an idea of what Troy was capable of. Don't forget how he hit Clem with the gun if she tries helping Kenny from C

  • KladeosKladeos
    edited May 2014
    Yes i have to admit that wasn't one of his best decisions. But still, I don't think he's a worse human being than Lee. Carlos also saved Clem's life when she runned out of bullets in episode 2 against the walkers.

    In my opinion, they're just different people with different personalities that make good and bad calls.
    TWD_1992 posted: »

    You make a pretty good point. But Carlos is not as good a human being as Lee in my opinion because I don't think Lee would have left an injured little girl to sleep in a shed over night. Or at least the Lee I played as wouldn't have done.

  • TWD_1992TWD_1992
    edited May 2014
    Very true. Carlos was a good guy and I was sad to see him die in episode 3. But I still question his decision to smack Sarah as hard as he did. Sarah is such a sweet girl and I wouldn't be able to hit her like he did. As you say humans have different personalities and make good and bad calls. The bad call wasn't hitting Sarah, but hitting her so hard she fell to the ground.
    Kladeos posted: »

    Yes i have to admit that wasn't one of his best decisions. But still, I don't think he's a worse human being than Lee. Carlos also saved Cle

  • OmidShouldHaveLivedOmidShouldHaveLived
    It looks like Clem would be more understanding than Sarah, but still...
  • KladeosKladeos
    Indeed. Emotionally, when i saw it at first time, thought the same, that he hit her too hard. But thinking rationally like he did, I guess he had no other choice, taking in consideration Troy's attitude.
    TWD_1992 posted: »

    Very true. Carlos was a good guy and I was sad to see him die in episode 3. But I still question his decision to smack Sarah as hard as he d

Sign in to comment in this discussion.