After somethings I think I did wrong about Sarah
After watching and reading many predictions about ep.4, I should have teach her(Sarah) to use a gun.
But at the moment, the best choice for me was not to teach because she is like an innocent, naive and inexperienced girl.So i thought that a girl like that could kill somebody(in future episodes) or make a shot with nonsense that could attract people or walkers.
So I decided not to teach her, but after what i've seen that choice could have marked her fate.
Like,
[Teach her to shoot] - in future ep.4(maybe) she will see some walkers going after her and she shoot them and she lives.
or[Not to teach her to shoot] - in future ep.4(maybe) she will see some walkers going after her and she don't know how to shoot and them dies to them.
What are your opinions about my choice?Did I made right or wrong choice?
Comments
I made the same choice as you and i didn't teach her how to use a gun and i am starting to regret it now, i never change my choices so i will have to stick with it and see how it effects the episode.
Hmmm I wasn't sure that would have any effect. I hope her life relies on more than just that one choice though, for such a big thing to just rely on a choice from two episodes ago seems a bit odd. I didn't bother teaching her to shoot either cause we still had everyone else but in hindsight that wasn't a great choice.
I would took the first choice because she need to learn how to shoot zombies.
those gun lessons i showed her better pay off
I chose to teach her because then she'll have a chance of being able to defend herself. I saw it as the same thing between Lee and Clem, Clem didn't know how to shoot so Lee taught her.
Well, if Lee didn't teach Clem how to shoot she would be dead by now.
And I think that'll be the same for Sarah.
I did worse... I said that she should ask her dad.... now he is dead. T.T
In my playthrough Clementine taught her, on the condition that she didn't tell her dad. I'm not sure it was a good idea, she has no respect for the weapon.
I taught her how to shoot, but told her that it wasn't a toy, and that she has to always aim for the head. I have also been 100% upfront with her since the beginning, she needs to know that everything is dangerous. The only thing I wish Clem could have added when teaching her to shoot was to not lock her elbows.
I don't think it was much of a gun lesson...
I mean, she just waved the thing around for like half a minute. It'd be kind of dubious if this is the end-all, be-all choice that determines her fate. I'd still like to see this choice have a small consequence, but not something as big as deciding if she lives or not.
If only Carver didn't show up. She could have gotten some target practice that they were planning to do.
Clementine was like an infant when lee taught her to shoot, and with bullets mind you. What were you thinking man?
I see why you wouldn't teach her but I taught her because she was inexperienced. If Sarah was ever by herself and needed protection, she would be able to defend herself.
That's what I didn't want for her.She could think a gun like a toy and not as a tool against many adversities.
The different between Lee teaching Clem and Clem to Sarah is that Lee is an adult and clem a kid.In the case of Clem teaching Sarah is that Clem isn't an adult and Sarah could think of Clem's lesson as something not useful and just for fun.
The both choices can be accepted but i'm VERY afraid of the consequences, but I think i did the best choice.
I don't know if that question is for me but I'm going to answer it.
Ok Clem was a kid.but there are many differences, Lee was a very good guy with moral values and other things we all know.So Clem as a kid and Lee was like a father to her because he was always teaching her things.Also Clem is a very attentive with many things.
We don't know much about Sarah's education but for what I've seen she had a mind of a kid in that zombie apocalypse and Carlos never wanted her to face the reality and in her mind was educated for the previous things of the apocalypse.
In one episode(i think) Sarah demonstrated a little of knowledge about this new world and I think she told that she wasn't stupid.
I knew it would matter, Telltale loves to pull that shit on us XD
I can't remember getting the option of teaching her how to shoot... Do you have to promise to be her friend to get it?
Sarah isn't stupid education wise, she was reading a book about trans dimensional body snatchers. She is just really sheltered and childish due to her fathers coddling. She also was aware from the get go that the walkers bite. In Episode One S2 she says about Clem's bite "So it really wasn't one of those thing?" She also knew that she needs to defend herself which is why she asked for help in the first place. Sarah is also aware that her dad tries to shelter her based on her dialogue when when you tell her "You should know what's going on" and she replies "My dad told you not to tell me huh?"
It's the zombie apocalypse. The idea of innocence died with civilization. In that world, you either know how to kill or you die. It's survival of the fittest. Not teaching Sarah to shoot just because she was "innocent" or because of Carlos just sentenced her to death. Even Lee knew Clem had to know how to shoot in season one and how many times did Clem save him as a result?
There was a time there was no real concept of child. If you were alive and had any sense, you were another pair of hands to help work. You helped your parents work the field as soon as you could walk or you were indentured off to someone else to help pay your parents bills. Once the industrial revolution hit, kids often worked in the smallest of spaces in factories, It wasn't unheard of for "children" to marry at 12 years of age not that long ago, either. My own great-grandmother was married at roughly age 12 back in the 1920s and started to have children shortly after. She died a few years ago well into her 90s. If I recall, William Shakespeare was also married to his wife roughly around the age of 12. Within the world of the zombie apocalypse, the idea of "child" only leads to the kid getting killed. If they're alive and can walk, they should know how to shoot. If they're too "innocent", you might as well dig them a grave early because they'll end up needing it soon enough. It's a harsh reality in that kind of environment. You can't coddle the children because you'll only get them killed..
Its useless now, Sarah doesn't have a gun with her when she went missing.
"Even Lee knew Clem had to know how to shoot in season one and how many times did Clem save him as a result?"
The difference is that lee was mature and adult, but I don't think that Sarah would carefully listen to Clem.
Clem was with lee since the beginning of the apocalypse, and Sarah, in my opinion, for all these months(maybe) she didn't grow up enough.
Sarah as kid knows Clem as a "physical kid" because their are almost same age and Clem is mature enough like almost an adult, but Sarah doesn't know that because she only see that maturity in adults.Who can guess(and in this case,Sarah) that in this new world, Clem is older enough in her mind?If Clem was an adult physically, it was enough for Sarah to take seriously the lesson of how to shoot a gun.
You know what i mean?
or maybe she will kill herself if you show her how?? i don't know..