I don't want Luke to be around Clementine anymore
Some user made a thread and wrote this:
I totally get where he is coming from. He hasn't got any in ages, of course he would want to do it. Hell, I totally would have done it, a guy has needs, and Jane isn't half bad. Unless I am missing something, why do people now hate him for it?
This is why I don't like Luke .I also don't want this man to be around Clementine anymore.If I get the opinion to left him I will do that without hesitation.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Man I dont like Luke either but even if he "needs it" he wouldt do that to Clem. You cant think Luke would to this!
Luke can always turn to Rosie Palms and her five sisters.
Nah, I don't blame him for geting laid, I just blame him for his terrible timing of getting laid.
Jane's a pretty sweet piece of ass if you get past the haircut.
Agree. Guy totally misses Arvo when watching the perimeter. Then he runs off with the assault rifle, to play hanky panky with Jane, leaving Kenny and Mike to do hand to hand combat with zombies as they try and save the group. Guy is worthless and selfish. Was more concerned with his new piece of tail running off than his longtime buddy Nick dieing. And while everyone else in the group was concerned and tring to save Rebecca and the baby..... Not good old Luke...Hes got needs. SMH.
Because he put everyone in the groups life at risk so he could get laid, like any other time wouldn't have mattered but he knew the baby was coming REAL soon.
I understand what Luke did in a way but the timing was well Ben-Like..... But I would choose Kenny over him if it's life or death..
girls can't have short hair? her hair is fine.
Hmm, Luke, a guy who acted stupid and irresponsible for one episode
Vs
Kenny, a guy who has been brash and rude for eight episodes and murdered three people, two of them group members, and told Lee to kill a seventeen year old.
I think I know who I would keep around Clem, if a choice needs to be made.
I just don't feel the same when he DID that. I still likes him but idk.... it feels weird. More like dissappointed? I don't mind if he wanna have sex or what but can he just do his job first? I know he's a human,have needs and all THAT stuff. but seriously? This situation? No.Just NO.
Well, Luke can be pushed pretty easily and easily justifies everything by pushing responsibility on others. Like saying it was Clementine's fault for leaving Sarah or arguing with Kenny even when he was at fault. Not to forget his comments about how he now sees that Clementine isn't a child anymore and that she's just like Jane (shortly before banging her). I don't think TTG would include this, but I can definitely see drunk Luke molesting Clem and then justifying it by saying she wanted it, too.
Well it's not like he knew that Rebecca was going into labor... he needed a break. Yeah, it was a bad time, but it's not like he's going to do that to Clem... he felt bad about doing it at such a bad time, so I doubt he will do it again. Let's just let it go, he's learned his lesson.
Jukebox?
Yeah me to but im a kenny fanboy so would of since that start but EVERYONE makes mistakes bad timing yeah but when you could die at any moment prob aint got sum in years at this point and get it thrown at you basically i find it hard to judge him that much after all when everyone was kidnapped by carver who run for days to save them luke who convinced the group not to just kill clem over the dog bite luke in my book he deserved sum tang
Oh, yeah? Kenny saves Lee in episode 1 no matter the choice (between Duck and Shawn) Kenny helps finding Clementine in episode 5.He then saves Christa.In episode 3 season 2 Kenny says that he stealed the radio no matter what.
Vs
Luke?A guy who locks Clementine in the shed.Runs from the group in episode 2.Gets laid with Jane instead of doing his job....
So yeah and I think I know who I would keep around Clem, if a choice needs to be made.
Well, if you were 3 years in the apocalypse without sex, I'm sure every straight guy and lesbian girl on this forum would bang a hot ass girl offering her fun hole to you.
You hear that? That's you jumping the shark.
Jesus people, some of you sound like if Luke killed someone or something, this episode actually makes him more relatable and human.
So you will go bang some chick while the whole group is believing that you are doing your job?...
Damn thats intense i like both kenny and luke well written characters with flaws just like us real people kenny jus lost the person who brought him back to life after duck abd his wife died my head would be screwie to and luke got offered sex prob for the first time in years and it jus so happens a few walkers show up no one died from his mistake the walkers would of been all over them anyways with the pregnant woman giving birth screaming right nxt to them
YES
I totally agree with you, Still_not_bitten.
For the first seconds i saw him with jane i wanted to rip out his throat, but i would never think he's attempt to do anything to clementine. That's too far, even for him.
Having "needs" makes him more human, sure, it's just the timing of those needs. For someone who went through all the trouble that he did to infiltrate Carver's camp, he could have gone an hour more without the nookie.
[removed]
So Luke made a mistake in this game that was dangerous to the group. That will often happen since after all Luke wasn't the first person we encountered to do something dumb like that.
Also as much as Kenny been around for a much longer time I'm more concerned about Kenny being a danger to the group rather than Luke over a mistake Luke made.
Kenny now is currently mentally unstable and is obssessed with protecting the baby. I won't be surprised in Episode 5 if we will be given a choice to stop Kenny from doing something very stupid due to him falling into insanity or letting him doing that stupid thing that will most likely get him and the entire group killed.
In a world like that after 1h you might be dead, If youre a guy Id doubt you would refuse the offer either.
That's true enough, but damn man...it's been so long ago, Kenny is nowhere near the same man as he was back then, besides, he left my Lee to die quite a few times : when Danny St. John has a gun on you and, if you helped save Larry, Kenny just stands idle, when scavenging the pharmacy store at the beggining of s01ep3, there may be others which I don't quite remember.
That's determinant. In my game, he wouldn't help Lee find her even if I told him she was family to me. And yes, I always helped Katjaa and Duck when I could, I just didn't agree with Kenny for most of the season.
'I'll give you that one'
(Tavia, you bitch!)
Not willingly: as stated dozens of times, the cabin group decided to lock Clem in the shed cllectively.
Seriously, we still DON'T KNOW the full context of that situation, and you, like so many others, is just assuming the worst for Luke. I think Kenny and Luke knew Carver and his group had showed up and Kenny wanted to confront him, whereas Luke suggested to stay behind and try to think of a better plan, so they 'butted heads' and got separated. In my opinion, Luke's plan was the lesser of two evils in that case, as exchanging bullets with a potentially crazy guy who has your friends as hostages ain't exactly a smart thing to do.
True enough,even though I still think that's plain bad writing and a crappy/forced attempt of characterization, I can't just ignore that's what happened and nothing will change that, Luke has indeed become real shitty in this episode, but then again, so has Kenny
IMO, Luke is still more redeemable than Kenny, so I'd probably still choose Luke, but now more as the lesser of two evils than an actual preference...
If he had just watched the perimeter, the chances of that death would have been less likely AND he still would have had the chance for some action on the side.
And, I've gone years without sex before. The temptation in a world with a lot less women in it would weigh on me more for sure, but if the choice comes down between protecting my friends/family and getting some, I'll protect my family/friends and just rub one out later.
Let's go save that little girl ring a bell? If it wasn't for Lee Clementine wouldn't have survived that long to become the badass that she is in season 2
Well then...I don't think you'll be the leader of your group
(no offence please)
He only says that if you're always nice to him.
Otherwise he always initially refuses to try to save Clem's life.
And as said, Kenny leaves lee under a door to die in episode three if you didn't help him kill larry, and Luke opposes locking Clem in a shed and negotiates trying to get her out earlier, which is why they visit her during the night not in the morning.
And which other group member did he murder other than Larry? He murdered Larry, I don't think he murdered another group member.
He got that THRUST
Ok I'll stop.
Looks like Luke needs Clem and the group a lot more than Clem and the group need Luke. He always not around when we need him. In the ski lodge, in Carver's camp, near museum.
Yeah, he could ask Bonnie or Kenny to guard the place while he and Jane as some fun. It would never happen.
You know, I liked Luke. But this really took it's toll on my respect for him. It was reckless, and completely selfish.
because he put his personal needs before the safety of the entire group. He should have simply told Jane "okay after the group arrives safely, they are depending on me to watch the perimeter." Instead he basically said "F' them, i'm going to have sex" As a man, I can undersand the desire especially after what, nearly 2 years?? but there has to be the right time especially when other's lives are counting on you.
Hell yes, after so long time I wouldn't think what am I really supposed to do or what situation I'm in
he was weak of will.