Is it not possible that Sarah's legs were broken?
After Sarah falls and Jane lifts up the rubble that was pinning her down. Sarah shouts that she can't go or move. In addition to that Sarah looked as though she didn't budge her legs in the slightest, not even in panic and just her upper body was moving around. She wanted to live the second time and I believe if she could have fled from danger, then she would have. Also I think if Sarah had to die that it should have been a save Sarah or Jane choice like it appeared to be at first versus the premature forced death she received.. Maybe that scene would have been even more impressive if the Armed with Death soundtrack began while Clem had snatched Luke's Machete from his back or Bonnie's AK-47 and went berserk against the horde to help Jane fend off the walkers to rescue her friend Sarah. But it just looked as though no one else bothered but Mike and Bonnie did make only a couple of shots then stopped shooting permanently until Sarah had to get eaten which was of miniscule help on their part. At least with Sarah and Nick's deaths in episode 4, Clementine should never have to ever feel guilty for. The culprits of their deaths were none other than the mediocre Tell-Tale writers.
Comments
i was actually thinking that to, but it would have still been extremely easy for Bonnie to shot the walkers, and then for jane to drag her up
Yeah, that contributed to why Sarah's inevitable death was frustrating - because it felt less naturalistic and more contrived by the writers needing to have her die before Episode 5, plausibility be damned.
Something like this.I'm so happy because she's dead,for me she was so annoying.
Then what? Carry Sarah through the harsh winter? We don't have a doctor.
Being nice = annoying.
Niceness is underrated in such a grim setting. I'd go with Walter, Sarah and Luke anytime over Nate, Carver and Kenny.
This, TWD is good because not everyone is a hardcore survivalist asshole. If people hate Sarah did they hate S1 Clem? o.o
The escapist fantasy of breaking laws, taking what you want and killing anyone who annoys you appeals to some people. It doesn't matter if they're portrayed as villains - hell, to some folks that's a plus.
we could have at least shot her so she didn't have to go through the pain of being eaten
For me Sarah wasn't annoying because she was nice, she was annoying because she was so utterly helpless and always burying her head in the sand. I mean for gods sake she's 15 years old, it's two years into the zombie apocalypse, and every time she's in any kind of danger she has a meltdown and puts everyone in danger.
Clementine was very different from Sarah in season 1. Yes she was often scared, and weak, but she was brave and eager to help out when she could.
That being said, I do feel bad for Sarah. It wasn't fair for the writers to give you the option to save her in the trailer only to have her inevitably killed later on. I MEAN WHATS THE POINT!!???
It's not her fault that her father is an overbearing paternal jackass who, let's not forget, was willing to let another child die just so that his 'precious' princess wouldn't be exposed to those horrors. Having her be able to fight back would mean losing her 'purity'/'innocence' and having to actually act her age. I have little sympathy for men who think only their children are valuable, and even less for men who try to control women.
Yup, also I'm not sure if bad writing or intentionnal but you can DEFINITELY know the difference between a human and a dog bite. Plus, suturing a dog bite increases the risks of getting an infection and you also need antibiotics for a little while. My guess is Carlos wanted Clementine dead but how could other the other survivors in the group know about what I've mentionned - I don't even know this for a long time until I looked for information myself. The game probably happens in 2005 and the internet wasn't as popular back then so I wouldn't be surprised if they didn't actually know.
Carlos is an ass. I never liked him, he underestimated Clementine, kept his daughter in a cocoon, wanted to leave Clem to die and even worse - did not actually take care of Clementine after he knew she wasn't bitten by a walker and actually I think he knew that since he checked her wound.
Don't get me started on Carlos, he always treated Sarah like a little kid and kept her out of the loop, not wanting her to have any responsibility. That's just bad parenting even when there isn't a zombie apocalypse. He did her no favours by keeping her blind from the dangers outside. He could have taught her to defend herself and build her confidence but instead he did everything he could to lie to her and keep up the façade that everything is fine and like it used to be.
By the way, how did she get caught under the rubble?
Didn't the deck fall under everyone?
When she fell I expected other group members to go with Jane and help her but they didn't even try. I wish the writers would have let her live until episode 5, there were still so many different directions to go with her character.
That's why I can't find it in myself to dislike Sarah. She helps Clementine out of her own will and desperation to have a friend (it seems that she was secluded from kids like Becca even when they were in Carver's community), tries to learn how to defend herself, blames herself for getting Carver's attention, and calls out Carver for hurting Clem. She was too socially malformed to realize talking to her 'friend' while the adults were busy was a bad idea, and was understandably shaken up when her overprotective dad did something as uncharacteristic as hurt her - she didn't even throw a tantrum and get zombies to enter the compound, as Kenny did. She wanted to survive, and having the game kill her off in such a callous way actually validates all the people who wrote her off as a lost cause without even giving her a chance.
I guess gamers would sympathize with her more if she swore, robbed people, and stabbed monsters in the face. But screw that superficial notion of 'strength' - it takes more strength for little children to survive than it does for fit young women and angry middle-aged men.
It flipped over.
I think they should have had Sarah die in the fight at the end against Russians. That way they could have removed her from the season in a not so predictable way, and maybe of made her death a bit more dramatic (dying of blood loss mabye? we then have choice to have her put down)
That was definitely a dick move on telltale's part. Either we'll see her walker soonish or they just wanted us to see her being eaten alive.
Does it matter? She is dead.
We definitely won't see her as a walker. There is not enough of her left to reanimate probably.
It's sad that we can care more about characters that Telltale creates and doesn't care about later. Sarah and Nick deserved better.
Well unless they got the brain, I guess yeah, she won't come back... but the bicycle girl was half eaten, so who knows?
Yeah, but didn't the walkers just jump all over her? I'm not sure though, it may be possible.
I recall them biting her arms and maybe her neck, I may be wrong though. They often just go for what's accessible, and with so many walkers, maybe it wouldn't take long for her to turn, and if she dies quickyl, they most likely will stop having an interest, since the skin will start rotting.
Walkers can come back alive even if their whole body is no longer attached to their head, proven by Tess, the Stranger's wife. Her severed head was pretty much alive in that bag.
Yeah, but I just mean, isn't there a possibility that if their brain is damaged in the process that maybe they won't come back?
Zombies, at least in the game, don't go for the head for some reason. Anything lower than that is fair game, but the head they leave (mostly, or partially) intact.
She's buried underneath a whole observation deck. She may be a walker but won't be able to budge from underneath all the fallen debris. Would be interesting if it happened though.
Kenny is no Carver dude, and Nate was straight insane, but loyal if he liked you.
Ok,ok.How about Duck ? grabs popcorn
Not really, it's just hyperbole and "what if" pretty much.
Sarah froze up in the past so possible she just froze up then. People can react rather funny when faced with danger. Some bolt, some lock up, some fight. Sarah locks up although she does run as well.
Sarah's legs are also out of sight for the most part. There's not much of a reason for them to animate something that's out of sight. It's a waste of CPU power. Makes no sense to animate people or body parts off screen unless they pop into the screen for a moment. You're not going to see someone sitting at a table tapping their foot rhythmically unless the camera pans out for a moment to show it. They're primarily just going to focus on what's above the table.
The deck also broke apart as it landed. Sarah either did break her legs, broke her lower back thus paralyzing her from the waist down (and thus making her even more of a burden than she already was), or her legs were caught. It's not likely Jane could have lifted the deck enough to get Sarah out by herself even with an adrenaline rush. If Mike, Luke, or Kenny had jumped down to help, one could have lifted the deck and the other pull Sarah out, but it was doomed to fail just because of only one helping her. The group knew Sarah locks up when panicked so the only way for her to have gotten out would have been if someone dragged her out. For that to happen, someone else had to hold up the deck.
Since there was no zombie Sarah sighted the next morning (or even what was left of her), it will likely never be known if she was caught or broke her legs. She's dead. But it's plausible a zombie Sarah could eventually get out from under the deck. Zombies don't care if they have all their limbs. If she struggled enough or the deck cut her in half (or crushed her lower body) from the weight eventually, she could still drag herself around. She still had her arms. A gruesome thought, but the biker zombie in the TV series is evidence that the idea is plausible. More than likely, someone shot Sarah (if she did reanimate) before they left the gift shop, though.
I thought about making a thread about that too... Good notice!
I was pretty surprised no one did already after the 4th episode has been out for at least a couple weeks already.
How was that a "dick move"?
At first I was thinking they might have used Sarah as this season's typical "Choices Judge" character at the very end of the finale some how. If you think about it. Season One had the Stranger as Lee's choice judge and in Wolf Among Us. Either Fabletown or the Crooked Man ironically was Bigby's choice judge. For someone to judge most of or all of Clementine's major decisions throughout the season wouldn't it have to had been someone whom has sort of had their eye on Clementine and been fairly close by? And seen what she's done since episode 1? Either Sarah or Luke (if he makes it to the end) appeared to had been the appropriate candidates assuming they did want to go that route again with this season Too.
...Carlos was a doctor... XD
Its due to our skull being hard to bite through i think
It doesn't fit well into the mouth, so yeah, I guess it is due to that.
the only reason carlos was such a dumb character was for the sake of the plot, so i tend not to include that + he was just trying to protect his daughter, he probably knew how fragile she was and thought she didnt deserve to go through that