Luke and Kenny

So guys, as the big decision that most people think is going to happen is coming up, I'd like your help. I am still not sure what I am going to pick... I've always liked Kenny, because in my opinion he is kind of like how I think I would be if an outbreak would happen, his reactions are very realistic. Luke is like a big brother for Clementine. But I have thought about something lately, it looks like Luke can't really hold himself in around the whole sexual thing, what about if sometime he would just try to get Clem... Not sure. So please tell me who YOU are going to pick, WHY, and who I should. Thanks ^_^

Comments

  • I don't know yet.. Luke is trustworthy but can he do the things that need to be done? Kenny can do what needs to be done.. but will he one day snap and put the whole group in danger? I just don't know yet..

  • edited August 2014

    I think Kenny's sanity is teetering over the edge, but he's able to control himself because of the baby. If it dies, well...

  • I think Kenny's pretty broken, but much more reliable than Luke IMO.

  • Luke every time. So what if he slept with Jane? There both adults. He states that SHE offered it and he took her up on it because the world has turned to shit and he wanted to feel human again.. just for a little white! I do not doubt for a second he would EVER do anything to Clem. People do have restraint and she's like a little sister to him! He's far more reasonable (actually thinking it would be better for Rebecca to rest. Surely the others can take turns searching for food and stuff?) than Kenny, thinking things threw before throwing himself in. Sure he makes mistakes, but who doesn't? At least he's actually willing to listen and take on board others ideas. Once Kenny makes up his mind about something, he doesn't care what everyone else thinks. It's his way or no way and I honestly don't care much for his attitude. It grated on me in season 1 but it's only got worse in season 2. For the record, I was neutral to him in season 1 though he did annoy me a few times, and although it was nice to see him again and I did have Clem hug him, I still think he should have remained dead.

  • it looks like Luke can't really hold himself in around the whole sexual thing, what about if sometime he would just try to get Clem... Not sure.

    A hormonal twenty something year old who had sex once during the ZA to relieve stress is different than a twenty something year old that is a pedophile. LUKE IS NOT LIKE THAT.

    Anyway, I would choose Luke because while he may make mistakes, he listens to his group and then makes a decision on what to do. His cabin group worked as a democracy whereas Kenny.. is not as open to other ideas and judgements. We've already seen in season one that he can't work well with other potential leaders (Lilly, :Lee determinately). Kenny's also pretty unstable. There were multiple cases in one episode where others feared he would hurt them.

    That's just my opinion though.

  • edited August 2014

    LUKE talked shit about mike behind his back though. Luke is a piece of shit while he was busy getting on with jane Mike was actually looking for supplies and got the water. It doesnt matter if she offered thats just a poor excuse for him he still accepted....

    Luke every time. So what if he slept with Jane? There both adults. He states that SHE offered it and he took her up on it because the world

    1. You would have accepted the offer too. Don't lie.
    2. It's stupid to hate someone for something that they might have said (if you chose the right options).
    3. If you hate Luke for a hurtful comment he made, you should hate Kenny more, have you forgotten Kenny's fistfight with Mike in episode three?
    kobe24 posted: »

    LUKE talked shit about mike behind his back though. Luke is a piece of shit while he was busy getting on with jane Mike was actually looking

  • Am seriously the only one who thought jane looked like a man? Seriously you all are acting like she was a victorias secret covergirl. And i dont care about kenny Mike is superior to both of them. Calling my opinion stupid yeah thats real nice

    * You would have accepted the offer too. Don't lie. * It's stupid to hate someone for something that they might have said (if you chose the

  • it looks like Luke can't really hold himself in around the whole sexual thing, what about if sometime he would just try to get Clem... Not sure.

    Are you kidding me?! You honestly think Luke would even do that?!

    Alt text

  • LUKE talked shit about mike behind his back though.

    Kenny didn't trust Mike either?

    kobe24 posted: »

    LUKE talked shit about mike behind his back though. Luke is a piece of shit while he was busy getting on with jane Mike was actually looking

  • I'd rather pick neither to be honest, but I will try to save one of them... I can't just let them both die... can I?

  • We don't know if the choice will involve them. Although i don't like Kenny a whole lot, it still would be sad to see him die. But that isn't why i think I'd pick luke if it came down to it. Kenny has had his time, and i think at this point he's losing his will to live. Yes, we've known him longer, which makes the choice hard. Luke kept screwing up too, but he has so much potential, i don't want to see him die, not with this whole sibling relationship we saw.
    Well really i still dont know, who am i kidding

  • @kobe24 and kenny got in a fight with mike, its not like luke left mike to die. If you like kenny more that's fine but one comment about mike shouldn't be a reason why.

    kobe24 posted: »

    LUKE talked shit about mike behind his back though. Luke is a piece of shit while he was busy getting on with jane Mike was actually looking

Sign in to comment in this discussion.