'Judge'
There seems to be a lot of discussion on who the 'judge' of this season will be, because of the stranger from last season who called Lee out on all of his choices. I don't believe there will be such a person, but if there has to be one I think it would make the most sense to have Luke take that role, he does it about once an episode anyway. For example, if you rob Arvo and tell him about it he sounds pretty offended. If Clementine tells Luke to shoot him, Luke doesn't want to at all.
I'm pretty sure he even calls her out if she kills Sam the dog in the very first episode. So if there was ever going to be a person to judge Clementine in the end, it might as well be Luke at this point.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
Luke is the closest one, but no one actually watched without interfering.
If you left Sam to suffer he will be revealed to be Sam from Sam & Max and he will be revealed to have been undercover watching you and will question your decisions.
Lee (hallucination):
"Clementine... you're not the same as you were before!"
"This is not the sweet pea I remember"
I think Lee in a hallucination would say this if Clementine's decisions were the opposite of Lee's.
That's just silly. It will be Son of Sam.
Not sure if Luke should be questioning anyone's decisions. He "fucked" up pretty bad in episode 4.
I guess Luke makes the most sense since he's been designed to be somewhat of a moral counterpart this season. He's really the only one who would know of everything she's done since he's been around since the first episode. The rest of the cast is either dead or showed up later in the season.
I think Mike seems to be the only one with the right to.
Kenny is a bit... well... you know... right now...
Luke, you just explained him.
Bonnie... she kinda is a main reason why the group is at this position in the first place.
maybe christa will come back and clementine will describe what has happened since she last saw her
Yeah but the stranger was a massive fuck up too and he still had the audacity to complain about all the things Lee did.
Christa will be the judge trust me!
Or Lee in a dream.
I think Luke is the best candidate, since he's been with Clem since episode 1, but after what happened in episode 4... I kind of think he lost that right. It could also be Christa, but there's no way she can know all the choices Clem has made unless someone tells her. Maybe Clem will be her own judge and that's what all the #MyClementine tweets are about?
The only problem is, I don't know if Mike has been around her long enough for that.
Yeah, you're right, but who really has the right to question other's decisions when it is clear that they have made questionable decisions themselves.
Well... Lee kind of gave him trouble and the group played a part in his massive fuck up, so he has some right, but really he only had right to talk about the food being stolen.
Even I think Clem will be her own 'judge' this season... Critiquing her own choices and whether they were just/wrong and whether she feels regret towards them (or on the flip side that they were warranted) would shed a great deal of insight into her evolution. Maybe the playground scene will be at the end of the epi and symbolise her retaining/ loss of her innocence depending on her actions throughout S2.
Lee (as a hallucination/dream) would be great too but I feel he would be deeply saddened by how pragmatic/survivalist my Clem has become. Hearing him express such disappointment would absolutely crush me.
True