It should've been Luke, not Jane (spoilers)
Luke should've been the one to have an ending with Clementine--one just as heartwarming as Kenny's endings were. I've always appreciated Jane, but it was really hard for me to defend her by the end of this episode; the endings with her just weren't as emotional as if Luke were there. TT had been building the Kenny vs. Luke conflict for so long; it just seemed like that's where it was going. Jane really didn't need to come back this episode at all.
Kenny and Luke were starting to get along during this episode, and I loved that. (Remember Kenny poked fun at Luke, "Sounds like a major for working in a coffee shop.") I've always wanted them to get along. Though Kenny took it a bit far by beating up Arvo, it was nice to see him genuinely upset by Luke's death too.
It seems TT's initial plan was to have Kenny duke it out with Luke, not Jane. But then they changed it. Maybe they couldn't see Luke going through with a fight like that? If Luke had lived though, I imagine his arguments with Kenny would've been devolving into something more and more petty. I'm glad we didn't see Luke get as ugly as the argument between Kenny and Jane in the car. But I still would've preferred Luke rather than Jane. If only they had brought the climax of the season to something other than a determinant fight where both of them will die eventually, maybe with something more hopeful instead.
Comments
I prefered Arvo over Jane
I don't know what I would've done If it was Luke,i like him more than Jane.
I agree. I would have preferred Luke as well.
It should have been neither. Clem, Kenny, Luke and AJ should have made it to Wellington and had a much better written realistic conflict in Season 3.
insert genius meme here
Me too. Honestly i think Jane went out of character by the end, but if I had to choose, it would've been Luke.
Maybe. But there needed to be a climax as this was the finale