An open challenge for the community *possible spoilers*

edited August 2014 in The Walking Dead

For someone to find a supporting character trying to convince Clementine that Kenny is too unhinged, too far gone ...

AND Clementine

completely agrees with them. Not split halfway like I think you might be right.

I'm not trying to say there isn't any. I haven't explored season 2 as much as I should. BUT I'm pretty sure you won't find something like that.

SEASON 2 ONLY

«13

Comments

  • Pretty sure you just copied my thread title

  • Nope, it's impossible, it's always maybe, and the subject is dropped.

  • Can this be considered spoilers?

  • I did?

    Pretty sure you just copied my thread title

  • Look, if I did. I'm sorry. Your post may have influenced me.

    I was analyzing all the endings..

    Pretty sure you just copied my thread title

  • I can't believe it. If this is true, this just hurts Season 2 A TON for me.

    dojo32161 posted: »

    Nope, it's impossible, it's always maybe, and the subject is dropped.

  • Any Kenny Fans up for the challenge?

  • edited August 2014

    this post doesn't exist

    remorse667 posted: »

    Any Kenny Fans up for the challenge?

  • edited August 2014

    ugh but censoredddddddddddddddddddddddddddd

    EDIT: fine flog won't come out to play

    remorse667 posted: »

    Thanks flog61

  • Your point is that jane convincing clementine that she shouldn't be with Kenny is unrealistic?I didnt get it,sorry

  • edited August 2014

    Thanks flog61

    Flog61 posted: »

    this post doesn't exist

  • I doubt it. Clem was Kenny's friend by default. Even if she did agree with Jane's theories, i don't think she would tell her.

  • edited August 2014

    That season 2 heavily favors Kenny. My challenge is that to find one instance, where Clementine completely agrees with someone trying to tell her that Kenny's too unhinged, too out of touch..

    No halfway agreement. Like you might be right

    A COMPLETE agreement

    Tolispro posted: »

    Your point is that jane convincing clementine that she shouldn't be with Kenny is unrealistic?I didnt get it,sorry

  • Totally censored porn isn't against the forum guidelines but fine

    remorse667 posted: »

    Thanks flog61

  • yeah it's 5 am i think I need some sleep

  • edited August 2014

    It's 5am and I can't sleep sh

    EDIT: also the sentiment of the picture is still true, that's genuinely how it feels on the forum.

    Tolispro posted: »

    You're weird..and immature

  • Season 2 favors kenny because Clementine likes Kenny.It was like season 1 was favoring Clementine.People might not like Kenny,but Clementine did/does

    remorse667 posted: »

    That season 2 heavily favors Kenny. My challenge is that to find one instance, where Clementine completely agrees with someone trying to tel

  • You're weird..and immature

    Flog61 posted: »

    this post doesn't exist

  • it's 5am I had an argument with my husband and I can't sleep so sh

    also the sentiment of the picture is still totally true, that's genuinely how the forums feel

    Tolispro posted: »

    You're weird..and immature

  • Which proves that season 2 is heavily Kenny favored.

    I doubt it. Clem was Kenny's friend by default. Even if she did agree with Jane's theories, i don't think she would tell her.

  • But then that removes the possibility of choosing what Clem likes. We are her, it's never shown that she bonds with Kenny, it just happens and there is no emotion to it.

    Tolispro posted: »

    Season 2 favors kenny because Clementine likes Kenny.It was like season 1 was favoring Clementine.People might not like Kenny,but Clementine did/does

  • If you shoot and kill Kenny, you never have a chance to completely tell Jane she was right about Kenny.

    Like with Kenny...

    You were right about her ... she was unstable.. always looking out for herself.

    Now, if you side with Jane. You don't get to do that.

    I don't get it, really. If it's supposed to be subjective and about your Clementine, then there should be an option like that with Jane. Not being heavily sympathetic with Kenny all the way through.

    Tolispro posted: »

    Season 2 favors kenny because Clementine likes Kenny.It was like season 1 was favoring Clementine.People might not like Kenny,but Clementine did/does

  • Lee's and Clementine's relationship was default like clem's and Kenny's at season 2.The difference is that everyone cared about clem at season 1.At season 2, being Kenny's best friend pisses off some people.

    remorse667 posted: »

    If you shoot and kill Kenny, you never have a chance to completely tell Jane she was right about Kenny. Like with Kenny... You were ri

  • Read my last sentence and you'll see why it bothers me.

    Tolispro posted: »

    Lee's and Clementine's relationship was default like clem's and Kenny's at season 2.The difference is that everyone cared about clem at season 1.At season 2, being Kenny's best friend pisses off some people.

  • I did.Lee was being heavily sympathetic with Clem all the way and Clem was being heavily sympathetic with Kenny all the way.

    remorse667 posted: »

    Read my last sentence and you'll see why it bothers me.

  • And we had no choice in the matter, Clem is not an NPC, she is the PC so we should choose how she feels about other characters, like Lee could in season 1.

    Tolispro posted: »

    I did.Lee was being heavily sympathetic with Clem all the way and Clem was being heavily sympathetic with Kenny all the way.

  • Doesn't Clem say "you showed me what he really was," if you forgive Jane? Correct me if I'm wrong, I can't remember exactly.

  • Mind private messaging me what it was? I need to know now, the curiosity is killing me.

    Flog61 posted: »

    it's 5am I had an argument with my husband and I can't sleep so sh also the sentiment of the picture is still totally true, that's genuinely how the forums feel

  • We couldn't choose how we feel about Clementine either.Thats my point.

    dojo32161 posted: »

    And we had no choice in the matter, Clem is not an NPC, she is the PC so we should choose how she feels about other characters, like Lee could in season 1.

  • But they at least catered dialogue choices to express some amount of dislike, not feeding her, telling her that her radio is stupid and didn't help anyone, saying we won't look for her parents, there are at least options to express some kind of hate.

    Tolispro posted: »

    We couldn't choose how we feel about Clementine either.Thats my point.

  • edited August 2014

    Somewhere along those lines... STILL not compared to what Kenny gets. You're still sympathizing with him.

    Let's see..

    You can cry about Kenny's death...

    But not Jane. Just feel incredibly angry and sad

    You can find the baby along with Kenny. And agree that's she's a completely psychopath.

    You can agree with Jane, but still heavily sympathize with Kenny.

    Doesn't Clem say "you showed me what he really was," if you forgive Jane? Correct me if I'm wrong, I can't remember exactly.

  • Well, season 2's ending was about

    Your Clementine

    Subjective. Based on personal opinions. The staff heavily advertised that it that way. Season 1 was not.

    Tolispro posted: »

    We couldn't choose how we feel about Clementine either.Thats my point.

  • I know it's not the same, I agree that Season 2 was pretty Kenny favored, but at least it's something. Although shooting Kenny was more than enough to prove that Clem thought she was right IMO.

    And just for the record I'm not one of the Kenny fans you and flog are hating on all the time. I'm a Kenny fan, but not as extreme as all of those are. I do sympathize with him, because I think he isn't a maniac, and that he won't end up like Carver as long as he gets the help he needs. Just my opinion :\

    remorse667 posted: »

    Somewhere along those lines... STILL not compared to what Kenny gets. You're still sympathizing with him. Let's see.. You can cry abou

  • You can still tell luke at the lodge that kenny was a jerk and tell luke at ep4 that Kenny's losing it.For Kenny fans like me,this season was very very enjoyable.I ended up with Kenny and AJ

    remorse667 posted: »

    Well, season 2's ending was about Your Clementine Subjective. Based on personal opinions. The staff heavily advertised that it that way. Season 1 was not.

  • Exactly. This game heavily favors Kenny.

    If you're gonna push an ending where it's subjective, at least cover all sides of the plates.

    Tolispro posted: »

    You can still tell luke at the lodge that kenny was a jerk and tell luke at ep4 that Kenny's losing it.For Kenny fans like me,this season was very very enjoyable.I ended up with Kenny and AJ

  • [removed]

    Tolispro posted: »

    You can still tell luke at the lodge that kenny was a jerk and tell luke at ep4 that Kenny's losing it.For Kenny fans like me,this season was very very enjoyable.I ended up with Kenny and AJ

  • edited August 2014

    I know she shoots him. She still sympathizes with him pretty heavily. It felt like a shot to put Poor Kenny out of his misery.

    I know it's not the same, I agree that Season 2 was pretty Kenny favored, but at least it's something. Although shooting Kenny was more than

  • Use your judgement!

    Flog61 posted: »

    Totally censored porn isn't against the forum guidelines but fine

  • No Kenny fans yet..

  • Yeah...I know. Mind if I ask why you don't sympathize with him though? I find it really hard not to feel bad for him, considering all he's lost, and the situation of his death (Jane tricking him, him dying thinking that the baby is dead, and knowing Clem was the one who killed him).

    And I think she was crying at the situation more than anything. She thought the baby was dead, and was forced to either shoot the man she's known longest in the apocalypse, or let him kill a woman who she had developed a very strong bond with. She also immediately stopped crying in both the situations when she found out the baby was alive, so there's no guarantee if she died at Jane's death or not.

    But I DO agree that it was Kenny favored Episode 3 onward, you won't find me disagreeing with that.

    remorse667 posted: »

    I know she shoots him. She still sympathizes with him pretty heavily. It felt like a shot to put Poor Kenny out of his misery.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.