Is There Anyone Who Still Likes Jane?

2»

Comments

  • I think Jane is crazy. I stated my reasons in other threads.

    Alt text

  • edited August 2014

    I was torn between Kenny and Jane but I went with Jane because she is a Survival Expert and I know Clem will learn from Jane and be safer then with Kenny.

    Jane was just trying to prove a point that Kenny was unstable. People seem to have not noticed Kenny tried beating a teen boy and a female to DEATH in this one Episode alone!

    #TEAMJANE #DynamicDUO

  • Jane was just trying to prove a point that Kenny was unstable. People seem to have not noticed Kenny tried beating a teen boy and a female to DEATH in this one Episode alone!

    By manipulating Kenny into a fight to the death. Jane brings the knife to the knife fight, and gets stabbed with her own blade. Don't even get me started on Arvo, i probably would have thrown him in the water with Luke.

    boomer8491 posted: »

    I was torn between Kenny and Jane but I went with Jane because she is a Survival Expert and I know Clem will learn from Jane and be safer th

  • im ok with her I just didn't like her lying to me at the end

  • This^
    They really complete each other in harmony.

    Yep. She's a survivalist who knows people can seldom be trusted. Clementine is her ying to her yang. Clementine learns from Jane and vice ve

  • I don't think Kenny will ever change, there will always be something that will trigger him to be out of control, it's not safe to be with him. Even though both endings with Kenny were way more emotional, I prefer Jane, she's a lot like Molly from the first season and I loved Molly. The ideal group would be Jane, Molly, Lee, Carley and Clem but then groups have never really worked out in this game. So yeah I still like Jane, she'll be very helpful and will teach Clementine different tricks like "the knee thing"

  • edited August 2014

    Acctually Clem hit the knee plenty of times with the axe before she met Jane, surely she'd figure it out by herself...

    Maybe Christa taught her? Who knows ;)

    -TWD- posted: »

    I don't think Kenny will ever change, there will always be something that will trigger him to be out of control, it's not safe to be with hi

  • I liked her, i still like her, but she fucked up. So she is dead, and soon to be forgotten.

  • No...i do not like Jane after this Episode...for those who know me i liked her at the start....Not so much now,I still wish there could have been an option for all 4 of them to get to Wellington together.

  • Yes!

    TeamJane!

  • I like both Jane and Kenny, but she died in my playthrough because I couldn't kill either of them. Timer ran out.

  • Jane set up the situation, Kenny did not have to attack but he did because he is unstable. Kenny did not have to attack a WOMEN for a "accident". I hated Arvo too but he still beat a boy.

    CrazyGeorge posted: »

    Jane was just trying to prove a point that Kenny was unstable. People seem to have not noticed Kenny tried beating a teen boy and a female t

  • I like her as she is the one who treats clem the right way. She understands what clem can do and lets her get on with it. There an equal pair, there is no protecting one or the other. And most importantly there honest with each other, if Jane fucks up clem can tell her right to her face and she will accept it. Same with Clem if Jane thinks clems wrong she'll tell her straight. There's no dumb denial here

  • the two people I liked most in S2 was Kenny and Jane, so I am glad I have two playthroughs, one where I am with Kenny and AJ and another where I am with Jane, AJ and the new family. If the final choice had been Luke and Kenny, I think I would have killed Luke both times, he never really make an impact on me

  • Kenny is unstable? Yes. DId Jane provoke the fight? Yes. Did Jane take her knife out of her belt and stab Kenny in the gut?

    She got what she deserved.

    boomer8491 posted: »

    Jane set up the situation, Kenny did not have to attack but he did because he is unstable. Kenny did not have to attack a WOMEN for a "accident". I hated Arvo too but he still beat a boy.

  • Its messed up how Jane did it but what if she really did lose the baby by ACCIDENT like she made it seem. Does that give Kenny the right to kill her? I feel like a lot of people only sided with Kenny because he is Kenny.

    Jane used the knife in self defense, Kenny attacked her 1st and then again after she put the knife away. He had it comming for not being able to be reasonable.

    CrazyGeorge posted: »

    Kenny is unstable? Yes. DId Jane provoke the fight? Yes. Did Jane take her knife out of her belt and stab Kenny in the gut? She got what she deserved.

  • My problem with Jane is that, if she had died and AJ never started crying, Clem and Kenny would have still gone on believing Jane actually killed the baby, and they would be right in this case. If the baby never started crying, AJ would have remained in the car to freeze/starve to death, and Jane was the one that made it that way.

  • What do you think Lee would do if you told him, Hey Clementine is dead.... Sorry Lee.

    boomer8491 posted: »

    Its messed up how Jane did it but what if she really did lose the baby by ACCIDENT like she made it seem. Does that give Kenny the right to

  • for the whole of seaon 1 and 2 Clem has survived in a group with others, she isnt a lone stray like Jane, she needs others and others need sher, So I chose to stay with Kenny :)

Sign in to comment in this discussion.