**** Wasn't Supposed To Die! (Proof)
Initially, it was supposed to be a Luke vs Kenny thing. But because of "Lexi Porter" and her Cluke nonsense, Telltale found out and rewrote some parts because she kept posting her bullshit everywhere on the internet. This was supposed to prevent disrespect on the forums and to other people as well. The player actually had the ability to save Luke from the water, thus making him determinant, and I THINK Jane was the one who was supposed to drown.
They wanted Lexi to stop insulting people.They thought that Cluke was disgusting and could lead them into a lawsuit for the fan made "idea" of an 11 year old with a 27 year old. If Luke had a non-determinant death, then the Cluke thing would end and Lexi would stop hating on Gavin. Jane was supposed to fall into the ice. Luke and Kenny become friends, but you could only save one in the storm. Also too many people found out about the leaked choices, so yeah. It kinda sucks, but either way, i still would have stuck with Kenny. Bro's for life! Live together, die together!
PROOF -
It's your choice to believe me or not 
Comments
Would explain why Jane is so terribly written in episode 5 and completely breaks character.
Well thanks a lot Lexi
<
But I did like how they ended this season. To bad they had to deal with the "Cluke" situation
The funny thing is, the one person who cared about Luke to such an extent, and wanted him to live no matter what, is the one who caused the death of him. Too good... -.-
She was written out of character since it seems like she was at the last minute made the final choice against Kenny instead of Luke which is a shame as it disrespects all the characters.
Ironic, don't you think?
Of course, Luke wouldn't have done what Jane did, so if there was going to be a Kenny\Luke fight, it would have been different. Unless Luke was going to totally lose his mind.
That sound is played when you try to save Luke, just without the shivering. Where do you get this information? Is it just your assumption?
This is the real reason why Luke was officially killed off?...
I think Episode 5 had too many determinant characters.
Luke
Mike
Bonnie
Kenny
Jane
I think originally, they were all supposed to be determinant. Then it was changed. Because it didn't make sense.
I highly doubt it, since the OP provided zero proof except for a sound file, which doesn't point to anything about Cluke??
I'll say it again, if this is actually their reason, then Telltale is the one you should all be getting mad at, not this Lexi person. Sacrificing a good story for such a stupid reason is... well, stupid.
Not that it matters, since I highly, highly doubt there is any truth to this at all. But then again, I thought Mike was gonna be dead in the first few seconds of episode 5... kinda wishing I was right, now that I think about it.
Ugh this depressed me..
Still, I seriously doubt it was Lexi's fault. They probably just wanted to make things more unpredictable.
I don't think they cared all that much about Lexi. I'm sure they just called her weird and laughed it off.
In fact, they only killed him off for shock value. In the Playing Dead interview, they say that they set him and Clem up to look like they would be the last survivors of the group walking into the sunset. They knew nobody would expect him to die as soon as he did, so they made him non-savable. They compared his death to the moment in Deep Blue Sea where the shark attacks randomly.
Though I think I prefer the choosing who to save fight scene rather than who you abandon in the storm thing. I mean whoever had an would have an advantage.
No guys, this is NOT an assumption. I have a friend, who has a friend that works at Telltale, who of which told him that there was a MAJOR script change due to this case of scenario. All the other information is most likely cut off due to prevention of episode 5 spoilers and whatnot. This is the truth. Most people are already catching on to this, and realizing the knowledge.
EDIT: Ugh, it irks me. Some people are SO stubborn >.<
Lexi will probably masturbate to that sound clip now... Just saying!
Yeaah, right. I'm pretty sure that Telltale wouldn't change the story just because of some Lexi Porter. There has to be another reason behind killing Luke.
This thread is probably BS. The audio clip proves almost mothing, and gives no indication to Lexi or cluke, so unless the OP can provide proof I'm guessing this is just their guess
I don't believe there was a major reason myself. I think k people just reacted well to Jane and she had an I interesting outlook on life which clashed with Kenny.
What I really wanted to know was where Luke kept vanishing to in earlier eps. That's the real great mystery.
Everybody Poops?
Any proof whatsoever?
Misunderstood Buricko was just killing the walkers sneaking up behind the group..
they did this with kenny. I literally highly doubt he will return in s3.
Well, the moment you said "a friend who has a friend" kind of discredits everything. We have no real proof that this friend really works at Telltale. Unless someone from Telltale(with the Telltale staff verification by their username) comes here to the forums and says it out right that that is the reason Luke was killed off, then I just can't believe you. Sorry.
Kenny and Jane will be I season 3 briefly and then do a Christa methinks...
who is lexi porter
I think that's a bit of a stretch
Till I see walkerLuke or he dies in my arms I still have hope he is out there somwhere
A mean troll who was a big Luke fan. She was also shipping Cluke...
Luke was most likely killed off because of how out of character it would've been for Luke to "hide a baby" or if they originally wrote him as leaving with Mike, Bonnie and Arvo it would've been out of character because Luke wouldn't abandon a baby or Clementine.
Did you copy some of your post from a youtube thread or was it the other way around? because i found some dude that explained why Luke died and he used the exact same words from here :P
Me too.
Cus we need proof!
Jane was always a terribly written character.
But what is that?
...
Originally, Jane was meant to fall in the ice instead of Luke and Luke would attempt to save Jane which would result in him falling into the ice as well. The part where he's hitting the ice and you have the option of saving him in the final version was kept from the original scene. However, unlike the final version (where he dies regardless of whether you try to save him or not), in the original when you chose to break the ice, Luke would climb out of the frozen water and if you didn't choose to break it, he would die (like in the final) making him a determinant character. The audio of Luke being saved should serve as proof as to not only the fact that he was meant to live but also to the fact that the change happened quite late in development.
Basically all they've done was switch Jane with Luke, Luke with Bonnie and added some extra dialogue for Jane for when Luke is hitting the ice. That should explain why some of the animations, dialogue and story feels so sloppy and its also the reason why Jane changed so much towards the end; because she was never meant to live that long.
Also, I don't believe in the Lexi thing. She's not that important.
I think it would be even more out of character for Luke to start a fight with Kenny than it would with Jane so I'm actually a bit happier with the outcome.
Oh, and you're not serious about this lexiporter person, right? I think it's a bit silly to think that one person on the internet who may or may not be trolling influenced this.
If by that gif you mean "pull out of ice - proof", don't worry, Gavin Hammon confirmed that there never was the option to save Luke.
Well still , fuck lexi