What Lee Would have done!

168101112

Comments

  • He says the the fight wouldnt have gone that far, if he didnt believe she killed AJ, which was HIS assumption, based on not real evidence...

    And our current law system would consider him as murderer, learn what assault means.

    Only reason anyone would want to save Kenny, is because of season1. Everyone would think he is just a violent asshole if they saw him only on season 2.

    Belan posted: »

    kenny clearly states that he wanted to kill her, because he taught she killed Aj. That was his assumption before he even came back inside. K

  • Which she fails to due unless Clem kills a friend. Please don't act like Jane had no other options and that Kenny was going to hurt Clem...Clem didn't leave the baby in a car and then pretend it died on accident! Even if she did you can't say for 100% sure that he would hurt Clem. Now Jane is another story as shes an adult and should know better than lying to start a fight she can't possibly win without your help. Kenny was wrong but Jane was stupid/unstable.

    zykelator posted: »

    She was only doing what she thought was best for Clementines safety, get her away from madman.

  • This Lee you're talking about is subjective..

    wwSTEVENww posted: »

    That's not true at all. You are actually completely off lol. I never beat up Kenny for not stopping the train (I managed to talk him into it

  • Well Jane wasnt unstable, just acting stupid because of emotions.

    And like i've said, She was sure that Kenny would become like Carver, and she didnt want to take the risk of leaving Clementine with him when that would happen.

    Which she fails to due unless Clem kills a friend. Please don't act like Jane had no other options and that Kenny was going to hurt Clem...C

  • Because the whole point of starting the fight was to let Clem realize that they need to leave Kenny behind. Running away and abandoning Clem is the last thing she would do.

    Pride posted: »

    When she stabbed him in the gut, it wasn't self defense anymore. She was going for the kill. At that point whoever ended on top was going to

  • Lee had seen Lilly make the very same mistake which he had made before. Why do you think he would allow Kenny to do it once again?

    What Jane tried to achieve, was winning Clem on her side, because she believed that Kenny wouldnt be safe to be around because of his anger issues. She did it all for sake of Clementines safety.

    alcana posted: »

    the lee that i was in season 1 always protected the weak. he would NOT have tolerated a new group member or any group member,jane in that ca

  • If she had, had Clem's safety in mind she would not have pissed kenny off in the first place; she could just have asked the girl who she wanted to stay with, given her an ultimatum.

    zykelator posted: »

    Lee had seen Lilly make the very same mistake which he had made before. Why do you think he would allow Kenny to do it once again? What J

  • Lee would have said : "You guys are nuts bitching at each other on this forum when Clem is still alive and thats all that matters"

  • She cared about Clementine and wanted to make sure she stays safe with her. Jane was just trying to prove that Kenny is unstable and crazy, and she hoped that Clementine seeing Kenny behave like that, would convince her to come with Jane instead.

    Nikolaj-11 posted: »

    If she had, had Clem's safety in mind she would not have pissed kenny off in the first place; she could just have asked the girl who she wanted to stay with, given her an ultimatum.

  • build a shrine for jane or something, jeez

    zykelator posted: »

    She cared about Clementine and wanted to make sure she stays safe with her. Jane was just trying to prove that Kenny is unstable and crazy, and she hoped that Clementine seeing Kenny behave like that, would convince her to come with Jane instead.

  • What for? I dont love Jane. Her worldview in the game is just very similar to mine. Objective and rational.

    Kenny-Lee posted: »

    build a shrine for jane or something, jeez

  • If Lee was there, the fight would've never happened in the first place.

  • Stop saying Jane is rational. Rational people don't start fights with crazy men to prove a point. Crazy people do that shit. She is a good survivor on her own but dealing with people she is anything but rational. You said in another thread you picked her because you agree with her. Well just because you agree doesn't make a choice rational or objective. You don't know what those words mean so stop saying it please. Jane was your choice...not the right/rational/objective choice like you keep saying. Makes you and all Jane fans seem as irrational and unstable as the character herself!

    zykelator posted: »

    What for? I dont love Jane. Her worldview in the game is just very similar to mine. Objective and rational.

  • Well, like ive said before, she got attached emotionally to Clementine, and did stupid thing to protect her (as she sees it).
    Even rational people can do irrational decisions if they care about someone. But overall, Jane is very rational and thinks objectively (and that is exactly the reason i like her, we are similar and its easier to identify with her character than Kennys)

    Stop saying Jane is rational. Rational people don't start fights with crazy men to prove a point. Crazy people do that shit. She is a good s

  • edited September 2014

    Jane is a great survivor...by herself. With a group she makes irrational choices and YES if you pick a fight and are killed during it you are the weaker survivor...not hard to understand really but then like I said you're reacting emotionally as you liked/agreed with Jane and THATS why you made your choice. Some like Kenny and some like Jane but you're acting like she was the best survivor is silly and irrational and flat out untrue.

    zykelator posted: »

    Well, like ive said before, she got attached emotionally to Clementine, and did stupid thing to protect her (as she sees it). Even rational

  • Since when is cheating a valid reason for murder? It's less justified than what Kenny did.

    zykelator posted: »

    And that is exactly the reason he was going for prison. He murdered someone. Lee however murdered someone who he knew was guilty of doing something. Kenny and Lilly murder someone because of assumption.

  • The point is that they were both enough angry to murder someone without hesitation.

    Pride posted: »

    Since when is cheating a valid reason for murder? It's less justified than what Kenny did.

  • It doesnt make you weaker survivor, it makes you weaker fighter. I could survive with my worldview in zombie apocalypse for long (with some luck also, of course), but surely i would lose fist fight with much stronger man than i, unless if i get lucky.

    But like ive said before, she did irrational decision because of Clem.

    You also seem to forget that Kenny is writers favorite.

    Jane is a great survivor...by herself. With a group she makes irrational choices and YES if you pick a fight and are killed during it you ar

  • yeah i would survive too.... i just pause the game a few months.
    and what if you don't know when the ZA is there and someone close doesn't feel so good?
    Would you already stab them in the head? Or take their temperature so they will bite your arm and you'll die?

    zykelator posted: »

    It doesnt make you weaker survivor, it makes you weaker fighter. I could survive with my worldview in zombie apocalypse for long (with some

  • Kenny being the writers favorite isn't why Jane was killed so stop being irrational please.

    You are right that you may not be able to beat a man but then you probably wouldn't provoke a crazy man and try to fight him either because you could die. THAT is a rational decision. Fighting to prove a point when you could die for nothing is a crazy unstable and weak thing to do. That is what makes Jane a weaker survivor...she can't back up her attitude yet still forces the issue anyhow. That's what makes her weak. She doesn't see her limitations/is cocky.

    zykelator posted: »

    It doesnt make you weaker survivor, it makes you weaker fighter. I could survive with my worldview in zombie apocalypse for long (with some

  • If someone i knew was going to die and become a walker, i would just kill them before that happens. Nothing i could do to prevent them from changing and only wise thing to do is stop it from happening.

    ps. Im pretty sure that if zombie apocalypse happens, i would only know about it through news, considering that i live in small town in lapland.

    Kenny-Lee posted: »

    yeah i would survive too.... i just pause the game a few months. and what if you don't know when the ZA is there and someone close doesn't

  • This is the last time i reply you, because you just keep bringing up same argument over and over again and i've give you a answer to it multiple times.

    Kenny IS the writers favorite. He wouldnt have survived those impossible situations in season 1 without writers magically resurrecting him. There is no point arguing about this, because it is so obvious.

    And again.... She did irrational decision because she cared about Clementine and as proven by Kenny, Lilly and Lee, emotions lead into bad decisions.

    Kenny being the writers favorite isn't why Jane was killed so stop being irrational please. You are right that you may not be able to bea

  • you won't know if they turn to zombies because the news hasn't spread yet
    they'll bite your arm and you'll be wandering the streets just like everyone else

    zykelator posted: »

    If someone i knew was going to die and become a walker, i would just kill them before that happens. Nothing i could do to prevent them from

  • The only reason Kenny was on top on Jane was to make the choice harder IMO. Realistically, Jane would've won the fight.

    Kenny being the writers favorite isn't why Jane was killed so stop being irrational please. You are right that you may not be able to bea

  • I dont understand the point of this question. Are you saying i should kill my friends/family if they get fever? I have no reason to believe its nothing else than normal fever, so why would i try to kill them?

    Kenny-Lee posted: »

    you won't know if they turn to zombies because the news hasn't spread yet they'll bite your arm and you'll be wandering the streets just like everyone else

  • Even if Kenny is the writers favorite what does that have to do with anything??

    I don't care if Jane is irrational...so is Kenny!!! I'm just saying YOU keep saying Jane is rational and then changing your story how it fits whatever you're trying to prove. Clem is a writers favorite too. Doesn't change anything about her character. Kenny surviving everything he has is unlikely but why does that make Jane the right/rational choice. It doesn't but you keep arguing that it does and if I see that I will tell you that you're wrong. I'm not being mean or offensive just giving you my opinion as you keep giving your opinion.

    Just stop saying rational...no one is rational in this game.

    zykelator posted: »

    This is the last time i reply you, because you just keep bringing up same argument over and over again and i've give you a answer to it mult

  • i might snap and punch the both of them -_-

    Rockworm posted: »

    Lee would probably have been able to hold them back. He isn't a 11 year old girl so they couldn't have just shoved him out of the way and i

  • He's saying no one will know if zombies come they will just come and you might be surprised by it (like having a family member or friend turn in the night.

    I think he's just pointing out that surviving is hard and probably alot harder than we even know. I mean heck if my power is out for a few hours I feel lost lol.

    Please don't kill a family member if they get a fever as the police will find this forum thread and shut TellTale down forever;) lol

    zykelator posted: »

    I dont understand the point of this question. Are you saying i should kill my friends/family if they get fever? I have no reason to believe its nothing else than normal fever, so why would i try to kill them?

  • If Lee was alive he would have never allowed a fight to break loose in the first place.

  • Theres a difference between being rational and being a robot... Learn the difference. What you are implying is that there are no rational people, because everyone makes irrational decision at some point.

    Even if Kenny is the writers favorite what does that have to do with anything?? I don't care if Jane is irrational...so is Kenny!!! I'm j

  • You can't say that because even if you only help Jane during the fight If you don't shoot kenny he wins...There is not any ending where Jane kills Kenny. There just isn't. So blaming the writers and saying what would happen don't make sense. If Lee wouldn't have went for the walkie talkie and looked around first like most would have he wouldn't have been bit. But he did go right up there and was bit just like Kenny did win the fight. If you want to argue thats fine but don't rewrite history and say its what really happened.

    Just saying!

    ErenCoral posted: »

    The only reason Kenny was on top on Jane was to make the choice harder IMO. Realistically, Jane would've won the fight.

  • eren has rewritten the story in her own mind and thats why she's arguing with a lot of people

    You can't say that because even if you only help Jane during the fight If you don't shoot kenny he wins...There is not any ending where Jane

  • Well since there is no evidence of supernatural in our universe. a parasite or virus etc. would be the cause of it. And i live in very isolated place, so its very unlikely that people would turn into zombies here before the news tell about it.

    But what if i BELIEVED that they were turning, would that justify it?

    Another Kenny argument won the day.

    Stuff like this just shows how crazy Kenny really was.

    He's saying no one will know if zombies come they will just come and you might be surprised by it (like having a family member or friend tur

  • And then you'll be bitten and become a walker
    just like a lot of people will thats all

    zykelator posted: »

    I dont understand the point of this question. Are you saying i should kill my friends/family if they get fever? I have no reason to believe its nothing else than normal fever, so why would i try to kill them?

  • Why do people assume Jane was a victim, because she wasn't on top?

    Kinky

    I get the feeling people would shoot her if she was the one with the advantage in the end.

    And i get the feeling people would side with Kenny no matter what happens. I'd shoot Jane if she picked the fight with pure rage and stupid ass assumptions.

    Pride posted: »

    Why do people assume Jane was a victim, because she wasn't on top? I get the feeling people would shoot her if she was the one with the advantage in the end.

  • BINGO! no one is 100% rational or irrational. Those type of things can change in an instant for any number of reasons!

    That has been my point all along. It's easy to say this persons rational and this one isn't but given the circumstances anyone can be anything at any moment.

    zykelator posted: »

    Theres a difference between being rational and being a robot... Learn the difference. What you are implying is that there are no rational people, because everyone makes irrational decision at some point.

  • Imagine Jane trying to run and Kenny chases after her and tackles her. Cause thats what I see happening.

    wwSTEVENww posted: »

    "When she stabbed him in the gut, it wasn't self defense anymore. She was going for the kill". The part where you say "it wasn't self defens

  • edited September 2014

    why bring kenny into this , you said you'll survive long in the Z-A but 80-95% of the deaths are..... SURPRISE !!!!UWAAAAGHHHH ... and you're a walker.
    thats all

    zykelator posted: »

    Well since there is no evidence of supernatural in our universe. a parasite or virus etc. would be the cause of it. And i live in very isola

  • Seems only fair. Ya'll already have one for Kenny.

    Kenny-Lee posted: »

    build a shrine for jane or something, jeez

  • ErenCoralErenCoral Banned
    edited September 2014

    Jane slashed Kenny with probably the most germ infected knife. She uses her knife to stab walkers and then she stabbed Kenny. His body should be leaking liquids/blood after that slash. Also after that she popped both of his eyes, she dug her fingers in his eyes. He should be blind + he should be experiencing the MOST PAINFUL THING EVER. I call this plot protection.

    You can't say that because even if you only help Jane during the fight If you don't shoot kenny he wins...There is not any ending where Jane

Sign in to comment in this discussion.