That's what I thought as well, honestly, as much as I liked luke he really wasn't a great leader or at making decisions. But he was a good guy that you could trust and never betrayed the group.
I thought Pete was the leader at first, he seemed have the most control over the group. And when he died, I though Carlos became the leader. I never thought it was Luke the whole time.
That's what I thought as well, honestly, as much as I liked luke he really wasn't a great leader or at making decisions. But he was a good guy that you could trust and never betrayed the group.
Well, Luke was the one that decided that he and Clem go scout out the bridge. And when Carlos says that he doesn't like that plan, Luke shoots him down, saying "Yeah, well, when's the last time you liked anything, Carlos?" That's not exactly something one would say to the sole leader of the group. And then after they cross the bridge, Luke and Carlos are the ones that go off to the side to discuss things. It's because of stuff like that I assumed that they were both leaders of the group in a way.
Well, Luke was the one that decided that he and Clem go scout out the bridge. And when Carlos says that he doesn't like that plan, Luke shoo… morets him down, saying "Yeah, well, when's the last time you liked anything, Carlos?" That's not exactly something one would say to the sole leader of the group. And then after they cross the bridge, Luke and Carlos are the ones that go off to the side to discuss things. It's because of stuff like that I assumed that they were both leaders of the group in a way.
My favorite character from season two...
Got a bullshit death for the sole purpose of Sarah's character development, which never even existed in the first place.
I could tell he would die from the first episode after he told us about Sarah. I thought she at least had a shot. Still Walking Dead isn't full of rainbows and flowers. People are gonna die regardless in the end.
I think that he died too soon, without getting enough character development. We know almost nothing about him, which is pretty sad. I can only imagine what it would be like if all characters were given enough character development and good deaths....
Actually, he died for a few people's laugh.
I'm sure this is how Telltale reacted to Nick's situation:
"lol look at this determinant fucker. Let's just give him a forgettable role and kill him in the most meaningless way. -Evil laugh-."
If you kill him in episode 2, it makes Clementine look like she never took Pete's promise or really cared about Nick, so neither option is better, and that really sucks.
If you kill him in episode 2, it makes Clementine look like she never took Pete's promise or really cared about Nick, so neither option is better, and that really sucks.
I liked the whole dynamic he had with Sarah and the direction it could have gone in accepting that he won't be always be there to shelter her, but I think the poor guy got killed before we could have more than two conversations with him.
My favorite character from season two...
Got a bullshit death for the sole purpose of Sarah's character development, which never even existed in the first place.
It was really Carlos' fault that his daughter died. He shielded her from what was happening. Now compare that to Lee, he showed Clementine what was up since day one. He didn't allow Clementine, to be ignorant. Carlos failed completely. Period.
Unsure. Lee didn't really tell Clem as much till Chuck showed him he should. He covered lots up in Ep3, not that he shouldn't have though. We can't blame Carlos much unless we know an adult suggested he shelter his daughter less and he ignored them. Pete seems like the kind of guy to advise him, but he also seemed like a guy whom would respect Carlos saying no to teaching her
It was really Carlos' fault that his daughter died. He shielded her from what was happening. Now compare that to Lee, he showed Clementine what was up since day one. He didn't allow Clementine, to be ignorant. Carlos failed completely. Period.
not seeing difference between dog bite and human bite.
He faked to not know about the bite because he didn't want Clem to stick around. Come on, for them, she was no different than Jolene was for Lee. And even if he didn't, walkers don't always bite like a human. Many are so mangled to hell and back that their bite would probably look like a dog bite aswell.
not realizing words "little" and "small" mean the same thing.
This isn't that big if a fail, either. Even if it's a small house, there are still varieties of small. Is it too small for Alvin alone or just big enough for everyone? It seems stupid at first, but after you realize what he meant, it makes sense.
He called out Clem that her opinion doesn't matter since she's a kid.
When did he do that? Do you mean before the bridge scene? That might be because Clem is a little girl, y'know? And one he didn't know very well, only for 6 days? But okay, it seems normal to just trust Clementine because she's Clementine.
And he practically killed his own daughter.
If you mean by sheltering her, then that's true. Can't say he wasn't wrong by doing that.
LOL, cos he got his doctorate from the back of a cereal box, not seeing difference between dog bite and human bite
He was dumb as a sack … moreof potatoes, not realizing words "little" and "small" mean the same thing.
He called out Clem that her opinion doesn't matter since she's a kid.
And he practically killed his own daughter.
RIPieces Carlos
Nick died to remind everyone that it's the ZA. There were many times throughout this season that I felt people on these forums were trying to play a family simulator and missing the bigger picture.
Unsure. Lee didn't really tell Clem as much till Chuck showed him he should. He covered lots up in Ep3, not that he shouldn't have though. W… moree can't blame Carlos much unless we know an adult suggested he shelter his daughter less and he ignored them. Pete seems like the kind of guy to advise him, but he also seemed like a guy whom would respect Carlos saying no to teaching her
I never forgave him for Episode 1, where he was either incompetent or cold enough to let a little girl die of an infection just so that she couldn't talk to his daughter.
That being said, he definitely had potential. If Kenny hadn't taken up the spotlight, I imagine he could have played a slightly more prominent role in Episode 3.
Yeah, I noticed that too. Although to me, his actions -after- episode 2 seemed OOC. He just seemed like a different character in the later part of the season. But the Kenny thing makes sense.
To me it would of made a lot more sense The Walkie Talkie Scene would of been you restraining Sarah, instead of Sarita. I think that she was added last moment and that is why she really doesn't have much Character Development.
Yeah, I noticed that too. Although to me, his actions -after- episode 2 seemed OOC. He just seemed like a different character in the later p… moreart of the season. But the Kenny thing makes sense.
Its funny cuz in the first few episodes I had assumed Carlos was the leader and that he was the one who led them away from Howes. It just felt like they were setting it up as Carlos vs Carver. I was surprised to learn it was Luke who got them to leave, cuz Carver seemed to dislike Carlos a lot more then Luke imo.
Maybe in the rewrite Sarah is still alive, and you have to make a choice to either kill her father or let them kill whoever it may be Jane/ Luke whoever.
I think the reason he kept her in the dark was because he knew she simply wasn't mentally capable of handling it. Jane said the same thing about her sister. Not everyone is capable of adapting, instead they just give up and die. He knew his daughter couldn't handle the world as it was, so he tried to hide it from her to keep her spirits up so she wouldn't just give up on life.
That definitely wasn't the right decision for sarah, if she was more like clem with a better understanding of the world that they live in, she would have coped better with the death of her dad and also survived to live another day at the gift shop.
Not really. Carlos knew that Sarah, with her mental issue, would never be a competent and reliable survivor even close to what Clementine is no matter how much she would be exposed and used to this decayed world, but even though, he didn´t just ditch his daughter, he raised her and loved her despite all the odds of the apocalypse plus her conditions, despite how big of a liability she would be, he was a exemplar father.
It was really Carlos' fault that his daughter died. He shielded her from what was happening. Now compare that to Lee, he showed Clementine what was up since day one. He didn't allow Clementine, to be ignorant. Carlos failed completely. Period.
Not really. Carlos knew that Sarah, with her mental issue, would never be a competent and reliable survivor even close to what Clementine is… more no matter how much she would be exposed and used to this decayed world, but even though, he didn´t just ditch his daughter, he raised her and loved her despite all the odds of the apocalypse plus her conditions, despite how big of a liability she would be, he was a exemplar father.
Comments
That's what I thought as well, honestly, as much as I liked luke he really wasn't a great leader or at making decisions. But he was a good guy that you could trust and never betrayed the group.
In episode 2, Carlos was the one was making all the decisions, not Luke. So I thought Carlos seemed to be the leader.
Well, Luke was the one that decided that he and Clem go scout out the bridge. And when Carlos says that he doesn't like that plan, Luke shoots him down, saying "Yeah, well, when's the last time you liked anything, Carlos?" That's not exactly something one would say to the sole leader of the group. And then after they cross the bridge, Luke and Carlos are the ones that go off to the side to discuss things. It's because of stuff like that I assumed that they were both leaders of the group in a way.
And then it was revealed that Luke was the one who led them, I was like "You're telling me he was the leader? Why didn't anyone tell me this?)
My favorite character from season two...
Got a bullshit death for the sole purpose of Sarah's character development, which never even existed in the first place.
Yeah he kinda has a point
And Sarah died for Jane's.
Nick-"What a fuckin' mess."
And Nick died for....................
Nothing. He died for nothing. Not even for anyone's character development.
Actually, he died for a few people's laugh.
I'm sure this is how Telltale reacted to Nick's situation:
"lol look at this determinant fucker. Let's just give him a forgettable role and kill him in the most meaningless way. -Evil laugh-."
I like the moment when he splits in Carvers face.
I feel bad for laughing at this ..
I could tell he would die from the first episode after he told us about Sarah. I thought she at least had a shot. Still Walking Dead isn't full of rainbows and flowers. People are gonna die regardless in the end.
Well at least Carlos got resurrected as Randy in Jane's ending.
I am also wracked with guilt.... BAHAHA!
I think that he died too soon, without getting enough character development. We know almost nothing about him, which is pretty sad. I can only imagine what it would be like if all characters were given enough character development and good deaths....
I thought Sarah died to push for the sake of objectivity.
Honestly, I liked him.
Can't say much else, since he didn't really do much for this Season, sadly.
I'm still pretty mad at that.
I'm starting to think killing him in Episode 2 is better than him fading out of the story and being forgotten.
If you kill him in episode 2, it makes Clementine look like she never took Pete's promise or really cared about Nick, so neither option is better, and that really sucks.
Yeah, Nick had a really bad death in Episode 4. We did not even see him dying, or say almost any lines during Episode 3! He was just thrown away.
Wow, I totally forgot about my promise to Pete...
Damn you Telltale and your gray options!
I liked the whole dynamic he had with Sarah and the direction it could have gone in accepting that he won't be always be there to shelter her, but I think the poor guy got killed before we could have more than two conversations with him.
i liked him,he was one of my favorite characters
And Sarah didn't even developed as a character.
Who's Carlos?
It was really Carlos' fault that his daughter died. He shielded her from what was happening. Now compare that to Lee, he showed Clementine what was up since day one. He didn't allow Clementine, to be ignorant. Carlos failed completely. Period.
Unsure. Lee didn't really tell Clem as much till Chuck showed him he should. He covered lots up in Ep3, not that he shouldn't have though. We can't blame Carlos much unless we know an adult suggested he shelter his daughter less and he ignored them. Pete seems like the kind of guy to advise him, but he also seemed like a guy whom would respect Carlos saying no to teaching her
He faked to not know about the bite because he didn't want Clem to stick around. Come on, for them, she was no different than Jolene was for Lee. And even if he didn't, walkers don't always bite like a human. Many are so mangled to hell and back that their bite would probably look like a dog bite aswell.
This isn't that big if a fail, either. Even if it's a small house, there are still varieties of small. Is it too small for Alvin alone or just big enough for everyone? It seems stupid at first, but after you realize what he meant, it makes sense.
When did he do that? Do you mean before the bridge scene? That might be because Clem is a little girl, y'know? And one he didn't know very well, only for 6 days? But okay, it seems normal to just trust Clementine because she's Clementine.
If you mean by sheltering her, then that's true. Can't say he wasn't wrong by doing that.
Nick died to remind everyone that it's the ZA. There were many times throughout this season that I felt people on these forums were trying to play a family simulator and missing the bigger picture.
But he HAS a point xD
Oh come one. In a weird way he was even more stupid than ben xD And i make him responsible for sarahs sad death
true thing. I think my Lee would do the same thing if chuck didnt showed up and told me the truth
I never forgave him for Episode 1, where he was either incompetent or cold enough to let a little girl die of an infection just so that she couldn't talk to his daughter.
That being said, he definitely had potential. If Kenny hadn't taken up the spotlight, I imagine he could have played a slightly more prominent role in Episode 3.
To me it would of made a lot more sense The Walkie Talkie Scene would of been you restraining Sarah, instead of Sarita. I think that she was added last moment and that is why she really doesn't have much Character Development.
Maybe in the rewrite Sarah is still alive, and you have to make a choice to either kill her father or let them kill whoever it may be Jane/ Luke whoever.
Ain't Rebecca and Alvin supposed to be partners? Why is she holding Nicks hand? or was he a ghost this whole time... Spooky.
I think the reason he kept her in the dark was because he knew she simply wasn't mentally capable of handling it. Jane said the same thing about her sister. Not everyone is capable of adapting, instead they just give up and die. He knew his daughter couldn't handle the world as it was, so he tried to hide it from her to keep her spirits up so she wouldn't just give up on life.
Not really. Carlos knew that Sarah, with her mental issue, would never be a competent and reliable survivor even close to what Clementine is no matter how much she would be exposed and used to this decayed world, but even though, he didn´t just ditch his daughter, he raised her and loved her despite all the odds of the apocalypse plus her conditions, despite how big of a liability she would be, he was a exemplar father.
From my experience most parents think their kids can do anything, Carlos included. He was just being protective of his teenage daughter.
What's wrong with that question? Other than the fact that you can't tell just by looking at it from outside.