There is no right or wrong! D:
Hey, i would just like to point out to a lot of people that the big choice between Kenny or Jane can be justified in both ways, and if you thank that for example Kenny was the best choice then feel free to share it, there aint no opinion police.
However i feel like too many people are using the words "right" and "best" too much. I personally feel like the game choices kinda determine on what your morally okay with, for example, if i'm more of a forgiving person i would pick Jane, because i felt like she was quite trust worthy through the show. But if i felt lying about the baby caused Kenny's death i may pick to leave her.
However this does not mean "KENNY IS RIGHT, JANE IS WRONG, KENNY IS BEST CHOICE" (Sorry if that sounds too bias, i'm just using this situation as a scenario, this could easily go the other way)
You have to realize everyone is different, i may chose Kenny over Jane simply because i like his beard, that's fine, but that doesn't mean Jane is the wrong choice. You get me?
I didn't really wanna post this kinda junk since it's kinda spammy and lame, but i thought this debate would really blow over after a while, but it's still the same, sorry if a sound like a pleb.
Comments
Someone here has figured it out!
yeah, you are absolutly right !
Yeah, you're right. There is no right choice in this situation, because both Kenny and Jane are virtually flawed individuals, who aren't morally right in any way, or in any of their justifications/actions. It is a question of preference rather than morality.
Yes. People should understand this is a discussion forum and everyone have a right to express their opinions. Most threads here immediately becomes a troll fest because of few fanatics who defend their idols insanely and they do that by insulting others or belittling their opinions. It's really gone out of control. Even I made a decision in the game, I like to read a thread (written in a respectful manner) about someone who made the opposite choice. So I can look at my decision from their point of view. In my opinion, THAT is the best part of a discussion forum. But instead it seems like people often use this place to spam their own ideas and team with others who think alike to crush those who think differently. So, PLEASE do not let them do that by participating in their threads help them achieve their goals. The more you argue and fight with them, the more pleasure they get out of it.
The only right choice is making the same choices as i do, and if you disagree with me your instantly wrong, and i will mock and ridicule you lose patience, or give up.
You are, of course, quite right. Funny thing, directly after finishing the game, I chatted with one of my best friends about our choices. He picked Kenny, I picked Jane. We ended up having a very interesting discussion about our reasons for doing so, and strangely enough didn't denounce each other as the Spawn of Satan.
I agree.
That is good to hear, if only everyone here could embrace different opinions and argue on them in a civilized manner.
Youre right...How about we remember our great hero...Our savior!
LEE!
More people need to read this!
Holy shit, he's drinking a Guinness
You are correct. The arguing here is a fine display of cognitive dissonance at work.
The writers even tried to prepare the player for it with the Lee flashback clearly stating that hard choices like that aren't always simple or straight forward. Lee second guesses whatever decision you made regarding Lilly and spells it out, that sometimes good people do bad things and how to deal with that isn't clear, isn't laid out, and isn't easy.
I do have an ending that is "cannon" to me. I can give you my reasons for making those choices. They are good reasons, I can assure you, but that doesn't make your reasons and choices "wrong."
[insert unrelated image as response here]
Can't stress this enough. Seeing as how people agree her, maybe they're just trolling us? xD
Wrong.
EDIT: By the way, is a joke.
...Weren't you permabanned?
I get that a lot.
Let's just say I got lucky. Real lucky.
Hey and weren't you banned? :P
Just for 10 days. Not a big deal in comparison.