It shows everything. The St Johns did that because they needed to lure people to eat them. Wellington gives the supplies away because of overpopulation issues, and there is no ulterior motive for them giving the supplies away.
It seemed pretty situational to be honest. I think they were cannibals but had no intention on eating the group. However when Mark was "injured." that changed, and they decided to eat him. If lee would of just ate dinner Larry might have been still alive.
That doesn't show anything. The St Johns give supplies away.
It shows everything. The St Johns did that because they needed to lure … morepeople to eat them. Wellington gives the supplies away because of overpopulation issues, and there is no ulterior motive for them giving the supplies away.
It seemed pretty situational to be honest. I think they were cannibals but had no intention on eating the group. However when Mark was "injured." that changed, and they decided to eat him.
I think that they expected the bandits to injury them so they would eat the group.
It shows everything. The St Johns did that because they needed to lure people to eat them. Wellington gives the supplies away because of ove… morerpopulation issues, and there is no ulterior motive for them giving the supplies away.
It seemed pretty situational to be honest. I think they were cannibals but had no intention on eating the group. However when Mark was "injured." that changed, and they decided to eat him. If lee would of just ate dinner Larry might have been still alive.
Well maybe, like if watch the cut scene when Mark is running back after being shot, one of the brothers i forget his name looks completely shocked when he sees them. That look alone, made me think this wasn't planned it just sort of happened. Like maybe they were going to treat his wounds, and started licking their fingers covered in his blood, and well.... couldn't help themselves, kind of like a Klondike bar.
It seemed pretty situational to be honest. I think they were cannibals but had no intention on eating the group. However when Mark was "inju… morered." that changed, and they decided to eat him.
I think that they expected the bandits to injury them so they would eat the group.
Andy's purpose for turning on the perimeter fences while Lee and Mark were checking them for weak points was to remove them as obstacles in his intentions to take the rest of their group to be used as trade meat.This can be backed up by the fact that he says that the only reason he turned on the fences was because he heard Mark yell (referring to when he got shot with the arrow) and he thought they were giving him the all-clear. However, no shout was given by either Mark or Lee until after the fences came on.
Well maybe, like if watch the cut scene when Mark is running back after being shot, one of the brothers i forget his name looks completely… more shocked when he sees them. That look alone, made me think this wasn't planned it just sort of happened. Like maybe they were going to treat his wounds, and started licking their fingers covered in his blood, and well.... couldn't help themselves, kind of like a Klondike bar.
people always talk of some better place in bad times.
jane was right. as always.
there was not even the slightest piece of evidence it was near by if exists at all.
what i actually wanted to say was, to answer the question of the this thread's creator, he was so convinced they would be save there for the same reason he was so convinced wellington is real.
people always talk of some better place in bad times.
And? That´s like saying people can aggree on a name-Wellington- and a place- Michingan- in the zombie apocalypse. There was not even a chance that Wellington was fake.
people always talk of some better place in bad times.
jane was right. as always.
there was not even the slightest piece of evidence it… more was near by if exists at all.
what i actually wanted to say was, to answer the question of the this thread's creator, he was so convinced they would be save there for the same reason he was so convinced wellington is real.
Though I agree with the second bit... Michigan was a bad idea to begin with. Should have gone deeper south. In Alamaba, the only thing that eats you alive are the mosquitos.
Wellington was a known place unlike St. Johns Dairy Farm, even Christa was headed there. Lets be honest, taking the chance to send the kids in there gave them much better survival odds than staying out in the cold with Kenny.
Grasping at straws is basically what you resort to almost every single time. Otherwise, you're arguing on something that has no right answer. Which is pointless.
Grasping at straws is basically what you resort to almost every single time. Otherwise, you're arguing on something that has no right answer. Which is pointless.
You really need to educate yourself on how humans respond to trauma
I know how humans respond to trauma. Does this change that we ha… moreve every reason to think Wellington is not evil? Nope.
GRASPIN AT STRAWS DOOD argument.
You are acting like this is the only thing I have said.
Because Wellingtin looked safe with that giant wall, and that's all that Kenny wanted them to be, and he knew they weren't safe with him. If the people inside are good, that we can't say, but Edith gave a good impression that people there are nice too, like her.
Grasping at straws is basically what you resort to almost every single time. Otherwise, you're arguing on something that has no right answer. Which is pointless.
If that was really all that Kenny wanted, to be safe behind walls, then he would have stuck around at Howe's, instead of calling anyone who even suggested staying there completely insane right from the get-go.
Also, Edith was just one person. Of course in a community of hundreds of people you'll have a few that are nice, which was the case at Howe's as well. Doesn't mean the leader is not completely messed up in the head. In fact, having leaders of large communities that are completely messed up in the head is a very common Walking Dead theme.
Because Wellingtin looked safe with that giant wall, and that's all that Kenny wanted them to be, and he knew they weren't safe with him. If… more the people inside are good, that we can't say, but Edith gave a good impression that people there are nice too, like her.
Comments
It seemed pretty situational to be honest. I think they were cannibals but had no intention on eating the group. However when Mark was "injured." that changed, and they decided to eat him. If lee would of just ate dinner Larry might have been still alive.
I think that they expected the bandits to injury them so they would eat the group.
Well maybe, like if watch the cut scene when Mark is running back after being shot, one of the brothers i forget his name looks completely shocked when he sees them. That look alone, made me think this wasn't planned it just sort of happened. Like maybe they were going to treat his wounds, and started licking their fingers covered in his blood, and well.... couldn't help themselves, kind of like a Klondike bar.
EDIT:
people always talk of some better place in bad times.
jane was right. as always.
there was not even the slightest piece of evidence it was near by if exists at all.
what i actually wanted to say was, to answer the question of the this thread's creator, he was so convinced they would be save there for the same reason he was so convinced wellington is real.
And? That´s like saying people can aggree on a name-Wellington- and a place- Michingan- in the zombie apocalypse. There was not even a chance that Wellington was fake.
Known? You mean like Terminus?
Though I agree with the second bit... Michigan was a bad idea to begin with. Should have gone deeper south. In Alamaba, the only thing that eats you alive are the mosquitos.
Look, the point is that Wellington being good is far more plausible that Wellington being Evil. How is that so hard to understand?
Grasping at straws is basically what you resort to almost every single time. Otherwise, you're arguing on something that has no right answer. Which is pointless.
Because Wellingtin looked safe with that giant wall, and that's all that Kenny wanted them to be, and he knew they weren't safe with him. If the people inside are good, that we can't say, but Edith gave a good impression that people there are nice too, like her.
Look, the point is that Wellington being good is far more plausible that them being EVIL. How is that so hard to understand?
If that was really all that Kenny wanted, to be safe behind walls, then he would have stuck around at Howe's, instead of calling anyone who even suggested staying there completely insane right from the get-go.
Also, Edith was just one person. Of course in a community of hundreds of people you'll have a few that are nice, which was the case at Howe's as well. Doesn't mean the leader is not completely messed up in the head. In fact, having leaders of large communities that are completely messed up in the head is a very common Walking Dead theme.