It's quite more complicated then that.
I didn't shoot kenny because clementine has changed over the last two years, or because despite the fact that i never hated kenny, he wasn't exaculy a favorite.
I already knew he was broken, and then main reason i shot him was to save jane.(which i regretted, I should have known she was up to something) he would have kept attacking her. And I thought if the baby died, as he said before "what's the point in going on after that."
Or I suppose it was a dumb heat of the moment thing. I don't know. Like i said, it's complicated.
What do you mean you don't see how? Jane set Kenny up to be shot (In her defense she tried to settle down) and Kenny was trying to stab her through the throat. Jane didn't actually do anything wrong in that situation, bar lying. Kenny and Jane did as much wrong as the other, Kenny tried to murder her, and she set Kenny up to be shot by Clem so she'd have her for herself... neither can be excused for their crimes because they're both twisted and in the wrong.
Kenny wasn't just trying to "back away", Jane told him to leave and he refused, then if you get in between them as Clem and tell Kenny to stop he'll tell you that he won't.
Kenny could easily have ended it after she put away her knife.
I 100% think she put her knife away so Kenny would feel safer to atta… moreck her. Otherwise putting the knife away was pointless to what she was trying to accomplish in the first place. Otherwise she would be like: "Uhh... soo... yeah.... by the way the baby isn't actually dead. I just hid him away all alone in a truck just to piss you off as bad as I could. I guess you're harder to manipulate than I thought.."
He threw the first punch. And she put away her knife, and was then attacked again.
Yeah, he threw the first punch. That does not mean he was trying to kill her though. The worst thing he did before she went to kill mode was pinning her against the wall (like he did to Mike in Episode Three). She then smashed him in his bad eye hard enough to knock him to the ground, and proceeded to leap on him and attempted to land several blows to his face. He eventually … [view original content]
Kenny admitted that he was wrong and that Clem was right to shoot him.
I was disappointed with Jane's lie at the end though, one of the m… moreain reasons I picked her over Kenny was because I thought she got rid of the baby. Now we'll have to deal with that pain in the ass next season.
Come to think of it, this would count as a crime of passion, the same thing Lee was convicted for, as Lee said, sometimes good people do bad things, and saying that, Jane isn't any better or worse than Kenny. Kenny was obviously so angry with the mere idea of AJ being killed by Jane that he couldn't control himself, most crimes of passion are the same way. Truthfully if Jane hadn't been so ... anti-social as loners normally are and others had got to know her better, I'm pretty sure that fight would've never happened, but Jane and Kenny never really had a point where they got along and did get to know each other, which gave Jane the opening to fool him and Kenny the inability to see through it.
About the first punch thing, I should point out that Kenny threatens to murder Jane before she even stabs him or does anything remotely life… more threatening, and I really doubt he was making empty threats. He was fighting to kill, and for no justifiable reason.
As for the theory that Jane planned all along to murder Kenny, I completely agree that it doesn't make any sense.
"I know! I will provoke Kenny into attacking me by telling him that AJ died, despite the fact that I have no reason to believe that he would consider accidental death a substantial reason to outright murder someone. I will then put away my weapon and try to explain my case in order to further goad Kenny into killing me so that I in turn will be justified in murdering him. I will execute this convoluted plan even though it would be much simpler to just slit Kenny's throat when Clem wasn't looking and throw his body to some walkers to get rid of the evidence."
Like, what… [view original content]
Flog, what do you tell a crying little girl after she shoots you? Fuck you? xD He didn't have much else he could say.
I'm not too sure if he agreed with it or just saw the reasons she did shoot him... either way he could've easily been saying that just to help Clementine before he died.
I like how you worded it, but i'd word it as 'Jane is just as bad as Kenny', because in the end, Jane is the one made to look the most innocent out of the two, but it's easy for other people to overlook that with all of the Kenny fans.
Are you sure? It's insanely clear that Kenny was favoured by the writers. It's also fairly clear that they anted him to look the best with an ending that is much longer than the other two.
Besides, I only said "Kenny is just as bad as Jane" because Saoralba131 said Kenny and Luke are the only two good people.
I like how you worded it, but i'd word it as 'Jane is just as bad as Kenny', because in the end, Jane is the one made to look the most innocent out of the two, but it's easy for other people to overlook that with all of the Kenny fans.
Are you sure? It's insanely clear that Kenny was favoured by the writers. It's also fairly clear that they anted him to look the best with a… moren ending that is much longer than the other two.
Besides, I only said "Kenny is just as bad as Jane" because Saoralba131 said Kenny and Luke are the only two good people.
sigh There we go again... That actually sounds to me like "Fuck you for not choosing my ending! My opinion is right and the others are wrong!" Warmonger threads like this are pretty much the reason why I don't stick to TWD section anymore.
sigh There we go again... That actually sounds to me like "Fuck you for not choosing my ending! My opinion is right and the others are wrong!" Warmonger threads like this are pretty much the reason why I don't stick to TWD section anymore.
are you serious? you have been threatening and provoking people who call you out, and you say you beat the shit out of people who anger you. no, you're not violent, you're basically crazy.
Holy shit, that's actually kind of right. O.o I mean, see yourself being in his group and not being Clem, he would act towards you as Larry acted towards everyone else!
are you serious? you have been threatening and provoking people who call you out, and you say you beat the shit out of people who anger you. no, you're not violent, you're basically crazy.
What I mean is the people that didn't shoot him make themselves much more heard than those who did shoot him... probably half of the people who shot him arent even on these forums.
Comments
I thought people generally grow out of this kind of behavior after high school.
True lol
its my way of life
It's quite more complicated then that.
I didn't shoot kenny because clementine has changed over the last two years, or because despite the fact that i never hated kenny, he wasn't exaculy a favorite.
I already knew he was broken, and then main reason i shot him was to save jane.(which i regretted, I should have known she was up to something) he would have kept attacking her. And I thought if the baby died, as he said before "what's the point in going on after that."
Or I suppose it was a dumb heat of the moment thing. I don't know. Like i said, it's complicated.
Oh please. Kenny killed Larry, Lee could kill the Stranger, Andrew, Danny, bandits, Ben.
Doesn't mean Clementine is horrible for shooting Kenny.
Lee would be rather disappointed about Clementine's decision IF YOUR Lee always sided with him.
Lee would be more or less okay with Clementine's decision IF YOUR Lee was always siding against him.
Either way, Lee would understand as he's the one who said that sometimes you have to hurt people.
What do you mean you don't see how? Jane set Kenny up to be shot (In her defense she tried to settle down) and Kenny was trying to stab her through the throat. Jane didn't actually do anything wrong in that situation, bar lying. Kenny and Jane did as much wrong as the other, Kenny tried to murder her, and she set Kenny up to be shot by Clem so she'd have her for herself... neither can be excused for their crimes because they're both twisted and in the wrong.
Kenny wasn't just trying to "back away", Jane told him to leave and he refused, then if you get in between them as Clem and tell Kenny to stop he'll tell you that he won't.
It's just a Telltale trick to make you feel worse about your decision.
Don't worry Lee, I stuck with Kenny. I won't lie, it'll be rough over the next few months, but our family will always stay together.
Atleast you're honest on how far down your Clem has gone, and not arguing that your choice was right, only the safest.
+1
Come to think of it, this would count as a crime of passion, the same thing Lee was convicted for, as Lee said, sometimes good people do bad things, and saying that, Jane isn't any better or worse than Kenny. Kenny was obviously so angry with the mere idea of AJ being killed by Jane that he couldn't control himself, most crimes of passion are the same way. Truthfully if Jane hadn't been so ... anti-social as loners normally are and others had got to know her better, I'm pretty sure that fight would've never happened, but Jane and Kenny never really had a point where they got along and did get to know each other, which gave Jane the opening to fool him and Kenny the inability to see through it.
Flog, what do you tell a crying little girl after she shoots you? Fuck you? xD He didn't have much else he could say.
I'm not too sure if he agreed with it or just saw the reasons she did shoot him... either way he could've easily been saying that just to help Clementine before he died.
Kenny is my adoptive father now since Lee past, and ofcourse Clems real father.
I like how you worded it, but i'd word it as 'Jane is just as bad as Kenny', because in the end, Jane is the one made to look the most innocent out of the two, but it's easy for other people to overlook that with all of the Kenny fans.
I shot Kenny and I would do it again without even the half-second of hesitation I had the first time. Lee would want me to.
Are you sure? It's insanely clear that Kenny was favoured by the writers. It's also fairly clear that they anted him to look the best with an ending that is much longer than the other two.
Besides, I only said "Kenny is just as bad as Jane" because Saoralba131 said Kenny and Luke are the only two good people.
Exactly plus i did not want to kill kenny because he was from season 1 and passed many obstacles to be there to just die like that
Favoritism and innocence, two different things, and I agree.
I saved Kenny.
You cant "save" Kenny you can just let him commit murder
Kenny had turned into Larry by the finale he had to go.
I'm not a boy. You are violent and barbaric, grow up.
Comments like these are the reason why i'm barely ever on here anymore..
Kenny haters... keep walkin'
sigh There we go again... That actually sounds to me like "Fuck you for not choosing my ending! My opinion is right and the others are wrong!" Warmonger threads like this are pretty much the reason why I don't stick to TWD section anymore.
But really, did Kenny deserve to die?
He just called my nation eurotrash and commie fuckers, and that makes him super dead in my book lol. And I used to like this guy a lot.
IM NOT VIOLENT
You're Russian? It's interesting to see what someone who had that background thought of Kenny's behavior.
...sigh...
there's a difference between being a kenny hater and not agreeing with this idiotic thread
are you serious? you have been threatening and provoking people who call you out, and you say you beat the shit out of people who anger you. no, you're not violent, you're basically crazy.
116 upvotes
Faith in this forum lost.
OH, COME ON. LET THIS THREAD DIE ALREADYYYY. (I'm not helping, am I? ;-;)
she was the defender not the attacker...
Holy shit, that's actually kind of right. O.o I mean, see yourself being in his group and not being Clem, he would act towards you as Larry acted towards everyone else!
That is where you wrong. That is not violence nor crazyness, that is just taking care of business. So if someone bullies you, what do you do?
Its so strange it seems everyone on here saved Kenny when in fact 70% of players shot him. We really are just a minority of people on this forum.
Uh no, I shot him
What I mean is the people that didn't shoot him make themselves much more heard than those who did shoot him... probably half of the people who shot him arent even on these forums.