So what if Jane actually wanted to kill Kenny?
[Mod edit: In order to ensure civil discussion regarding the Pizza/Ice Cream choice, I have created a Civil Character Discussion Megethread. In order to ensure there is no drama, I am locking all other threads about the choice - old and new alike. Please keep discussion in the Civil Character Discussion Megathread. Thanks! - Blind Sniper]
The way i see, she wanted to kill him herself, she never wanted to Clem have to kill his friend. First Jane tested him and made him really mad so she could not only show his true colors to Clem but also have a reason to kill him without feeling bad about it, because she has her moral concerns, as shown when she ironically killed the russian about to kill Kenny and saving him (at the time she still believed that Kenny could turn around with Clem´s help), so Jane wanted to be sure about him first. Eventually things conveniently got out of her control so Clem could decide the fight.
Now, everybody thinks that Carver was a madman that could only stopped if killed (just killed, not necessarily in a brutal way), and Luke was a pussy for not wanting to shoot him etc., but what if people think the same way of Kenny? Kenny´s mental state only went downhill since S1, and while he still isn´t at Carver´s level, he is definitely getting there. If you disagree you are in denial by your loyalty to him just like Bonnie was about Carver´s evil nature at S2E3, because Bonnie, Mike and Jane all thought the same thing about Kenny and this is what broke the group apart.
With this in mind, i see no problem taking out someone that, while respects and protects me, for now at least, is harmful and dangerous to pretty much everyone else around him. Keeping him alive seems pretty selfish and Kenny wanted to die anyway.
Comments
This is another thread that I predict won´t go smoothly...
Stop hating on Jane Ryudi. We know how much you hate her OK.
Did you even read the thread
Well you know as the haters see her as an manipulative sneaky person, she would back stab Kenny in the back rather than get into a fight with an overpowering strong insane adult.
He clearly hates Jane. I want him to explain why he hates her so much.
I know man, but after the ending of this game i can´t find nothing else more interesting to discuss about here...
It would be interesting to discuss if people were more open to the concept of "opinions". But as it is...
The plan was originally to get Kenny to overreact and try to kill her, so Jane could kill him in self-defense. It almost worked to perfection...
If only Jane knew about the magical powers if Kennys beard. Cut the beard, slay Kenny.
I will say one good thing about the whole Kenny vs. Jane debacle, it allows me to post this gif more than necessary.
I really shouldn't comment on these threads but here I go anyway:
I don't view kenny as a person that was going insane. Danerous, yes, but not towards those he care about.