Did **** survive?

2

Comments

  • Yeah, but if there was 1 im sure Kenny would win. Luke didnt really seem strong to me, more like the guy that wanna talk it out.

    Blinx posted: »

    Because Luke would probably not harm Kenny for Clementines sake. But then again Luke wouldn't "abandon" the baby in the first place so there wouldn't be a fight. But if there was a fight...

  • Too soon

    prink34320 posted: »

    Luke is Frozen.

  • edited September 2014

    More importantly the water is colder than 32 degrees Fahrenheit/ 0 degrees Celsius. His core temperature would have dropped rapidly causing his organs to fail. The combination of freezing temperatures and drowning would have made it near impossible to revive him even with advanced medical intervention - simply pulling him out of the water isn't going to cut it.

    Kennysucks posted: »

    His mouth was open, at that point, even if he was unconsious, his lungs would be filling with water quickly and he'd be done

    1. The cold saps your strength.
    2. They can't use their full strength under water with no solid foundation to brace themselves against.
    3. You find the white hole in a sea of white when your eyes are being painfully chilled by the cold water.

    Ah. Nevermind then. One thing I don't get is, why didn't both Luke and Clem just come back up through the giant hole they fell through instead of trying to break through somewhere else?

  • Not a chance..

    We spent the night in the house, so even if he did get out of the water in some way he would have frozen on the ice, if we hadnt have stayed the night there is a slim chance TT could have gave him "I got lucky status" but no..... hes gone....

  • Fighting without thinking or talking things out doesn't make somebody strong, it makes them stupid.

    JuanNieves posted: »

    Yeah, but if there was 1 im sure Kenny would win. Luke didnt really seem strong to me, more like the guy that wanna talk it out.

  • But Kenny is very strong in season 2

    BipedalP posted: »

    Fighting without thinking or talking things out doesn't make somebody strong, it makes them stupid.

  • My point is that his willingness to fight without talking is not what makes him strong.

    Luke is pretty strong, too. He actually appeared to be larger than Kenny. Not to mention he still had his youth and he didn't have a fractured orbit.

    JuanNieves posted: »

    But Kenny is very strong in season 2

  • edited September 2014

    And? Kenny restrained Mike pretty easily in Episode 3 and knocks down Carver with a simple punch to the face. Also, his endurance seems to be better that Luke. He fought and won against Jane with a cut on his abdomen, no weapon and only one eye and still handled Jane easily. His reaction speed is good enough to dodge Jane´s slashes and he throws Jane back against the sign of the Rest Stop without much effort. Kenny would easily defeat Luke.

    BipedalP posted: »

    My point is that his willingness to fight without talking is not what makes him strong. Luke is pretty strong, too. He actually appeared to be larger than Kenny. Not to mention he still had his youth and he didn't have a fractured orbit.

  • Gets out of Ice Water
    Alt text
    Doesnt go to the house

  • edited September 2014

    I'd throw my Playstation out the window because that would just be too unrealistic and ridiculous.

    That's exactly what I thought when they crossed that silly lake when it was clearly walkable around the sides ;_;

    He's dead. If telltale brought him back alive, I'd throw my Playstation out the window because that would just be too unrealistic and ridiculous.

  • It's a failure on the part of the writers. One good shot to his fractured orbit would probably cause a brain hemorrhage or even cause a TBI.

    AlanSpencer posted: »

    And? Kenny restrained Mike pretty easily in Episode 3 and knocks down Carver with a simple punch to the face. Also, his endurance seems to

  • I think it actually started to heal, not sure tough. And yes what Alan said. Plus Carver messed up luke

    BipedalP posted: »

    It's a failure on the part of the writers. One good shot to his fractured orbit would probably cause a brain hemorrhage or even cause a TBI.

  • It's a failure on the part of the writers. One good shot to his fractured orbit would probably cause a brain hemorrhage or even cause a TBI.

    Yes, a shot. Did Jane shoot him? Nope.

    BipedalP posted: »

    It's a failure on the part of the writers. One good shot to his fractured orbit would probably cause a brain hemorrhage or even cause a TBI.

  • "Shot" as in a hit or punch. It's a colloquial term.

    AlanSpencer posted: »

    It's a failure on the part of the writers. One good shot to his fractured orbit would probably cause a brain hemorrhage or even cause a TBI. Yes, a shot. Did Jane shoot him? Nope.

  • His orbit had been fractured for less than 4 days. The bone would take more than a month if not several months to heal.

    JuanNieves posted: »

    I think it actually started to heal, not sure tough. And yes what Alan said. Plus Carver messed up luke

  • Luke and Nick went to heaven. or whatever.

    Alt text

  • Luke wouldn't have hidden the baby so there wouldn't have been a fight.

    BipedalP posted: »

    "Shot" as in a hit or punch. It's a colloquial term.

  • HAHAHAHAHA.
    funny...
    jk :P
    Also , I liek your profile pic

  • edited September 2014

    "Shot" as in a hit or punch. It's a colloquial term.

    Oh, really? Well, then, seeing Kenny´s eye looked better in No Going Back, maybe it actually got better.

    BipedalP posted: »

    "Shot" as in a hit or punch. It's a colloquial term.

  • His eye and the bone surrounding it are not the same thing. They are two separate injuries in a localized area. Soft tissue heals much faster than bone.

    AlanSpencer posted: »

    "Shot" as in a hit or punch. It's a colloquial term. Oh, really? Well, then, seeing Kenny´s eye looked better in No Going Back, maybe it actually got better.

  • Way to side-step the point.

    Kennyftw posted: »

    Luke wouldn't have hidden the baby so there wouldn't have been a fight.

  • So when Jane tried to poke his eyes out Kenny should have died?

    BipedalP posted: »

    His eye and the bone surrounding it are not the same thing. They are two separate injuries in a localized area. Soft tissue heals much faster than bone.

  • I want him to be alive but he's most likely dead

  • he did not survive unfortunately. luke was the only one in the cabin group besides pete that i could stand in the slightest way during my first playthrough i really feel like he deserved more justice then what he was given. shoulda been kenny vs luke in the end imo. hard choice would have been even harder

  • He should have at the very least been incapacitated. Aggravating that injury would have been debilitating at the least, potentially lethal at worst - likely lethal. If Luke had hit him in the eye it would likely result in massive brain trauma.

    AlanSpencer posted: »

    So when Jane tried to poke his eyes out Kenny should have died?

  • Kennys reaction
    Alt text

    BipedalP posted: »

    He should have at the very least been incapacitated. Aggravating that injury would have been debilitating at the least, potentially lethal at worst - likely lethal. If Luke had hit him in the eye it would likely result in massive brain trauma.

  • He really should have stopped at "I dunno what the fuck you're saying." If he doesn't know what the fuck I'm saying he can't know if it's bullshit or not.

    lee4life posted: »

    Kennys reaction

  • Yes he can.
    He's kenny.

    BipedalP posted: »

    He really should have stopped at "I dunno what the fuck you're saying." If he doesn't know what the fuck I'm saying he can't know if it's bullshit or not.

  • not possible hes was in freezing water for way to long

  • Do you see, Telltale? This is the result of you making Kenny survive the impossible.

    By this logic, CARVER is still alive. Proof? His body didn't get eaten in Jane's endings. He was just taking a nap.

    We'll see his faceless not-zombie in Season 3.

  • edited September 2014

    hE ISNT DEAD

    Alt text

  • Shit's getting dICEy

    prink34320 posted: »

    Well I guess it's time to break the ice.

  • Their reactions when playing episode 5 thin on ice and Luke "drowns"

    Luke and Nick went to heaven. or whatever.

  • Lee came down from heaven, used his badass-ness to save Luke, and will travel alongside him to find Clementine. Then, they will all live happily ever after. Calling it for season 3.

  • edited September 2014

    ^You get absolute zero points for that one.

    maxbear29 posted: »

    Shit's getting dICEy

  • I guess things are starting to heat up ;)

    ^You get absolute zero points for that one.

  • I don't get why people watch cartoon's....

    torkahn808 posted: »

    Believe me, I know its hard but you just gotta...

  • Luke: shivering W-w-well lon-long story s-s-s-s-short shivering intensifies I-I-I go-go-got lu-lu-luc-lucky... falls down onto the ground in a permanent shivering state

    Clem: Luke!!!

    The Shivering Life: Season 1/
    Episode 1:Shiver me Timbers

  • Game of the Year.

    HurlyBurly posted: »

    Luke: shivering W-w-well lon-long story s-s-s-s-short shivering intensifies I-I-I go-go-got lu-lu-luc-lucky... falls down onto the ground in a permanent shivering state Clem: Luke!!! The Shivering Life: Season 1/ Episode 1:Shiver me Timbers

Sign in to comment in this discussion.