What are some choices you regret?
The choices I regret is stealing food from the car in S1EP2 and chopping Sarita's arm off
And if you're gonna mention Kenny vs Jane choices, please keep it civil.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
The choices I regret is stealing food from the car in S1EP2 and chopping Sarita's arm off
And if you're gonna mention Kenny vs Jane choices, please keep it civil.
Comments
None.
I chose to lie to Walter which i really regret, thankfully i still managed to save Nick by telling Walter that he is a good man.
I regret staying to watch Kenny kill Carver (because my initial goal was to keep Clem as innocent as possible but I just hated Carver so much!) and I regret not staying at Wellington (because it is the best thing for Clem as she will be able to live a normal life for a while) but in the end I'll still stick with my original choices.
Lots.... All of these are from my first playthrough.
I regret crushing Larry's head.
I regret killing both of the St. Johns.
I regret stealing the supplies.
I regret fighting Kenny.
I regret making Kenny shoot the walker in the attic.
I regret hiding my bite.
I regret killing the stranger in front of Clem.
I regret agreeing to Kill Roberto.
I regret watching Kenny kill Carver.
I regret chopping off Sarita's arm.
I regret Killing Kenny.
And I definitely regret going with Jane.
I regret helping Kenny kill Larry
But then again, Kenny never thoroughly plans out shit..
I regret siding with Kenny over Lilly.. But then again, asshole Larry makes it hard to side with Lilly.
For what it's worth you saved Boyd's life by killing Roberto.
I regret hiding to the side of the road.
I regretted a lot of choices. In some ways, I think the best choices in Walking Dead are the ones I regret - those no win situations. If it's a 'good choice' vs 'bad choice', I get less satisfaction. I love those choices where I cringe afterwards. The only exception was Sarita's arm choice and that's I think (am I remembering correctly?) because the results weren't shown until the next episode and I came out of that feeling it was a little cheap. I may have felt entirely different had the outcome been shown then and there.
In particular, I regretted a whole bunch of choices in 400 Days almost as soon as I made the choice. Especially in Shel's story. I almost restarted the whole thing because of what I did in her story.
In Season 2, I definitely regretted letting Kenny kill Carver. That was a dark moment. Oddly enough, my Clem kind of went on a journey of redemption after that. She was a far nicer person by the end of Season 2 compared with Clem in early Season 2. A good character arc.
I felt regret many time, but the one that I regret the most is chopping off Sarita's arm. I wanted to help so desperately that I've made a big fuckin mistake. Kenny was actually right, I felt like a stupid kid for doing that.
Feed Sam in season 2 episode 1
I majorly regret chopping Sarita's arm off. I thought the outcome would be good, but in all reality, it was the shittiest decision I have ever made in this game.
I regret every single nice thing i've said to Jane.
( no kenny vs jane arguments pls :c )
Me too.
Can't believe i've sided with her almost the entire episode 5...
I regret taking stealing stealing the supplies from the stranger's van.
I regret keep lying to Clem about her parents finding Lee and Clem.
I regret that I made Lee cut off his arm, in front of everyone else.
I regret chopping off Sarita's arm.
I regret I couldn't help Sarah. I didn't hate her like other people did but I choice not to slap her because I saw her father forced to slap her by Carver's hand, and her being shocked / depressed afttwards, and here that choice comes up again by the one people that has promise to be friends with her. I didn't want to leave her but I really think that it wouldn't help.
I regret cutting of Sarita's arm
I regret killing Kenny (and don't worry Kenny fans, I didn't forgive Jane she forced my hand to prove a point that I already know, there was no chance that I would forget her after that. I got the alone ending)
The only choice I truly regret is dropping Ben. I've always viewed that as my greatest failure in the series, even factoring in Season 2's choices. It's the only one I would go back and change if I weren't so anal about living with my decisions.
Two other choices would be shooting Kenny and giving Victor the water. The Howe's ending with Jane was good enough when I let the family in, but I preferred the Wellington endings after seeing them. As for Victor, I chose to go with Pete at the end of Episode 1 and when I discovered that you could give Pete water if you didn't give any to Victor I actually got a little upset that that scumbag got water instead of Pete, a true hero. So in all subsequent playthroughs of Season 2, Victor gets the honor of fucking right off with his "I'm dying, give me water and ease my pain" shit. You're not Pete. You don't deserve it.
Honestly, I don't really regret any of my choices.
I regret trying to help Kenny in S2E3, because Clem had to get a huge smack in the face for it...
I also regret not going with my original choice of not making a choice of a time to leave at the end of S2E4, because I really wanted to remain neutral at the end of that episode.
I kind of also regret not choosing the alone ending originally.
And I don't know if these count as choices, but in season 1 I didn't complete the battery puzzle, because I couldn't find the other battery, then I forgot to tell Lilly about Lee's past before we left the Motor Inn, and I didn't have time to go and get the animal crackers for Duck.
Otherwise, no regrets.
Watch Kenny kill Carver. This is the only one.
None honestly. I feel bad about some of them, like letting Sarah die. That will always eat at me, but no matter what, we keep finding something worth surviving for. I've struggled alot with surviving this season. But like I told her, I swear.
Alot of folks have mentioned Sarita. I, too, took her arm, and then I axed her face. They both seemed like the right moves at the time. I was genuinely concerned that Kenny would just sit there until he got chomped.
Knowing what I know now, both were wholly unnecessary. Both Hershel and Reggie got carried off to a safe place with some small modicum of medical capability before their amputations. Neither did Lee try and pull that stunt right in the middle of a herd. In retrospect, not realizing that giving her the chop had zero chance of accomplishing anything other than turning her into a giant walker lure was extraordinarily short-sighted. Also, had I thought Kenny's position through from a programming possibility perspective (oooh...alliteration) I would have realized that either he was going to get up regardless of what I did, or that his death warrant had already been signed by TTG. You can't think like that in-game, though, or you suck all the fun out of it.
Here's the thing. I think back on it from Sarita's perspective and I feel SO BAD. Think about, in the heat of the moment, how it looked to her. This sweet 11 year old girl just up and goes all "Mike Myers" on her ass. I worry to her it seemed like my thought process was "La-dee-da-dee-dah... Oh, hey! I' ve got this hatchet. I think I'll go ahead and murder that lady with it." Poor thing. She must've been so confused. It eats me up every time I think about it.
I don't really regret the decisions I've made in both the games, but if there was one decision I would have undone, it would be watching Kenny kill Carver. No real need in watching that, but gosh darnit, I wanted to see Carver get it so badly! XD
Killing Kenny in my first playthrough.
What episode was that?
I regret leaving duck hanging.. (I didnt high five him)
Letting Kenny kill Jane.
Getting Alvin killed.
Not getting Bonnie killed.
Episode 5.
I regret dropping Ben from the Crawford Belltower.
The way Kenny worded my actions back at the manor, with Clem in earshot, made it seem like I did it to lessen a burden on the group - when in reality I had let Ben influence me and make the decision that hangs over me as a sliver of guilt even now. He was Clem's friend if anything, so I should have MADE him live even if it was just for her. He was in no mental state to make such a judgement on his own life, and yet, I did as he asked as he was possibly right.
It doesn't matter if Ben asked to be dropped. In that moment, given everything I'd witnessed in the game so far, I made a concious decision to drop him to his death. Is this applicable to real life? If so, what kind of person am I to do that?
Watching Kenny beat Carver's face in.
Near the end when Kenny was beating Arvo and I tried to stop him he looks back at me and through gritted teeth says "What's the matter? Lost your taste for this sort of thing?"
It was fucking creepy, and made me realize that Luke wasn't out of line for flipping out on me earlier in the season. It made me realize that most of the people probably thought that my Clem was a bit twisted. The truth is that I wanted to make damn sure Carver was dead. I "did" also want to watch him die, but the social stigma that comes attached to being okay with watching that is why I regret the choice.
If I play through again I'll probably leave with Sarita.
Also, if we're talking "metagaming" once I realized that objecting to taking the supplies from the abandoned car was considered "not stealing" and that we wouldn't all die from that choice, objectively I understand that not "stealing" (achem, note; taking from an abandoned vehicle) the supplies is the "better" choice, but only because of the foreknowledge as to how the game plays out.