How Everyone SHOULD Have Died.
I will ask you guys how you think 5 characters Should have died.
How Should Lee Have Died?
How Should Ben Have Died?
How Should Luke Have Died?
How Should Rebecca Have Died?
How Should Sarah Have Died?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
meteor.
How he did.
How he did.
Shouldn't have. shakes fist
How she did.
I dunno.
Lee: That way.
Ben: I dunno.
Luke: He didn't. He got lucky. Real lucky.
Rebecca: That way.
Sarah: In the shootout with the Russians. And Carlos shouldn't have died before Sarah.
hmm thats intersting...
me. i think,
Lee: After Getting Clem out and giving her his watch for her Birthday.
Ben: The Way Kenny Went Out in S1 Except while saving clem from the stranger, by trying to kill him while they escaped and they both die.
Luke: Being Trapped in a Cellar in a DLC with either Bonnie or Jane and kissing her and saying he loves her and then creating a path so she can escape.
Rebecca: She Just Shouldnt Have Died, That is all.
Sarah: Finally Learning How to Survive And Minutes Later Saving Clem.
I was perfectly fine with all of their deaths except luke, he deserved better
Actually Luke's last act (determinant if you went to him) was saving Clem. He's already close to the surface when they fall in, but he looks down and see Clem stuck with the walker. He goes back down straightaway with no hesitation and wrestles the walker away. Of course, somehow the walker grabbed his leg. Luke "died" in the same way he met Clem. He saved her each time.
True I covered Luke and he did save Clem, but idk what I just feel like they could have had Luke save Clem in a way that felt "better" the way they killed off Luke just felt like to me a way to Bring in the FEELZ
Lee: Original death
Ben: Original death
Luke: Doesn't die, becomes one of the possible ending options
Rebecca: Original death
Sarah: Dies in shootout, or while trying to save Luke
Lee:Original Death
Ben:Episode 5 death
Luke:Survives Episode 5 regardless of endings
Rebecca:Original Death
Sarah:Shootout
Well...yeah. Luke was honestly the only logical dude and the one keeping everyone together. Luke was always a good dude. With Luke gone, why would Bonnie want to stick around Kenny? Mike already had his attraction to Arvo. And, to me if it came between Kenny and Luke, I would have picked Luke with no hesitation. It just sucks so much.
*Lee: original
*ben: episode 5 death
*Sarah:i'll take anything over both her deaths
*luke: magically comes back to life
* Rebecca: original
I'm fine with all of them except Sarah. She should have died in the shootout.
Did most people find the "Leave Sarah" death bad too? I understand if you "save" her, but I thought her first death was fine...
Honestly, realistically someone from the group should have died in the shootout. Sarah and/or Nick could have filled that role.
I wish Lee would've lived to see Season 2 and beyond.
Pretty much this
Nick: Alive with Clem.
Luke: Alive with Clem.
Pete: Alive with Clem.
Carlos: Alive with Clem.
Sarah: Alive with Clem.
Alvin: Alive with Clem
Rebecca: Alive with Clem.
Baby: Alive with Clem
How Should Lee Have Died?
-He should have been bitten by a random walker. He then should have had the option to chop his arm off to try and stop the infection only to have done it too late. He should then spend the little amount of time he has left saving Clementine's life. Then she and he should become trapped in a shed and she should have been forced to either chain him up and leave him to turn or to shoot him to keep him from turning.
How Should Ben Have Died?
-Ben should have had a near fall in the Bell Tower and Lee should have caught him by the arm. Ben should have asked Lee to drop him and Lee should have had the option to do that. If Lee doesn't drop him then Ben should later on be the last to make a precarious jump only to fall and get impaled down below.
How Should Luke Have Died?
-Luke should have fallen into an iced over lake as the group was crossing it. Clementine should have the option to be smart and stay back, in which case Bonnie gets him killed like a dumbass. Clementine then should have the option to try and break the ice to get him out, only to fall in herself and see him drowned. Or, instead of Bonnie being the dumbass that got him killed Clem should have the option to be stupid and go towards him, sealing his fate. The "choices" screen should accurately reflect these choices.
How Should Rebecca Have Died?
-Rebecca should have died shortly after giving birth to AJ due to complications that modern doctors might have been able to deal with (but you know... ZA...).
How Should Sarah Have Died?
-Sarah should have had a mental breakdown after her dad got shot. Clementine and the group should have had the option to leave her behind when walkers are closing in on them all, or Clem should have had the option to convince her to go with them. If Sarah made it then she should have become trapped under some debris later with zombies approaching. Clementine should have the option to ask Jane to try and save Sarah, but even if she does try it should have been futile.
I thought it was kind of weird... The camera angle and how the walkers were attacking her just didn't seem natural at all to me.
You know, those are pretty decent... With the exception of the last one.
When sarah died at the lookout i said as clem: you didnt even wanna help her jane, you BITCH! thats an option on the PC
wow like all of those were the exact same deaths except for lee and sarahs death.
i HATED the fact that sarah died, because my clem was like a lee to her
Thanks
It took me forever to come up with them all on my own.
Ok, so for Sarah, maybe... maybe all this happens when Rebecca is in the middle of having her baby and the group is fighting off a hoard of walkers that are about to get them. Maybe they are all on a deck. Clem and Luke are pushing a cannon, or something, across the deck to try and brace an entry way when the deck gives and THAT'S when Sarah falls and becomes trapped under the debris. Jane also falls, but Luke and Clem catch her arms. Jane tells Clem to pull her up, but then Clem has the option to tell Jane to help Sarah. If Jane does go down to help Sarah a plank cracks and hits her on the head when she's trying to free Sarah from the debris, and the walkers close in on Sarah. Even with Jane trying her best, she just can't manage to get her out in time and is forced to climb up what's left of the deck.
Would that be better?
Your face is the exact same death except for Lee and Sarah's death :P
I worked really hard on these!
You really don't like them? cries
i like them dont worry!
you've got it all wrong.
They just seem alike... theyre good though
Lee: Same way. Season 1 wouldn't have the same emotional effects if Lee hadn't died how he did.
Ben: I always have thought that he should've been able to redeem himself in some way. Maybe, instead of Kenny shooting Ben, Ben distracted the walkers and Kenny disappeared then? I don't know.
Luke: I think that he should be a determinant character instead of dead, but he lives or dies based on the previous actions Clementine has made. Nick shouldn't have died in the fence, and would die in the shootout depending on whether or not you saved the baby or not, and if he was still alive at the lake, he would save Luke from dying at the lake at the expense of his own life. Luke would then go missing in the snowstorm, and everyone would be left guessing if he is alive or dead.
Rebecca: Same way.
Sarah: Instead of dying in the rubble (which made no sense whatsoever, she fell after the deck did.), she is either saved or killed. In the shootout, she either dies or lives depending on whether you taught her to defend herself or not. If she's still alive after the shootout, she takes the place of being shot by Arvo, because she goes outside to find out what the noise was, just like Clem, but Arvo thinks its Kenny, and Sarah is shot in the chest and is doomed to die. If Luke is also alive, he puts down Sarah, but if he's not then Clem does, in a scene similar to Lee/Kenny putting Duck down in season 1.
I just think Ben deserved a chance to redeem himself more, and episode 4 and 5 of s2 should've been more impacted by previous choices.
Eboli, decapitation or diabetes
I get what jane means when she says we cant save her if she won't let us, but i hate how jane assumes that sarah is like her sister. And when it comes to sarah, jane was in no position to decide if sarah should be left behind. So after the r.v. Scene, i kinda hated jane.
Lee's death should be unchanged, Ben's would have to still be being dropped, Rebecca should have fallen into the ice instead of Luke (without AJ), Sarah should have been bitten on the Observation Deck, then either left behind or killed before or at the ice. Luke shouldn't have died.
I think Ben's redemption is determinant. If you save Ben and only go with Ben and fail the jump, Ben saves your life.
Also if you don't fire any bullets in the hallway, when Ben gives you back the gun you can later give it to Kenny to defend himself in the alley, or you keep the weapon and if you strangle the Stranger, you can shoot him to prevent reanimation.
Lee: Same
Ben: Same
Luke: Left unknown after season 2, separated from the group, and returns in Season 3. If he absolutely had to die, I feel like he had a good death scene, so same.
Rebecca: Same.
Sarah: Her determinant death in E4, if you saved her she runs into the woods when Clem gets shot in E5 (unknown).
Luke is the only death I really struggle with. I knew he was going to die at some point so that didn't surprise me. It was the execution (pardon the pun) that bothered me. As soon as Kenny was reintroduced, I was expecting to have to choose between Luke and Kenny. Many people are upset about Sarah and I didn't like that she never redeems herself. But their would be some people simply incapable of coping with such an extreme situation.
For all of them: never.
Lee: Original (Had more feeling)
Ben: Should've died right there when Lily threatened him
Luke: Original (Felt like it was suppose to happen, pls dnt h8)
Rebecca: Died from Pregnancy (Original...)
Sarah: Bitten...put her out of her misery....
How Should Lee Have Died?
The same, even though I wish he could've gotten out of Savannah with Clem first.
How Should Ben Have Died?
Same. His death made me sad, but still the same.
How Should Luke Have Died?
ಠ_ಠ
No, stupid, plot device lakes!
Alive or determinant or unknown, but preferably alive!
How Should Rebecca Have Died?
Same.
How Should Sarah Have Died?
First death same, second death I'd of left to the last episode. Say if Sarah failed to keep coping after losing her dad and gave up on living, where within a scene Clem had to tried convincing her not to shoot herself [like being foreshadowed with Sarah putting the gun to her head in Episode 2 if Clem remains mute] that or she exited out from the group by some other means like with Mike and Bonnie and is left unknown.
Pretty much agree with this. To be honest, the only death I had a real problem with was Luke's because it just sort of happened. Now in a way that goes with the depressingly bleak feel of season 2 so I'm not going to say it was wrong to have happened but I guess I wanted more weight to it.
I think my bigger issues with Luke's death and Sarah's too for me is that I felt the reactions of the other characters weren't nearly strong enough. Certainly nobody seemed to care a damn about Sarah, which felt odd.