Should they add a torture scene?

I think they should. It would give the game a chance to go in a direction it would never could go before. What do you think?

«13

Comments

  • Well, with the way Carver turned out... it's only going to get darker, so I think a torture scene would be interesting but only if it was for the right reasons.

  • Maybe they hold clem down and force her to watch them torture someone with fire.

    Kateis posted: »

    Well, with the way Carver turned out... it's only going to get darker, so I think a torture scene would be interesting but only if it was for the right reasons.

  • I don't really see the need. But If there had to be one, only as long as Clementine wasn't the one doing it.

  • Yes though I think our group should do it for it to be more dramatic, there's a reason for it however it a how far are you willing to go kind of thing

  • I mean like a group of twisted people held clem down and forced her to watch.

    Grafite posted: »

    I don't really see the need. But If there had to be one, only as long as Clementine wasn't the one doing it.

  • That would be disturbing, but I've seen worse so... Anyway it would be intriguing to play.

    lee4life posted: »

    Maybe they hold clem down and force her to watch them torture someone with fire.

  • I wouldn't do it. Watching torture is one thing, being the torturer is another. I won't make my Clem become that.

    lee4life posted: »

    I mean like a group of twisted people held clem down and forced her to watch.

  • That could be a really sad character death. Get us attached to someone and then force us to watch them get tortured.

    lee4life posted: »

    Maybe they hold clem down and force her to watch them torture someone with fire.

  • No I don't mean clem is being the torturer. She is being forced to watch her friend be tortured while they people who are doing it force clem to watch.

    Grafite posted: »

    I wouldn't do it. Watching torture is one thing, being the torturer is another. I won't make my Clem become that.

  • I agree.

    That could be a really sad character death. Get us attached to someone and then force us to watch them get tortured.

  • I don't think I would be able to watch if I got attached to a character and then have to watch them die a horrible death...

    That could be a really sad character death. Get us attached to someone and then force us to watch them get tortured.

  • That's exactly why telltale would implement it! They feed on your feels , without it they die...

    Kateis posted: »

    I don't think I would be able to watch if I got attached to a character and then have to watch them die a horrible death...

  • You know that story can be dark without cruelty, right?

  • Get with the times... Torture is clearly the superior weapon... :P

    fallandir posted: »

    You know that story can be dark without cruelty, right?

  • They can't have anymore of my feels, I'm never getting attached again!

    lee4life posted: »

    That's exactly why telltale would implement it! They feed on your feels , without it they die...

  • Telltale inserts character that you inevitably get attached to and then he dies from torture

    Kateis posted: »

    They can't have anymore of my feels, I'm never getting attached again!

  • I think it will be done terribly.

  • edited October 2014

    You mean a torture scene likkkeeee.....Maggie? In the comics?

  • I have not read the comics.

    You mean a torture scene likkkeeee.....Maggie? In the comics?

  • then he dies

    He? What if he's a she... Still, I won't get attached again :P

    lee4life posted: »

    Telltale inserts character that you inevitably get attached to and then he dies from torture

  • What if it's luke? He somehow survived and then that happens to him. Will you be attached?

    Kateis posted: »

    then he dies He? What if he's a she... Still, I won't get attached again :P

  • It's not.

    lee4life posted: »

    Get with the times... Torture is clearly the superior weapon... :P

  • -___________________________________________________________________________________________________________-

    fallandir posted: »

    It's not.

  • Yea... I mean no, no... Luke is already dead, I was trying so hard to not think about me being attached to him, but then you mention him...

    lee4life posted: »

    What if it's luke? He somehow survived and then that happens to him. Will you be attached?

  • He's all fine and dandy now , when I saw him I had shivers up my spine. He layed a cool joke on me.

    Kateis posted: »

    Yea... I mean no, no... Luke is already dead, I was trying so hard to not think about me being attached to him, but then you mention him...

  • Don't you start this. I always say 'Cool' to compliment something but now? I can't say it without thinking of Luke :(
    Anyway we are getting off topic, lets stay with the idea of a torture scene.

    lee4life posted: »

    He's all fine and dandy now , when I saw him I had shivers up my spine. He layed a cool joke on me.

  • Ok. So they're torturing luke with fire.

    Kateis posted: »

    Don't you start this. I always say 'Cool' to compliment something but now? I can't say it without thinking of Luke Anyway we are getting off topic, lets stay with the idea of a torture scene.

  • If done tastefully and not just for traumatizing the player, then sure.

  • I would die inside... It would be ironic, almost dying from drowning/the cold and then dying slowly in a fire...

    lee4life posted: »

    Ok. So they're torturing luke with fire.

  • Oh well.

    Kateis posted: »

    I would die inside... It would be ironic, almost dying from drowning/the cold and then dying slowly in a fire...

  • I actually think making the player do something like that would be really good. Have it be that you need information that if you don't get it maybe AJ would die. It's Clem and some other survivor who've got this guy hostage. If you're too easy on the guy he'll give you pretty meh and vague information at best that will cause someone to die down the line. You're too hard and pretty much beat him to death then you get the same result. The only way to do well is to make Clem do something horrible but not fully give in, I think that'd be a cool as hell scene.

  • Didn't Carver torture Carlos and Alvin?

  • waiting for season 3 torture because it's far worse.

  • I mean like on a bigger scale. We see it.

    Didn't Carver torture Carlos and Alvin?

  • More like in TLOU or Reseirvour Dogs?

    IMO that's unnecessary.

    lee4life posted: »

    I mean like on a bigger scale. We see it.

  • I have not seen either of those games...

    More like in TLOU or Reseirvour Dogs? IMO that's unnecessary.

  • I like your logic

    ABigBadWolf posted: »

    If they add it, cool...if they don´t, cool.

  • If they add it, cool...if they don´t, cool.

  • Such soon , very wait , many season 3

Sign in to comment in this discussion.