which form of death upset you more ( not WHO dies, but the way it happened)
EP 201 left me upset for dont have kat with me. i never accepted their way of death. She seems so stronger with Duck's fate and them BANG, commits suicide. i understand she die for kenny development, and people can hide your problems and seem more stronger tham really are. i know killing your own son can broke everyone. But Kat was so strong 
FUNNIEST PART IS :
in my first gameplay I CHOOSE KAT FOR KILL HER SON, BECAUSE I DONT WANT TO DO THAT AND WAS THINKING KENNY WAS GOING TO KILL HIMSELF ( oops LOL )because he seems more emotional than kat. I have to rewind it when kat dies and personaly kill duck for kenny dont blame me for kat death. i was shocked.
Another thing that is funny is : KAT IS A VET. SO SHE CAN TELL THE DIFERENCE BETWEEN A DOG BIT AND A WALKER BITE * cough you hear me carlos? cough*
i cant resist
if kat had survived with clementine in the end, she could saved clementine of beeing locked in a shed.
Carlos : UR DUR i cant tell if its a walker bite or a dog bite, lets lock her in the shed
Kat :BACK OFF! im the vet here and you are a stupid doctor,obviously this is a dog bite. how the hell you became a doctor
~~ Rebecca opens your fucking mouth
Kat : AND YOU NEVER, EVER, HURT THAT GIRL, YOU HEAR ME, STUPID BITCH?
- millions of claps of all the players for kat being a badass here
my reaction : WOAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH CLAP , CLAP CLAP. I LOVE U KAT 
but they had to kill her 
- I DONT HATE BECA AND CARLOS, JUST IN THE BEGINNING. I liked them after that
Comments
Pete for me, but I know everyone in their mama is gonna say Nick and Sarah.
Matthew... Matthew... Matthew.
Carley. I wanted to blow Lilly's head off afterwards.
Yeah, Kat's death was pretty devastating for me as well seeing as I also supported her being the one to end Duck. That scene is a lot more shocking with that choice because you have no idea what happened until you get there. If Lee offers to do it, or says Kenny should, you hear Kenny shout no after the gunshot and you know something went wrong. If Kat goes alone, you assume she killed Duck and once you get there you get the full emotional impact all at once.
Luke falling in the perfectly avoidable ice.
I keep saying this but...come on. ;_;
Sarah's death. Both versions. Hearing her scream for her father is just...
...yeah.
I really hated Charles' death. I mean, he just appears in the sewers, dead, after sacrificing his life for the group! Tottaly disappointed...
Dem feels man...
Sarah, because in her second death scene Bonnie only protects her for two seconds and doesn't fire the weapon again even though there were no signs of it being empty.
Plus, she was trapped, calling out for her dad that would never come to her aid. There's nothing worse to my ears to hear someone cry out for help and have nobody come.
Also Beatrice if you leave her behind. Sounds like she was being nibbled on like an apple for a few minutes.
Lee's - From the moment he was bitten, you knew he was dead, and no-one could do anything. A feeling of hopelessness and helplessness washed over you. Even if you saved Clem, you knew you'd have to say goodbye, you knew the good times between the two wouldn't last for much longer. Despite this build up and knowing what would happen, when it did, it still destroyed us.
Basically all the deaths that were pure shock value and added nothing to anything.
Edit: I didn't read the OP properly lol.
SO the most horrible deaths were...
EDIT again: I forgot Troy. Ouch.
Any character who gets eaten alive, but Sarah in particular because it's an especially cruel, unfair fate for her when men as vile as Carver suffer relatively merciful deaths. Having a panic attack during her last moments, falling and being forsaken by her 'friends', wanting so desperately to live - yeah, it hurts.
I suppose Troy's death was probably more painful, but fuck that guy.
Katjaa's death actually bugged me because I somehow doubt a loving mother would kill herself right before her son's eyes. You may rationalize it by saying she's not thinking straight (obviously), and that she didn't want to see Kenny/Lee kill her son or abandon him, but it just bothers me that she gave her son one last trauma in his final moments.
I think for me it would be Sarah's death for reasons that have already been stated before. I think the characters could've done more to save her when she fell from the deck and her death was one of the most horrible deaths I've seen so far in the game.
Carley/Doug. Both of them had so much potential in a ZA but fucking Lilly ended it for them over some stupid argument.
NEVERFORGET
Nick, when he died, it felt like something was missing.
Nick's second death was kinda lacklustre. I expected them to do more with him. Compared to Ben's second death, Ben got more dialogue and his character had more impact on the story along with his death. Nick's one was a quick 'annnnd now he's dead.' made harder that you're forced to chop up his face, and then have Jane pass Clem that screwdriver, all like "Yeah I could've given you this three swings ago, but that's life girl." poor Clem, if Jane had been written as a joker, that would've been the meanest thing she could've ever done! But there's a lot more they could've done with Nick, if at least given him a bit more of death that played into the main storyline. Even if he'd died trying to help the others out of the motor home place, that would've been something. I definitely would've cheered if he'd gone down saving them, in a really big "You go man! You go and die for Clem and country! I'll miss you buddy! ;_;"
Sarah's second death again like Nick's, was poor. Hers too was a quick 'okay gotta get her out the way' that really could've been handled better to end her character arc as tragic as the first death. But sadly it's just felt very rushed and just made a bunch of adults look stupid who simply watched on and let that girl die instead of jumping down to pull her out. [That's right I'm looking at you Mike! If you can pick up two huge jugs of water, then you can help Jane hold up that wreckage and pull poor Sarah out! >.< and Bonnie and Luke, you could've covered with some firepower guys.] Unlike Nick, Sarah didn't have to be as active within the group with decision making since she's still a kid, so they could've kept her for the finale and given her an equally tragic death as before.
Bonnie's death [if you don't break the ice] again like the others, her death just seemed very meaningless and nobody in the group really cared. All those scenes with her, giving the sad puppy eyes and saying how sorry she is for everything...it's like, her purpose or development just seemed to go nowhere in the end, other than 'Luke is my pickle, I love my pickle! How dare you do nothing to save my pickle!' if you did break the ice. Speaking of which is that why she got anti wrinkle cream since her last appearance? Because Bonnie had a hell of a lot more in 400 Days o.O can't a guy like a gurl with wrinkles?
But Luke, his death was the terrible and I'm still frustrated about it. The whole set up to the lake was really poorly handled because people with the right sense of mind would not cross a frozen lake when there is clearly a path around it and when they have a baby with them [and even if there wasn't an easy way on land, they could've just walked around the edge of the ice so there's less deep water to fall into and makes it easier to get out] and why would they see sense to listen to the kid being held captive, who's group they killed and clearly would like to get away from Kenny sometime soon. Why not go up an active volcano while they're at it? There is NO reason at all to the cross the ice, that I wished they made it a river because that would've made much more sense, because then they really do have no choice.
Then you got Bonnie having no common sense to lesson her weight by dumping her backpack to go help, Luke having no sense to spread out his weight as well and dump that silly gun he keeps carrying that's probably adding more weight to him. Heck, he's loaded with weapons! It's no wonder the ice cracked in the first place. And then Clem having no sense to jump on the ice? I mean if she's going to go all suicide trying to break it anyway with the gun, why not just hop up and down on the ice because she falls in either way, it sure would've helped Luke in getting some air, and if Jane can pull Clem out and Bonnie can climb out like a polar bear, then Luke could roll out like a wounded seal with that's logic of survival in this game o_o. And don't even get me started on the group watching from the shore, who have no brains to go inside the house and go look for something that they could've used as rope and perhaps to go help them.
Are you seeing the problem here I can't get over? T_T Seriously, Richard's death in Resident Evil 1 is better than what Luke, Bonnie, Sarah and Nick got!
Rebecca, be carefuuuuuul
...Aw dang it, I'm out of RE1 deaths references ;_;
Chuck's. :<
Luke's. I have a fear of drowning.
Nicks death in s2e4. Any kind of off screen death for major/semi major character makes me mad
To be fair, I don't think Duck was really conscious of anything at that point. Still a terrible outcome for everyone involved though.
As far as the physical manner in which they died?
Chuck dieing alone and forgotten in the sewers was a pretty depressive fate in season one. Along with Mark being dismembered and left to bleed out with full knowledge that he was being fed to children...
And again, Sarah's fate. Crying for help, clear desire to be saved, clear and logical opportunity for the group to help her, only for her to be left to be eaten alive and forgotten.
Luke's death, why I understand that one choice means you try to save him and the other doesn't, everyone didn't think you save - bonnie gets pissed off at you. In both cases you did save him 1: reach out to pull him up, ice breaks and both Luke and Clem fall into the water. 2: you cover him and Bonnie jumps into trying save him and they both fall into the water. the most logical choice is to drop the ground spread your weight crawl off the cracked ice slowly. Tecnorly in both cases Clem saves Luke its just one you get praszed for and other you get hate for even through Bonnie made the moment worse. couldn't tell-tale do something like save or just walk away, make it more clear cut. As it ends up the choice is both "I will save him in a different way". look if you make a change during last moment your writing the episode, this character needs to die not other that was originally planned at least make a clear cut choice what happens to the character, you will get less hate afterwards from the fans of the character.
Omid died mins in the 2nd series, he deserved a lot more T_T
Hmm...
Omid, Nick, Sarah, Luke. Most of them were avoidable (bring the gun with you so Omid isn't shot, Jane could have saved Sarah, after a year and half in the apocalypse don't take risks and instead walk around the ice (maybe it's just my Canadian instincts)). Nick's was a real insult to his character, but the way I see it now that point has been driven home and it just pisses everyone off.
Smashing someone's face is merciful? He did not suffer long I guess.
Carley - her first death seemed rather easily avoidable(if I remember it correctly). But getting shot by Lily man. It's not exactly friendly fire but being killed by your own was messed up. Plus it was very unexpected(@ least for me). Luke was pretty awful but I saw it coming once Kenny volunteered the group over the ice. Omid's was shocking for how early into the episode we were. Mark's was pretty bad.
Carlos.
Obviously the most devastating death for me was Pete. The fact that he was so close to surviving, if he was just able to pluck up the courage to cut his foot off. But the truth of the matter is, not many people are capable of that type of courage, and to see him struggling with it, and then succumbing to his fear was heartbreaking. There were so many "should've, could've, would've" moments for him, the final blow was the small spark of hope at being able to see Nick once more before he died being cruelly extinguished as he sacrificed himself to help Clem get away. I will never be over it.
Mark's death was hands down the most disturbing. He went into these people's home, expecting to be patched up and then given a meal, only to become the meal. They very well may have sawed off his legs when he was awake and conscious, while one of the St. Johns was going on about how good he'd taste, how the best kind of meat was fresh, that he would have died anyway, so isn't it better for his body's meat to benefit others etc. I can't even fathom how petrified he must have been, to be alone in that bathroom, dismembered, and knowing people, who weren't walkers, were planning to eat his flesh. It makes my skin crawl.
Carley's death was the second most disturbing for me. She was under the impression that the only dangers she needed to be wary of were walkers, and people outside her group. For her to be shot in the head by her own group member is perhaps the worst kind of betrayal and such an unexpected/unperceived way of dying, both for her, and by other members of the group.
Nick's death for me was sad in the way that nobody knew how he died. The saying "if a tree falls in the forest, and nobody is there to hear it, does it make a sound?" truly resonates with Nick's death in my eyes. No one witnessed his fear, or what he was thinking/saying in his last moments, nobody was there to hear his cries of pain and terror, make eye contact with him, or call out his name as he was bitten. It was just so quiet. It's one thing to die, but to have no one be there when you go, or for no one to ever know how you went, whether it was bravely or terrified, is just so sad.
Yes, since Carver was unconscious/dead long before Kenny was done mutilating his corpse. If you really want to torture someone, you need them alive and aware.
Brie.
I understand SOMEONE had to block the door, but why a single woman and not others or a man, since she wasn't strong enough, the walkers got in. Although I don't think her being alive would affect anything.
Luke.. the way they just killed him like that...
Luke's definitely. That was just messed up. -_-
Carlos and Sarah. Just... Ugh.
Brie's death was pretty brutal, but her strength didn't have to anything to do with the walkers being able to break the window next to her...
How can Jane save Sarah exactly (I'm assuming you are speaking about her 2nd determinant death)?
Katjaa's suicide was pretty messed up.
So when you think about it, Sarah only died at the deck because a horrible excuse was needed to dispose of her. I mean, who's ever heard of a rifle that only holds TWO bullets?