›

Choices you felt mattered more?

ZachiscoolZachiscool
in The Walking Dead

What were choices you felt should have matter more, or that did more for the plot than others.

For me really, pulling Ben up or dropping Ben mattered most, and Chopping off Lee's arm should have mattered more.

Comments

  • quinnicsquinnics

    • [Cover Luke] or [Help Luke].

    • Saving Nick in episode two.

    • Teaching Sarah how to shoot a gun or not.

    • Trusting Bonnie or not with the escape plan at Howe's.

    I feel like those should have mattered a lot more.

  • InKennyWeTrustInKennyWeTrust

    400 days.

  • ABigBadWolfABigBadWolf

    I feel like watching Carver die should have influenced how people see you at some point. Only Luke can bring it up and he forgets soon after.

  • bloopbloop

    Saving Nick: He should've had heroic death.

    Teaching Sarah how to shoot: If you saved her, during the scene where Rebecca goes into labor, she should've shot some zombies and at least try to grow before she dies.

    Watching Carver die: This option I really wanted to see people viewed Clem after it, but only Luke and Kenny mention it.

    Help or Cover Luke: HE SHOULD'VE LIVED!

    400 Days: The characters should've be involved in the story more instead of just Bonnie.

  • colgatocolgato

    Season 1

    1. Doug should have lived entire season, or at least until late episode 4, he was cool but had little to no development and i just genuinely wanted to see more of him. Carley could still die in episode 3 for the fact that lily actually wanted her dead, and ben could die in episode 3 if doug was saved.
    2. Lily should have stayed, once again, around until late episode 4 if you kept her around. it makes almost no sense to give the player the option
    3. The scene with christa if you drop Ben makes no sense at all. it doesnt happen if you dont drop him so continuity makes no sense.

    Season 2

    1. Nick didnt have tor be determinant in episode 2, walter seems like the kind of guy who would save him either way. this goes against what i said about the lily thing but this is something i would like to be more of an "allusion of choice", to make the player cautious on what to pick
    2. In the final fight between jane and kenny, depending on how the player gets in the way either jane or kenny could be at the upper hand instead of just always kenny
  • MrAppleJuiceMrAppleJuice

    Teaching Sarah how to shoot a gun.

    Cutting of Sarita's arm or not.

    Shooting Rebecca or not.

  • CandySquaredCandySquared

    Teaching Sarah how to shoot a gun, whether Clem kills the Stranger or not, 400 Days should've been more important.

  • Kenny_Is_AliveKenny_Is_Alive

    Almost every Choice in S2

  • Near_Near_

    Watching Kenny kill Carver was way too important. And the choice wasn't that clear, I thought staying meant that you could convince Kenny to stop.

  • ZachiscoolZachiscool

    Well, When Kenny's beating up Arvo and you watch and tell him to stop, he says "What, lose your fast for this sot of thing?"

    ABigBadWolf posted: »

    I feel like watching Carver die should have influenced how people see you at some point. Only Luke can bring it up and he forgets soon after.

  • ClemyClooAndBabybooClemyClooAndBabyboo
    edited November 2014

    Saving Sarah should have mattered, I miss that little selfie taking rascal... ;_;

  • AhmedAli1AhmedAli1

    Rob Arvo or Don't rob Arvo.
    I thought that would have an impact on episode 5 I was wrong.

  • MikejamesMikejames

    A few choices that could have used more polish-

    Blackmailing Rebecca: Could have fueled some consistent resentment.

    Saving Nick: Give him a greater final struggle than getting through an off-screen fence.

    Teaching and helping Sarah: Whether or not she shoots anyone, follow through on her character arc.

    Any interaction with Arvo: The guy shoots a child who potentially defends him at every given opportunity.

    Where the 400 Days crew ended up.

  • InfiniteDawnInfiniteDawn

    Luke.

    The fact that if you cover him, Bonnie takes her dumbass across the ice to 'help' him. Sigh. I'm pretty sure that Bonnie's smart enough not to do that. Then again, she did start to unload her AK for some god-awful reason in the herd. Still wondering how Sarita got bitten and she didn't.

  • CrazyGeorgeCrazyGeorge Banned

    Choices matter?

Sign in to comment in this discussion.