Did Hershel like you?

Hershel hated me in my play through, as I lied, then saved Duck

Comments

  • He liked me till I saved Duck.

  • I was Honest and Tried to save Shawn

  • I didn't even know it was possible for Hershel to like you (Lee). I just thought either way he talks smack then boots you off his farm.

  • I tried to help Shawn. Hershel then says "You tried to save him, but this piece of shit let him die!"

  • I honestly don't know how not to lie to Hershel. I always save Duck so I guess it really doesn't matter if he likes me or not.

  • Honestly I'm still surprised by the amount of people that went ahead and saved Shawn. I figured getting a little boy to safety would be first priority.

  • Yeah until i saved Duck

  • Oh, and if your confused about what this thread is about, it's about if you were honest to Hershel and saved Shawn, Honest to Hershel and saved Duck, Lied to Hershel and saved Shawn, Or lied to Hershel and Saved Duck

  • I was honest to Hershel.

    Then he accused me of lying to him.

    That logic tho.

    I decided to help Shawn anyway. Poor decision on my part.

  • edited October 2014

    Because Shawn saved your life and it was Duck's fault the accident happened.

    I saved Duck but the majority was that I read the comics and knew shawn was gonna end up walker chow.

    Hazzer posted: »

    Honestly I'm still surprised by the amount of people that went ahead and saved Shawn. I figured getting a little boy to safety would be first priority.

  • Told the truth, saved Duck, so NOPE, he didn't like me.

  • no he didn't/

    he fucken stabbed me with a pitchfork

  • ElliasEllias Banned
    edited October 2014

    he liked me and i tried saving his cute son over duck but sadly it didn't matter and that's when I found out this was going to be an illusion of choice game but still great 7.5/10

  • Yeah but you can't exactly blame him for it considering his age... Seems fucked up to abandon Duck because of that but hey, that's what I've been raised to believe. Duck was younger and therefore it'd be reasonable to assume he had more life ahead of him.

    Because Shawn saved your life and it was Duck's fault the accident happened. I saved Duck but the majority was that I read the comics and knew shawn was gonna end up walker chow.

  • edited October 2014

    I lied to Hershel and saved Duck. He was pissed.
    Alt text

  • I lied to him and I saved Duck. So no, he didn't like me.

  • This

    He liked me till I saved Duck.

  • I was honest with him but saved Duck. So nah, he hates my guts.

  • I told him the truth and kept calm with him. I go to save Duck as most people would save a kid first and the he hated my guts.

    Still have no idea how Shawn could of not heard walkers coming towards him or Duck to see movement in the field. Stupid Logic, also how did he get trapped under a bloody tractor?

  • Why do you always talk in italics? I'm curious

    BlueShadiw posted: »

    I was honest to Hershel. Then he accused me of lying to him. That logic tho. I decided to help Shawn anyway. Poor decision on my part.

  • I;ve never understood why he kicks you off the farm even if you get a long with well and try to save his son and even bad mouth Kenny by saying it was Kennys fault.
    Seems odd how he'd kick you off for that.

  • Because it's fancy. :)

    I'm quite surprised I'm getting all this attention just for typing in italics though, lol.

    Bubadoo posted: »

    Why do you always talk in italics? I'm curious

  • I told the truth, and I felt a nice little connection and bond.

    Until I saved Duck.

  • Duck.

    ImUrban posted: »

    I told him the truth and kept calm with him. I go to save Duck as most people would save a kid first and the he hated my guts. Still have

  • You are The Italics Guy.

    BlueShadiw posted: »

    Because it's fancy. I'm quite surprised I'm getting all this attention just for typing in italics though, lol.

  • Duck crushed Shawn's foot with the tractor

    ImUrban posted: »

    I told him the truth and kept calm with him. I go to save Duck as most people would save a kid first and the he hated my guts. Still have

  • Yep

    BlueShadiw posted: »

    Because it's fancy. I'm quite surprised I'm getting all this attention just for typing in italics though, lol.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.