Do you want a Hunter scene in S3?
MrX1H2
Banned
So after watching S503 I thought of a very interesting scene that could happen in S3. Okay so picture this. In S3 there is a conflict between Clem and AJ's new group and another group who is a very dangerous threat to Clem's group. So after this conflict Clem's group is surrounding the other group and people are debating what they should do to them. So you are given two choices. [kill them] or [Show them mercy].
If you choose to kill them you are given two options [Make them suffer] or [Shoot them]. If you choose to make them suffer Clem and the group kills them brutally like Rick's group. If you choose to shoot them you just end their lives quick and painlessly.
If you choose the other option [Show them mercy] you are greeted once again with two choices. [Let them go] or [Tie them up]. If you choose to let them go there will be a consequence and one of the enemy group members kills one of your people and your group ends up killing the other group. If you choose to tie them up your group will just leave them tied up and there fates will be unknown.
In all of these scenes AJ is there watching the whole thing and regardless of the choice you choose it will say (?) AJ will remember that. Your choices on this will influence AJ and his opinion on Clementine. This will also be a choice relating to Clem's humanity.
Anyways, what do you think of this and do you want this scene to be in S3.
Comments
What happened with Rick is a very extreme case. Can you really see Clementine doing what he did?
It depends on the situation and how big a threat the group is. I can see Clementine doing it, but she would lose any last bit of humanity she had left.
I think it would take a lot more to lose your humanity to that point. I just dont think its in her character. Rick has been pushed and pushed for five seasons and his actions have gotten more extreme when it comes to people who threaten him or his group. It took a long time to develop his character to that point. I don't think Clementine is there yet. She would need a few more years of just hard living and pain and becoming more and more cold for me to buy her willingly making people suffer. The scenario you're putting forward, I think, would fit better with a harder edged group of people.
They already did the cannibal thing with the saint johns. It would seem stupid to do all over again.
I can't argue with you that Rick has been through more hardships than Clementine to get to that point. But you have to take in consideration Clementine has been through a lot for a little girl in such a short time. Rick still has one thing going for him. His family. Carl ,Judith,Daryl, Michoone, etc. Without them there would be no point in living for him. Clementine has literally seen every single person she cared about die in front of her eyes. Her parents, Lee, Kenny(determinant), the motor inn group, the cabin survivors. She was kidnapped, shot, punched in the face twice and hit with a gun and all of this happening to a little girl is enough to push her to that point. She can determinantly watch torture and literally say she's glad she did. If she can say that than I assume she has no problem doing it herself.
Hmm...No. I would imagine having a choice in which Clementine has the choice to kill somebody who has caused them to suffer and threteaned them. But not brutally murder a group of people.
I can't imagine Clementine making a group of people suffer. So no, I don't really want a scene like this.
well they already did a hunters type shit. the St. John's
we already had a cannibals section no need for another people would just bitch about it anyway