Kenny or AJ?

2

Comments

  • Kenny is not some dog you put out of misery, people with that attitude makes me sick.

    I wouldn't want Kenny to suffer. Hence the reason why I got the alone ending. I put Kenny's out of his misery so he could be with his fam

  • I'd save AJ, its what Kenny would want and I could imagine Kenny flipping out if you let AJ die.

  • It's a very arguable viewpoint from a mental stability viewpoint.

    In the ending he wants Clem to go in because he thinks he'll hurt her. He's convinced himself he's a monster after all the murders he's committed.

    BoatsNHoes posted: »

    Kenny is not some dog you put out of misery, people with that attitude makes me sick.

  • He outwardly states in episode 4 that he;s still messed up because of Katjaa and Duck as well.

    he was unstable in season 2 before he lost his eye and girlfriend.

    9 days later he is currently nice and together. He was currently nice and together during the rest scene in episode 5 when you name AJ. That does not mean he was mentally stable then, nor does it mean the same for that ending.

    Poogers555 posted: »

    I feel like Kenny was so messed up because he had just lost his girl friend and his eye. Yeah Aj helped him get through it an Aj dieing woul

  • Kenny without a doubt.

  • Why should I care? :P

    Please don't post cartoon pic's... I hate them...

  • Well it was worth a shot .... But why do you like cartoon's? They are for children. I'm just curious.

    Green613 posted: »

    Why should I care? :P

  • edited October 2014

    The only cartoon I watch is Legend of Korra, and I think the amount of death in it and how brutal some are, shows that it isn't only for children.

    Well it was worth a shot .... But why do you like cartoon's? They are for children. I'm just curious.

  • There's not that much death in Korra is there?

    Granted, I haven't been able to watch the current season yet, but the past three have been fairly without death.

    Green613 posted: »

    The only cartoon I watch is Legend of Korra, and I think the amount of death in it and how brutal some are, shows that it isn't only for children.

  • edited October 2014

    Well I won't spoil anything for anyone who hasn't watched it, but in book 3 the way Zaheer kills that certain person by bending the air out of her is pretty brutal, also Mako with shocking the water causing that other person to be shocked to death, and mainly that one person who had there head blown off because someone threw a metal plate over their combustion eye thingy. I'd say they're pretty brutal for a channel like Nickelodeon :P

    Flog61 posted: »

    There's not that much death in Korra is there? Granted, I haven't been able to watch the current season yet, but the past three have been fairly without death.

  • Oh yeah that's true, but all of those were pretty self contained in a couple of episodes. Outside of the end of season 3 there's hardly any death whatsoever, and when here is death, it's the villains dying which is hardly as emotionally evocative and arguably an entirely different form of death altogether in the narrative.

    Green613 posted: »

    Well I won't spoil anything for anyone who hasn't watched it, but in book 3 the way Zaheer kills that certain person by bending the air out

  • I like cartoon's pic's, it made the discussion more funny. :)

    Well it was worth a shot .... But why do you like cartoon's? They are for children. I'm just curious.

  • Kenny. period.

  • Ask your mother to give me a lease, I got my eyes on her condo there ;)

    BoatsNHoes posted: »

    To AllThatRemains: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kSDSUhD4fv4

  • Alt text

    Ask your mother to give me a lease, I got my eyes on her condo there

  • You shouldn't talk about someone's mom. You never know how crazy people are.

    Just some advice.

    Ask your mother to give me a lease, I got my eyes on her condo there

  • You never know how crazy people are.

    Well, at least you advertise it lol

    CrazyGeorge posted: »

    You shouldn't talk about someone's mom. You never know how crazy people are. Just some advice.

  • Personally, I've seen crazier reactions from people when their favorite character has been insulted than when their parents have. But yes, best not to call anyone a whore around these parts. Maybe IGN.

    CrazyGeorge posted: »

    You shouldn't talk about someone's mom. You never know how crazy people are. Just some advice.

  • I would explode.

  • Well in my crazier days, someone insulted my mother and i broke his nose.

    DomeWing333 posted: »

    Personally, I've seen crazier reactions from people when their favorite character has been insulted than when their parents have. But yes, best not to call anyone a whore around these parts. Maybe IGN.

  • The Tent Scene with Kenny when he talks about Katjaa and Duck is him just talking about his family that he lost. People dont just move on from loved ones who died. Like I said, the way Kenny deals with death actually feels human unlike the other characters who dont seem to care at all. And honestly until ep 4 and 5 I dont know what people can say bad about Kenny in Season 2.

    Flog61 posted: »

    He outwardly states in episode 4 that he;s still messed up because of Katjaa and Duck as well. he was unstable in season 2 before he lost

  • No they don't 'move on' fully but they do stop being torn apart emotionally by it to the same extent in a way Kenny just hasn't.

    You can make the point that he is horrible to Luke and Nick for no actual reason, and almost gets the group gunned down while trying to escape the van in episode 3. Oh, and forces Clem to take the radio.

    Poogers555 posted: »

    The Tent Scene with Kenny when he talks about Katjaa and Duck is him just talking about his family that he lost. People dont just move on fr

  • I would save AJ. Kenny would want that. Its the right thing to do regardless.

  • Being force to take the radio for the plot to move. What would happen if the game just let you say no.

    Flog61 posted: »

    No they don't 'move on' fully but they do stop being torn apart emotionally by it to the same extent in a way Kenny just hasn't. You can

  • You know, this might happen if you chose to go with Kenny.

  • The game could easily have been structured in a way that allows you a choice. Or it could have been structured that made it clear that Clementine HAD to take it.

    Kenny forced it on her. You can't justify bad things your favourite character does just by saying 'plot convenience.'

    Poogers555 posted: »

    Being force to take the radio for the plot to move. What would happen if the game just let you say no.

  • Well It doesnt really matter because I never found being forced to take the radio a bad thing

    Flog61 posted: »

    The game could easily have been structured in a way that allows you a choice. Or it could have been structured that made it clear that Cleme

  • Save AJ, no question. I couldn't live with myself if I let AJ die. I'd cease to function. Seriously, no joke.

    Plus, think of what Kenny would do if AJ died. He'd lose it. Again.

  • If you didn't mind taking the radio then you weren't forced. The problem is that if Clem feels really unsafe taking it and asks not to be given it, Kenny does it anyway.

    Poogers555 posted: »

    Well It doesnt really matter because I never found being forced to take the radio a bad thing

  • I don't mean it like that, you shouldn't have even interpreted it like that in the first place.

    People have such a negative view in life, that is what makes me sick.

    I mean that I didn't want him to drag himself around anymore. Didn't want him to live in the harsh world that he's been surviving in for so long. He even wanted to die himself, does that not prove anything?

    Jesus Christ.

    BoatsNHoes posted: »

    Kenny is not some dog you put out of misery, people with that attitude makes me sick.

  • LOK is pretty deep, season 1 ends with a murder suicide.... The feels :'(

    JMOREL posted: »

    I like cartoon's pic's, it made the discussion more funny.

  • Yeah, I love Kenny and all, but I would pick AJ. Kenny would go insane if we lost AJ anyway, and I couldn't pick Ken over a defenseless newborn.

  • He didnt think he'd hurt her, he said he would never do anything to hurt Clem. Dont pull assumptions from your rear end.

    He said he didnt trust himself to take care of her, there is a difference.

    Flog61 posted: »

    It's a very arguable viewpoint from a mental stability viewpoint. In the ending he wants Clem to go in because he thinks he'll hurt her. He's convinced himself he's a monster after all the murders he's committed.

  • I wouldnt save either of them.

  • Forgive me for not having any faith in him saying he wouldn't hurt clem after he threw my clem on her back when she tried to stop him attacking Jane.

    Jane does the same, but she doesn''t promise she'd never ever hurt Clem.

    So yeah, I'm pretty sure that claim is only true as long as he isn't pissed off. Which is, what, about 50% of the time?

    BoatsNHoes posted: »

    He didnt think he'd hurt her, he said he would never do anything to hurt Clem. Dont pull assumptions from your rear end. He said he didnt trust himself to take care of her, there is a difference.

  • I went with Kenny but if it'll come out to save either him or AJ I would choose AJ. First of all - I'm sure as hell that Kenny would want me to protect the child. I also think that he might've even sacrifice himself if it was neccessary to protect Clem and AJ. Of course he would be mad if I didn't choose to save AJ so it's easy decision for me. :)

  • Thats what i wanted to say, even if you chose Kenny he would go nuts because you have to choose AJ in his eyes for humanity

    Tewudin posted: »

    I went with Kenny but if it'll come out to save either him or AJ I would choose AJ. First of all - I'm sure as hell that Kenny would want m

  • edited October 2014

    Thats cold.

    zykelator posted: »

    I wouldnt save either of them.

  • Kenny.(I love AJ but I cant choose him over the lord Kenny.)

  • Thats me

    JMOREL posted: »

    Thats cold.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.