maybe they wasted a big twist ( determinant protagonist)?
What do you guys think about a determinant protagonist? I prefer Clem and everyone is expecting her to be the next protagonist, but i have no problems with another person (even Lilly. so i can watch her die , every possible time 
) I would still buy the game, regardless of who will be the new protagonist. But the point here is :
What if telltale had made a determinant protagonist for S3 ( Kenny or Jane as clem caretaker, Controled by You in S3). they pass through the same situations but from different perspectives, both of them will have advantages and disadvantages and some diferent dialogue options like :
Clem : What do we do now?
Kenny: [ we need a boat ]
Jane [ Let's kill some walkers and search their stuff]
But you still have common options for both of them, like : We have to find a safe place
How threaten an asshole?
Kenny : [Listen vanilla ice, you better not hurt me or my girl, you understand?! ]
Jane [ Dont come over me or my girl, son of a bitch!]
common [ Back off, asshole]
You will be able to be good or an asshole with them, with dialogues that they didnt seem out of character,for both cases, the two can be good or bad in some situations. Both of them will find the same group and join them for some reason, with clem.
If you choose the alone ending you will be reward with 20 extra minutes with pure action, where Jane/Kenny realizes how stupid was left clem alone, so you save clem from the zombie horde killing a lots of walkers. in the end you carry clementine and she carries AJ, and you will have to convince clem to stay with you.. both of them will go with clem for a common point and we start things again.
I know some peoples hate Kenny and Jane, but how would you react if you could have redemption for one of them?
Also, was gonna be cool see you playing S3 with Kenny and your Friend with Jane, i think.
The 2nd shoot Kenny option ruined that possibility . GODDAMIT!
*Also that was going to end the problem with a little girl doing adults stuff
Comments
They can do common dialogues and put two options only avaluable for Kenny/Jane, not everything diferent. like 70% of the voice actors job identical, just work in the combat system and some diferent moments, i dont think this was going to waste double of the time, just 1, 1,5 months in max
and if you ley Kenny kill Jane and then you killed him
I like this idea! I actually thought that they were going to do that for Season 2. That'd be awesome because it shows that your previous actions really did matter.
"The 2nd shoot Kenny option ruined that possibility . GODDAMIT!" I know this is impossible, i just like the idea
Unless you get 3 determinant playable characters, the 3rd could be either a new one or Clementine herself but then it would actually be pretty close to impossible for this to happen, it's one of the best ideas I've heard for Season 3 though.
I actually feel rather than an optional protaganist they could be an optional side character but the would only ever really work if it was one or the other. Part of me is thinking you end up tih Kenny or Jane (whoevers alive) regardless, I.E you cant be n your own
what about the people who ended up with just clem and aj
nvm just read that part. i missed it lmao
Honetly I'm thinking if kenny and jane are ever going to matter they'll have to retcon the ending where they both die.... dunno have Jane be fine somehow.
There's no way Kenny and Jane can ever last if there is an option for them not to be there at all