STRAWPOLL: Carl vs. Clementine
I'm sure this has been discussed countless times before since it seems like a pretty popular topic, but I haven't seen one, so I figured I'd ask the question: Who would win in a fight, Carl or Clementine? This can be either Carl (comics or T.V.). http://strawpoll.me/2911376
And while I'm at it: Who is the better character? http://strawpoll.me/2911381
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
Comments
If they had a fist fight then I think Carl would win but I definitely think Clem could outsmart him. Clem's probably a lot tougher than him though, she's had to stitch up her own arm and she's lost almost everybody who she cares about. Clementine's definitely the better character.
I think her smarts are enough to beat Carl, but that's my opinion.
Probably Clem assuming Season 2 and where Carl is in Washington my rubies are on Clem she's faster and more agile she could take Carl out without him knowing and even if he's aware would have a hard time hence the fight with Winston.
Exactly, I feel Carl would go into a fight and just try and kill her. Clem is smart for her age and knows how to use the environment for her advantage, that's why I think she would win.
Yeah I think Carl could throw a stronger punch but Clem could probably outwit him.
Coral would win because if a fight between the two were to happen, Rick would get into the mix.
What if Rick wasn't around, Carl (Coral) has no one to help him, same goes for Clementine.
Clementine is tougher than the TV show's Carl but the Carl in the comics took a bullet through the eye and survived.
Carl. He's been through more, became hardened, stronger, confident, better at using weapons. He's also a very more interesting character than the emotionless blob that was Clem S2. His hat also beats all.
Who Needs Coral When you have Clementine
CORAL !
I don't think Rick is going to beat up a little girl if he were to help Carl.
Comic Carl>Clementine> Tv Carl.
Comic Carl lost an eye and he's quite tough. I think he could win Clementine in a fight.
Dammit, everyone keeps losing eyes. And limbs. This series should change its name for The Lost Body Parts.
For the fight I'd go with Carol from the comics. Who's a better character? I'm going to vote Clem, but S2 has me tottering.
Oh please, look what forum you're asking this in.
Yes, but look how many people are saying Carl and not Clementine, just saying.
In the polls? A rather small proportion.
I meant in the comments. And concerning the poll, I also posted the links on a Youtube video about Carl vs. Clementine, so the poll is not only asking people from the forums, but on Youtube as well.
Yes but by advertising on the fourms you'll be attracting more clementine fans than carl fans automatically. Unless you also posted it on the most popular tv show and comic fan forums.
Nope, not on any T.V. or comic forums.
Clementine. But I'm obviously going to say that as someone who's not too fond of the show.
I would say- Clem, but they will probably never meet and have a fight, so you never know...
Beat!