What if Clementine died...
Thought I would create a thread where we hypothesize what would have occured to characters and the plot if Clementine was killed at certain points during season 2. These can be real deaths that result from a QTE failure, or more random deaths during a specific time.
Examples:
If Clementine died at the stream during episode 1, Pete would have died anyway and Nick would have ran off. Depending on whether Nick was found by the group or ran to the moonshine cabin would either make the group look for him or not. If Carlos decides to stay with Sarah at the cabin while the others look for Nick he would have been there when Carver arrives and would have likely killed him. If he left Rebecca to watch over Sarah, Carver would probably take them both hostage.
If Clementine died from the walker trapped under the truck in episode 5, Jane would arrive at the rest stop with no AJ and no Clem, making a awkward situation between her and Kenny... at that point I think she would just give Kenny the baby and go on her own way, but it's a tough situation to predict.
Comments
If Clementine died the Cabin Survivors would have never made it through the Season.
They didn't anyway.
Clementine just delayed the inevitable.
Or sped it up.
You guys are golden.
What?
Don't know about that, if Clementine wasn't around then they wouldn't have an escape plan for episode 3, and they were rather safe at Carver's. (At least Rebecca was)
I die.
Number one.
Is that a pun?
...I'm confused...
Do you want it to be?
...Fallandir....Pls.
Of course.
Then it is. Just like that.
Was that magic?
What if Clem died after meeting the cabin group but before finding Kenny?
Say, on the bridge. Matthew approach them with a more hostile mind or Clem/Luke screws up which results in him firing and hitting Clem then Nick shooting Matthew (justly?)
Either they would have been denied entry by the lodge or maybe since, they had a pregnant woman they would probably be allowed to stay overnight, and if so a situation would probably arise between the two sides depending on if the situation at the bridge would be brought up.
I like the off-top we did.
Death=Bad
Indeed!
You're doing great, CC!
proudly pats CC on the shoulder
If clem died while attacking the walker before the bridge I can only imagine the reaction from Luke, then him having to tell the others XD
"Oh that kid.... well Carlos dont say I told you so but....
/edgy
Then I would have enjoyed S2 more.
/unedgy
What if Clem died when Arvo shot her, the flashback with Lee being her final thoughts. The rest of the episode is just her dreaming until she finally bleeds out.
I suppose Kenny and Jane would have split up after a bout of arguing. Jane would go wherever and Kenny would go to Wellington where he most likely would have begged them to take him and then go his own way.
What if Clem died when she's supposed to grab the ladder in episode 3? Wouldn't that have been an awkward conversation.