How Should Certain Characters Deaths Have Been Handled?)
Carley/Doug- They shouldn't have, simple as that.
Luke- Same as before. They shouldn't have.
Nick- Episode 2 Death(Same). The episode 4 death would be Determinant. If he survived Ep 2 but you didn't give him the watch he will be killed and die the same fence Walker death as before. If he survived all this, than he will survive the season.
Sarah- If she survives her first Determinant Death, but Nick is not alive, she will die being crushed. If she survives these but you didn't teach her how to shoot in Episode 2 she will be killed by the Walker that almost killed Kenny in No Going Back. If she survives these she will survive the whole season.
Reggie- If you didn't get him in trouble the night before, Carver won't kill him. If he survives Episode 3 he will be killed in the Shootout.
Walter- If you get Kenny to stop in time he will survive and be killed when crossing the ice instead of Luke.
Alvin- If you convinced Carver not to kill Alvin in In Harms Way, he would survive and be killed saving AJ in No Going Back during the Shootout.
Pete- If you saved him in Ep 2. He would survive until Episode 5 if Nick is alive and survive the entire Season. If he survived Ep 2 but Nick died, he will be killed during the horde escape in Episode 4.
Comments
Carley/Doug- The same with Carley , but Ben will be killed in episode 3 by Lily instead of Doug. Doug will be involved too in the deal with the bandits and will have an arc similar to Ben , but he will die in episode 4 even if you try to pull him up because he is too fat :P
Luke- I was fine with his death
Nick- He will die in episode 2(same) , trying to get Sarah out the trailer park(left Sarah). If he didn´t die there he will live
Sarah- Same first death , In the shootout if Nick isn´t alive. If she survives these she will live
Reggie- Shouldn´t have existed in the first place
Walter-I am fine with his death , but i would have liked him to live if you Stoped Kenny from shooting
Pete- Takes Walter´s death if saved in episode 2
Larry- Lee can find a syringe of epinephrine in the medical storage closet while searching for Mark. In the meat locker Lee can choose to stab Larry in the heart with the syringe instead of doing CPR or siding with Kenny. Larry bursts back to life. After Clem opens the door Larry with the syringe still hanging out of his chest is the first one out. Larry grabs the hay hook walks up behind Danny and instant kills him, Larry then grabs Charlotte and runs into the house. Lee moves slowly towards the house and hears two gunshots. Larry is killed by Brenda.
Luke - Shouldn´t have died at all.
The bitterness never ends.
Have Nick die but Sarah live to the end.
Dammit, ignore this, hit reply by accident.
Have Nick die and Sarah live on. :P
Nick - Found Clementine and Jane, they patch him up. He survives till the Episode 5 gunfight, where he pushes Clem into cover and is killed. Luke then goes haywire and shoots up the Russians, and that's how Luke gets injured.
Have Nick and Sarah die in the shootout.
Luke - Doesn't die.
Walter - Replaces Nick when dying, is shot in the shoulder and then found as walker by Clem and Jane.
Sarita - Dies in the shootout.
Nick - Dies sacrificing himself so Sarah has enough time to get out in the trailer park
Sarah should just never die. :P
Determinant characters have to die eventually, but that doesn't mean they can't have an impact on the story before they do. I honestly just can't think of a way to fit those two into the finale to be honest, that's why I feel it's better to have them die in the shootout.
Nick dies in the gun fight.
Sarah should have never been determinate so there wouldn't be... Save her. Congrats ! Now she wont talk for the rest of the episode and die later.
Sam the dog- Clem finds the dog bowl behind the barbeque and pours half the beans into the bowl. Sam eats his share of the food and is satisfied. Clem and Sam are walking through the woods and come across Luke and Uncle Pete. Luke and Uncle Pete invite Clem to the cabin and when they arrive Rebecca and Alvin suggest that they kill and eat Sam. Clem can agree and gain immediate acceptance to the cabin group or can refuse. If Clem refuses Sam is killed protecting her in the mess with Nick and Uncle Pete. Rebecca and Alvin are upset that they missed their chance at a good meal.
Lord Chet made it to hot-dish night though.
When Luke fell threw the ice Jane should have jumped in after him. You should have had the choice to save one or the other. Nick should have survived to the gunfight with Arvo, and died there protecting Clementine.
The fight with Kenny, and Jane should have been different. I think that Clem should have shot the knife out of Kenny's hand. At that time Kenny, and Jane decide to go separate ways. You can go with one of them, or on your own. I think Telltale shot themselves in the foot. Both of those characters were getting quite a bit of fans. They should have kept them around for later.
Luke -> Jane/Luke decision, alive in ending
Nick -> Die in Russians shootout or left unknown
Walter -> Die while escaping Carver's camp
Pete -> His death wasn't bad, but possibly make it back to cabin, then put down by Nick.
Luke - aliiiiive! [collapses as sobbing wreck on the floor]
Nick - gets to die a hero for saying he was a good man to Walteeeer
Sarah - at least gets to shoot a gun like how Clem taught her to protect Clem before being wasted T.T
Ditto T.T
Luke - Should be alive or at least have unknown status, Telltale killing him off for shock value was a horrible move on their part and i'd say it was, between Luke's and Nick's death, the worst one in the Season 2.
Nick - Anything besides the horrible character development he received if alive in Episodes 3 and 4.
Carver - I felt he should have lasted a bit longer, he could have developed into a great villain instead of this Governor 2.0 we got.
Carlos - Again, not a fan of shock value deaths. I never really felt that Carlos was that well developed, same with Sarah. Carlos ended up becoming another throw away character for the plot.
Sarah - Your choice to save her or not in Episode 4 was meaningless in the end. Sarah was another example of a character being thrown away because the plot doesn't entire around them.
Moral of the story, try not to kill off every single character by the time the story gets to the end of Episode 5. I'm looking at you, Telltale. Don't get me wrong, I'm a huge fan of TTG, but the way they handled the characters in Season 2 was not done properly and should be improved on in Season 3.
Luke just shouldn't have died in general.
Here here. /still grieving some way after the fact, fff
Luke should have been pulled out by Clem (no choice for Bonnie to go instead). Clem can't get him up and the ice starts to crack again, he begs Clem to leave him.
You can then choose to help him up or leave him.
If Clem helps him up, Luke uses his last bit of strength to push Clem away and then he falls in, at this point Clem cries and Bonnie goes over to comfort her.
If Clem leaves him she stands up but the ice breaks and they fall in, you then see Luke's floating body like the cover option.
This way Luke gets a more emotional death.
Nick - his death should not have been determinant.
Walter should have always shot him or let him be bitten.
Alvin, Reggie - if Alvin survives Ep 2 and Reggie's death (by Carver's hands) should be determinant based on the garden work, they both should be killed by the horde (combo of being shot, not moving right, making noise).
Pete - I may have altered how he died in All that Remains, but his dead is essentially to the story. I may have had him die in the beginning of a Divided House by buying Clem time to escape the walkers but not have been already bitten.
Luke - would have allowed an option to walk around the pond, but it causes deterioration of his leg and it needs to be amputated. Makes his decision to go to Howe's instead of going north. He then is either left behind by both groups or ends up packing with Mike/Bonnie/Arvo and gets shot fighting Arvo after he shots Clementine.
Sarah - if you save her from the trailer, she should die in the shootout. I'd consider Bonnie should as well.
Let me rephrase my original comment:
Luke never died. What are you all talking about?
/comforting shoulder pat
You can discard it tho.
I didn't realize until I hit post comment that I did it. I was distracted, hit the reply button by accident when I thought I hit Add Comment, so I made a comment but didn't know I was replying to him.
Oh I get it now
Yeah, I miss Luke.
What if Nick died in the shootout and Sarah left with Bonnie, Mike and Arvo?
Because she doesn't know Mike, Bonnie, and Arvo well enough to betray the group and I don't think she'd leave Clementine, especially if you agreed to be her friend in All That Remains.
In season 3 they need to somehow end up at Hershel's farm and Clementine need to see Chet as a walker (undead or dead idk) and say "Looks like he never made it to hot dish night..." Or she needs to end up at his house with Lord Kenny and they shall have a hot dish night of the gods.
I would've had Sarah bitten and either Clem or Carlos shoots her. Carlos would've replaced Kenny in his arc and I would've built up the animosity between him and Jane. Also I wouldn't have killed off Luke instead he gets lost in the woods or something and his fate is unknown.