And here's a question, how come if Carol is dead in the comics, why isn't she dead the show? They are totally separate entities, it's like the book, The Hobbit, which is different from the Hobbit movies, which are inspired by book.
Gotta agree with ol' Pal here.
And here's a question, how come if Carol is dead in the comics, why isn't she dead the show? They are tota… morelly separate entities, it's like the book, The Hobbit, which is different from the Hobbit movies, which are inspired by book.
No. For one thing, I find the guy overrated. Secondly, he exists in the TV universe, not the comic universe. The game takes place in the comic universe so it's not possible.
I don't see why it's not possible. It's all still Kirkman's universe whether it's TV, Comic's or the game it's all still The Walking Dead. What would a cameo of Daryl hurt? Maybe just an episode or so of him interacting with the character's similar to how Glenn or Hershal was in S1E1. They didn't greatly affect the story. I think it would be cool.
Like I would enjoy seeing a Clementine on the TV show. Again, she wouldn't have to become a major character, maybe just part of another group they encounter, maybe share a couple smiles and wink's with Carl then they all continue on their own way's.
Neither senerio need's to have any real impact on the show or in the game, but just something to give fan's of both a nice little crossover gift.
The entire Walking Dead is all just a work of fiction so why can't they bend some rule's a bit just to add something unique and extra for the fan's to enjoy? I say "Damn the Man" and power to those who dare to walk the fine line!
I don't see why it's not possible. It's all still Kirkman's universe whether it's TV, Comic's or the game it's all still The Walking Dead. … more What would a cameo of Daryl hurt? Maybe just an episode or so of him interacting with the character's similar to how Glenn or Hershal was in S1E1. They didn't greatly affect the story. I think it would be cool.
Like I would enjoy seeing a Clementine on the TV show. Again, she wouldn't have to become a major character, maybe just part of another group they encounter, maybe share a couple smiles and wink's with Carl then they all continue on their own way's.
Neither senerio need's to have any real impact on the show or in the game, but just something to give fan's of both a nice little crossover gift.
The entire Walking Dead is all just a work of fiction so why can't they bend some rule's a bit just to add something unique and extra for the fan's to enjoy? I say "Damn the Man" and power to those who dare to walk the fine line!
Here we go again.. You and I have agreed to refrain from posting on each other's comments in a couple of different threads and I for one have made the effort not to post anything regarding you. You've already butted heads with other's on this thread as well. Please try to honor our earlier agreement. Unless you cannot control the urge to troll me or other's in which case i'll simply bring this to the attention of a mod.
Here we go again.. You and I have agreed to refrain from posting on each other's comments in a couple of different threads and I for one hav… moree made the effort not to post anything regarding you. You've already butted heads with other's on this thread as well. Please try to honor our earlier agreement. Unless you cannot control the urge to troll me or other's in which case i'll simply bring this to the attention of a mod.
Thank You!
What I did say was, "You and I have agreed to refrain from posting on each other's comments in a couple of different threads and I for one have made the effort not to post anything regarding you".
If you cannot abide by our agreement then I consider that as trolling!
I wont respond to any more of your comment's if you do so either don't waste the effort or do as you choose!
I did not say you could not disagree with me!
What I did say was, "You and I have agreed to refrain from posting on each other's comments… more in a couple of different threads and I for one have made the effort not to post anything regarding you".
If you cannot abide by our agreement then I consider that as trolling!
I wont respond to any more of your comment's if you do so either don't waste the effort or do as you choose!
Maybe my issue is that I don't completely understand the definition of "canon" in regards to this.. Maybe I tend to look upon it in a more basic manner.
Kirkman created TWD. The TV show and even the game were made based upon TWD universe that he created. The TV show added Daryl who was never in the comic's meaning they didn't have any absolute rule that they had to follow the comic's to the letter.
The TTG was able to add Glenn and Hersal. So what rule or law say's it's absolutly impossible to have a crossover of character's?
If we played Season 3 and Daryl walked by, how would that destroy the game or TV show?? If some actress played Clem on the TV show for an episode, how would that destroy the show or game? It just doesnt make sence to me.
If we played Season 3 and Daryl walked by, how would that destroy the game or TV show?? If some actress played Clem on the TV show for an episode, how would that destroy the show or game? It just doesnt make sence to me.
The Game is in DIRECT correlation to the comics, everything is the same in both...To the letter. The TV show is a rogue, only barely following the lines of the comic. The game is never happening in the TV show. Having Daryl in the game would never make sense and be impossible, having Clem in the TV show is just like that too.
Maybe my issue is that I don't completely understand the definition of "canon" in regards to this.. Maybe I tend to look upon it in a more b… moreasic manner.
Kirkman created TWD. The TV show and even the game were made based upon TWD universe that he created. The TV show added Daryl who was never in the comic's meaning they didn't have any absolute rule that they had to follow the comic's to the letter.
The TTG was able to add Glenn and Hersal. So what rule or law say's it's absolutly impossible to have a crossover of character's?
If we played Season 3 and Daryl walked by, how would that destroy the game or TV show?? If some actress played Clem on the TV show for an episode, how would that destroy the show or game? It just doesnt make sence to me.
Canon is kinda confusing with adaptations. An adaptation is the retelling of a story that previously existed. The Walking Dead show is an adaptation, but is different as all of them are, meaning new characters locations, but same basic plot.
Now the Game is canon to the comics because of several things, I forget most, but one of them is Herschel and his farm. They don't look ANYTHING alike comparing the game to the show, but the comics' one is basically the same. So therefore, it is based on the comics. The Game is NOT based on TWD comic universe. It is directly set in it. Glenn and Herschel appear in their comic form, and stay that way in game and comics.
The reason it would mess up the canon is because it is merging 2 separate universes. Think about combing the events of the novel Jurassic Park and film. It just won't work and basically it destroy our understanding of it, since different things happen in both. The Game and show cannot be present with each other, as the game is basically the comics, which is different than the show.
Maybe my issue is that I don't completely understand the definition of "canon" in regards to this.. Maybe I tend to look upon it in a more b… moreasic manner.
Kirkman created TWD. The TV show and even the game were made based upon TWD universe that he created. The TV show added Daryl who was never in the comic's meaning they didn't have any absolute rule that they had to follow the comic's to the letter.
The TTG was able to add Glenn and Hersal. So what rule or law say's it's absolutly impossible to have a crossover of character's?
If we played Season 3 and Daryl walked by, how would that destroy the game or TV show?? If some actress played Clem on the TV show for an episode, how would that destroy the show or game? It just doesnt make sence to me.
Okay, I have to admit that I have never read any of the comic's because I simply never even heard or TWD before the TV show. I found a youtube video of the game before I ever heard of TTG tbh. So my only real knowledge of TWD is from the TV show and I have purposly avoided the comic's because I don't want the spoiler's. That being said, I have still learned a few thing's regarding the comic's than I wanted to, but being a fan around here's it's hard to avoid everything. I remember when we first met Michonne, I had no Idea who she was, but I noticed that many TV fan's were going crazy about her talking of the comic's character. Same with Abraham and Eugene, and the Governor.. I realized during the season's all these were character's from the comic's.
Then comes TT TWD and we saw Glenn and Hershal, that was very cool, and people here have talked about Lilly and how there is a Lilly in the comic's. (though if I recall they are actually different character's they just share the same name) It all just seem's to me their would be no harm in as I suggested, a cameo appearance. Something small and meaningless to the main stories, but just intended to give fan's a nice moment.
The reason it would mess up the canon is because it is merging 2 separate universes. so what? it's a work of fiction anyways and if the bit's are small and insignificent to the main story, why would it matter?
Kenny is on his boat, crossing the south pacific. He gazes out to a small island and plot's a course. Suddenly a storm brew's, his tiny ship is tossed, if not for the courage of his fearless crew, his canoe would be lost. He goes into the island and soon find's himself being chased by walker's. One is dressed in a red shirt, white sailor pants and hat, the other look's like a captain, another like a professor, there's a millionaire and his wife, a movie star too.
Yes silly but that's kinda the point. How come something that's a work of fiction, that doesnt truely impact the story be impossible?
btw, I've only seen the Jurassic park movies, never read the book's so I cannot grasp that specific analogy.
Thank's for taking the effort to explain it all though!
Canon is kinda confusing with adaptations. An adaptation is the retelling of a story that previously existed. The Walking Dead show is an ad… moreaptation, but is different as all of them are, meaning new characters locations, but same basic plot.
Now the Game is canon to the comics because of several things, I forget most, but one of them is Herschel and his farm. They don't look ANYTHING alike comparing the game to the show, but the comics' one is basically the same. So therefore, it is based on the comics. The Game is NOT based on TWD comic universe. It is directly set in it. Glenn and Herschel appear in their comic form, and stay that way in game and comics.
The reason it would mess up the canon is because it is merging 2 separate universes. Think about combing the events of the novel Jurassic Park and film. It just won't work and basically it destroy our understanding of it, since different things happen in both. The Game and show canno… [view original content]
Okay, I have to admit that I have never read any of the comic's because I simply never even heard or TWD before the TV show. I found a yout… moreube video of the game before I ever heard of TTG tbh. So my only real knowledge of TWD is from the TV show and I have purposly avoided the comic's because I don't want the spoiler's. That being said, I have still learned a few thing's regarding the comic's than I wanted to, but being a fan around here's it's hard to avoid everything. I remember when we first met Michonne, I had no Idea who she was, but I noticed that many TV fan's were going crazy about her talking of the comic's character. Same with Abraham and Eugene, and the Governor.. I realized during the season's all these were character's from the comic's.
Then comes TT TWD and we saw Glenn and Hershal, that was very cool, and people here have talked about Lilly and how there is a Lilly in the comic's. (though if I recall they are actually di… [view original content]
Great post, loved the Gilligan's Island reference, but on merging the canon, while it is a work of fiction, it sets rules for itself. As much as I want to see Clementine and Carl act as awkward teenagers, and Kenny to play ping-pong with Negan, the butterfly effect, and the 'essence of chaos' is that small changes make big differences in long run.
Okay, I have to admit that I have never read any of the comic's because I simply never even heard or TWD before the TV show. I found a yout… moreube video of the game before I ever heard of TTG tbh. So my only real knowledge of TWD is from the TV show and I have purposly avoided the comic's because I don't want the spoiler's. That being said, I have still learned a few thing's regarding the comic's than I wanted to, but being a fan around here's it's hard to avoid everything. I remember when we first met Michonne, I had no Idea who she was, but I noticed that many TV fan's were going crazy about her talking of the comic's character. Same with Abraham and Eugene, and the Governor.. I realized during the season's all these were character's from the comic's.
Then comes TT TWD and we saw Glenn and Hershal, that was very cool, and people here have talked about Lilly and how there is a Lilly in the comic's. (though if I recall they are actually di… [view original content]
Understood and I wont continue to debate the matter but I still personally would love to see Clem and Carl in that awkward teen moment.. I think it would have been a treat for us fan's of both the TV show and game.
BTW, as a matter of fact I watched Jurrassic park on AMC lastnight and liked Jeff Goldblum's character explaining his theory of the Butterfly effect and the 'essence of chaos'. The preview for Jurrassic World look's awsome!
Great post, loved the Gilligan's Island reference, but on merging the canon, while it is a work of fiction, it sets rules for itself. As muc… moreh as I want to see Clementine and Carl act as awkward teenagers, and Kenny to play ping-pong with Negan, the butterfly effect, and the 'essence of chaos' is that small changes make big differences in long run.
I generally enjoy Daryl's character well enough, but I feel like he's already served his purpose from the first 2 seasons well enough. Back when pretty much everyone in the show was "zombies! OMG!", Daryl was "we'll deal with this and get results". Now all the people who fit into the first group are dead or changed over to the second group to varying degrees. I'm glad the show's been pushing Carol and him together (I like him better in smaller groups).
That being said, TWD S2 has already given us a badass, gruff crossbow wielder who nevertheless has a heart of gold for his dysfunctional family and children. His name was Pete; we all know what happened to Pete. RIP. I hope whoever shot him (Carver likely) got him before the zombies did.
...I'm okay with Daryl. Anyway, I don't see it possible how they'll do it since Daryl is TV Universe only while the game is linked to the comic universe. It's 100% impossible.
I think Norman Reedus is an amazing actor but I dislike the character. Daryl was put in by AMC to look pretty to draw the attention of a wider audience. He wasn't in the comics, he's about as useful as T-Dog. So please for the love of God do not put him in Telltale the walking dead.
Comments
The game isn't in the TV universe.
It isn't the same universe.
Not really. Daryl doesn't exist in comic universe, and Andrea is alive in comics.
Yes it is, its like happening at the same time, with the whole Lilly character in the game AND the comics, and Glen in the game AND the TV show
Well, we were taking about The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct, then you randomly say,
So tell me, why does your freedom of speech have to do with this particular statement, and why do you bring Silent Hill?
Because it's called changing the subject, not freedom of speech.
[removed]
Gotta agree with ol' Pal here.
And here's a question, how come if Carol is dead in the comics, why isn't she dead the show? They are totally separate entities, it's like the book, The Hobbit, which is different from the Hobbit movies, which are inspired by book.
Was this suppose to be replied to me?
No. For one thing, I find the guy overrated. Secondly, he exists in the TV universe, not the comic universe. The game takes place in the comic universe so it's not possible.
Opal is not amused
Definitely not.
I don't see why it's not possible. It's all still Kirkman's universe whether it's TV, Comic's or the game it's all still The Walking Dead. What would a cameo of Daryl hurt? Maybe just an episode or so of him interacting with the character's similar to how Glenn or Hershal was in S1E1. They didn't greatly affect the story. I think it would be cool.
Like I would enjoy seeing a Clementine on the TV show. Again, she wouldn't have to become a major character, maybe just part of another group they encounter, maybe share a couple smiles and wink's with Carl then they all continue on their own way's.
Neither senerio need's to have any real impact on the show or in the game, but just something to give fan's of both a nice little crossover gift.
The entire Walking Dead is all just a work of fiction so why can't they bend some rule's a bit just to add something unique and extra for the fan's to enjoy? I say "Damn the Man" and power to those who dare to walk the fine line!
Not the same universe.
It's impossible.
Here we go again.. You and I have agreed to refrain from posting on each other's comments in a couple of different threads and I for one have made the effort not to post anything regarding you. You've already butted heads with other's on this thread as well. Please try to honor our earlier agreement. Unless you cannot control the urge to troll me or other's in which case i'll simply bring this to the attention of a mod.
Thank You!
no no and no daryl does not exist in the game/comic universe
I was all okay with you till this comment.
I can't disagree with you?
I did not say you could not disagree with me!
What I did say was, "You and I have agreed to refrain from posting on each other's comments in a couple of different threads and I for one have made the effort not to post anything regarding you".
If you cannot abide by our agreement then I consider that as trolling!
I wont respond to any more of your comment's if you do so either don't waste the effort or do as you choose!
The game is canon to the comics. Darryl wasn't in the comics.
Then you have a pretty weird definition of trolling, how about we have our debates?
Or you can bring this to a Mod, neither of us do anything wrong!
How about instead of pulling this just comment back defending your position.
You should have left out me being a troll, which i'm not, and I would have said okay, but you attempt to antagonize me.
No it wasn't. Oops. And I've forgotten who I was to comment to.
Just because Daryl was in it doesn't make it a bad game. The idea for Survival Instinct was a very very good idea, but it was just executed poorly.
It's all cool, I was confused if you were asking me that question.
Maybe my issue is that I don't completely understand the definition of "canon" in regards to this.. Maybe I tend to look upon it in a more basic manner.
Kirkman created TWD. The TV show and even the game were made based upon TWD universe that he created. The TV show added Daryl who was never in the comic's meaning they didn't have any absolute rule that they had to follow the comic's to the letter.
The TTG was able to add Glenn and Hersal. So what rule or law say's it's absolutly impossible to have a crossover of character's?
If we played Season 3 and Daryl walked by, how would that destroy the game or TV show?? If some actress played Clem on the TV show for an episode, how would that destroy the show or game? It just doesnt make sence to me.
The Game is in DIRECT correlation to the comics, everything is the same in both...To the letter. The TV show is a rogue, only barely following the lines of the comic. The game is never happening in the TV show. Having Daryl in the game would never make sense and be impossible, having Clem in the TV show is just like that too.
The game is canon to the comics, and Daryl doesn't exist in the comics.
Canon is kinda confusing with adaptations. An adaptation is the retelling of a story that previously existed. The Walking Dead show is an adaptation, but is different as all of them are, meaning new characters locations, but same basic plot.
Now the Game is canon to the comics because of several things, I forget most, but one of them is Herschel and his farm. They don't look ANYTHING alike comparing the game to the show, but the comics' one is basically the same. So therefore, it is based on the comics. The Game is NOT based on TWD comic universe. It is directly set in it. Glenn and Herschel appear in their comic form, and stay that way in game and comics.
The reason it would mess up the canon is because it is merging 2 separate universes. Think about combing the events of the novel Jurassic Park and film. It just won't work and basically it destroy our understanding of it, since different things happen in both. The Game and show cannot be present with each other, as the game is basically the comics, which is different than the show.
Walking Into this thread be like
Okay, I have to admit that I have never read any of the comic's because I simply never even heard or TWD before the TV show. I found a youtube video of the game before I ever heard of TTG tbh. So my only real knowledge of TWD is from the TV show and I have purposly avoided the comic's because I don't want the spoiler's. That being said, I have still learned a few thing's regarding the comic's than I wanted to, but being a fan around here's it's hard to avoid everything. I remember when we first met Michonne, I had no Idea who she was, but I noticed that many TV fan's were going crazy about her talking of the comic's character. Same with Abraham and Eugene, and the Governor.. I realized during the season's all these were character's from the comic's.
Then comes TT TWD and we saw Glenn and Hershal, that was very cool, and people here have talked about Lilly and how there is a Lilly in the comic's. (though if I recall they are actually different character's they just share the same name) It all just seem's to me their would be no harm in as I suggested, a cameo appearance. Something small and meaningless to the main stories, but just intended to give fan's a nice moment.
The reason it would mess up the canon is because it is merging 2 separate universes. so what? it's a work of fiction anyways and if the bit's are small and insignificent to the main story, why would it matter?
Kenny is on his boat, crossing the south pacific. He gazes out to a small island and plot's a course. Suddenly a storm brew's, his tiny ship is tossed, if not for the courage of his fearless crew, his canoe would be lost. He goes into the island and soon find's himself being chased by walker's. One is dressed in a red shirt, white sailor pants and hat, the other look's like a captain, another like a professor, there's a millionaire and his wife, a movie star too.
Yes silly but that's kinda the point. How come something that's a work of fiction, that doesnt truely impact the story be impossible?
btw, I've only seen the Jurassic park movies, never read the book's so I cannot grasp that specific analogy.
Thank's for taking the effort to explain it all though!
Never seen so much truth in one sentence.
Well considering that they live in separate universe's that would be rather difficult for them to meet.
But honestly, Daryl would not fit in this game, and I personally hate the character with every fiber of being, he's so overrated.
Nice Gilligan's Island reference!
Great post, loved the Gilligan's Island reference, but on merging the canon, while it is a work of fiction, it sets rules for itself. As much as I want to see Clementine and Carl act as awkward teenagers, and Kenny to play ping-pong with Negan, the butterfly effect, and the 'essence of chaos' is that small changes make big differences in long run.
Understood and I wont continue to debate the matter but I still personally would love to see Clem and Carl in that awkward teen moment.. I think it would have been a treat for us fan's of both the TV show and game.
BTW, as a matter of fact I watched Jurrassic park on AMC lastnight and liked Jeff Goldblum's character explaining his theory of the Butterfly effect and the 'essence of chaos'. The preview for Jurrassic World look's awsome!
I generally enjoy Daryl's character well enough, but I feel like he's already served his purpose from the first 2 seasons well enough. Back when pretty much everyone in the show was "zombies! OMG!", Daryl was "we'll deal with this and get results". Now all the people who fit into the first group are dead or changed over to the second group to varying degrees. I'm glad the show's been pushing Carol and him together (I like him better in smaller groups).
That being said, TWD S2 has already given us a badass, gruff crossbow wielder who nevertheless has a heart of gold for his dysfunctional family and children. His name was Pete; we all know what happened to Pete. RIP. I hope whoever shot him (Carver likely) got him before the zombies did.
I miss the downvote ;(
Having daryl in the game would be the worst thing ever, most overrated character ever
silent hills has nothing to do with how shit twd survival instinct is don't try to change the subject
...I'm okay with Daryl. Anyway, I don't see it possible how they'll do it since Daryl is TV Universe only while the game is linked to the comic universe. It's 100% impossible.
Just going to put this out there....I hate Daryl.
I think Norman Reedus is an amazing actor but I dislike the character. Daryl was put in by AMC to look pretty to draw the attention of a wider audience. He wasn't in the comics, he's about as useful as T-Dog. So please for the love of God do not put him in Telltale the walking dead.
In conclusion my answer would be -
I hope not. He cried in third season. Wuss.