Who would you rather return; Christa or Lilly?

2»

Comments

  • Lmao, don't try sarcasm. Last time you did, you got completely wrecked. And I'll be happy to do it again if you like, but I've got some stuff to do. Let's try tomorrow.

    MrX1H2 posted: »

    Woah calm down there sweetheart, no need to get your jimmies rustled. Having a bad day? We can talk about it if you like.

  • No sarcasm intended. I sincerely want to know what is that caused you to come out in such a manner. I hope to have a civil conversation with you about the matter and hope to help you through whatever problems you might be facing.

    Lmao, don't try sarcasm. Last time you did, you got completely wrecked. And I'll be happy to do it again if you like, but I've got some stuff to do. Let's try tomorrow.

  • I hope to have a civil conversation with you

    Oh?

    Weirdo.

    Oh.

    Goodbye, honey.

    MrX1H2 posted: »

    No sarcasm intended. I sincerely want to know what is that caused you to come out in such a manner. I hope to have a civil conversation with you about the matter and hope to help you through whatever problems you might be facing.

  • edited December 2014

    Everyone calm down. Nothing has changed has it? We stay the course, don't turn on each other.

    I hope to have a civil conversation with you Oh? Weirdo. Oh. Goodbye, honey.

  • lmao no

    Clemenem posted: »

    Everyone calm down. Nothing has changed has it? We stay the course, don't turn on each other.

  • MrX1H2MrX1H2 Banned
    edited December 2014

    Well in my defense you had acted out in a strange manner to my seemingly innocent post which had caused great confusion to me as I had not intended it to be something difficult to understand.To which then you acted out in an extremely uncalled for and harsh manner when you could have simply told me what you found wrong with my post. I am greatly sorry if my remark to you caused you any great deal of trouble. I really didn't mean anything by it other than your replies to me seemed a bit odd to me.

    But now I would like to talk to you about your problems if you let me and find out what caused you to act in such a rash manner and help you from it, for example, I see your the one to hold grudges. We can talk about that first if you like. Or we can work on your social skills and how to act and respond in a proper manner. Remember, words can't hurt you if you don't let them and I'm always here to talk.

    I hope to have a civil conversation with you Oh? Weirdo. Oh. Goodbye, honey.

  • you had acted out in a strange manner to my seemingly innocent post which

    Sorry for my ignorance, but I didn't know that insulting someone was 'innocent'.

    To which then you acted out in an extremely uncalled for and harsh manner

    Oh, so in your eyes, you're either the victim...

    or the victim. Hmph.

    when you could have simply told me what you found wrong with my post.

    I did.

    Don't call me a weirdo. I didn't even insult your sorry ass.

    But yeah.

    I am greatly sorry if my remark to you caused you any great deal of trouble

    Sorry, love, but you should have said that in the first place. Better yet, not insult me at all.

    I really didn't mean anything by it other than your replies to me seemed a bit odd to me.

    That doesn't justify the need to call me a 'weirdo', but okay.

    But now I would like to talk to you about your problems if you let me and find out what caused you if you to act in such a rash manner and help you from it

    I would, but I don't think the language and your character involvement would be PG.

    I see your the one to hold grudges.

    LOL! Says the one who tends to mimic me when it comes to retaliation. Funny how the other time we crossed paths, you got rather annoyed from when I called you "Sweetheart" or "Honey". But then you go ahead and say it to me?

    You must not know me at all if you think I hold grudges.

    Or we can work on your social skills and how to act and respond in a proper manner. Remember, words can't hurt you if you don't let them and I'm always here to talk.

    My social skills. How interesting. Why don't you just... you know? Read your comment to begin with? "So do i want a boring depressing bitch to return or a unstable psychotic bitch to return?"

    Adorable. Your need to try and make me angry shows your vulnerability and how much you struggle. It's amusing, to be honest. Have fun with whatever life you have, love. I'm sure your need will pass sooner or later.

    MrX1H2 posted: »

    Well in my defense you had acted out in a strange manner to my seemingly innocent post which had caused great confusion to me as I had not i

  • I'd rather see what happened to Lilly after what happened- if she's still the same or if she became more like Carver/Jane after losing Larry and being left behind. Most of all, her reaction to seeing Clem again would be pure gold- would she be glad, or would it remind her of the old days and would she not like Clem? What would be even better is if you (at the end of Season 2) chose to go with Kenny and THEN ran into Lilly with Kenny as well; I'm guessing that would eventually result in another Jane-Kenny style fight.
    However, although it'd be interesting to see what happened I hope neither come back- I want some fresh characters (although Kenny never gets old so they better keep him alive!), not people randomly returning from nowhere. The game would lose it's realism if people started coming back.
    If anyone is going to return, it'll be Bonnie- we never saw her die, and Mike's character doesn't have the depth to be another main character for the next season- Bonnie is more interesting (though I do hate her!), especially if she chooses to tell Clem about her past (the story from 400 Days). Plus, Clem has had multiple father figures in her short time so having a mother figure would balance things out a bit and would have an interesting effect on her character.

  • Personally, i don't want any characters i like in S3, because I'm afraid for their lives.

    Hola, George.

  • Was just looking through the commentxs and someone suggested that Lilly could be the leader of Wellington- that situation would be a ridiculous coincidence BUT it would be an amazing plot twist. As i said though, either of them returning would ruin it a bit. Bring on the new characters for Season 3! Also saw someone suggest Nate from 400 Days, which would be interesting though he's probably dead. Plus I couldn't imagine Clem lasting to long under his care!

  • Yeah but look how Kenny turned out?

    CrazyGeorge posted: »

    Personally, i don't want any characters i like in S3, because I'm afraid for their lives.

  • If both are so desired to return I wonder....

    Why not both?

    Just a suggestion.

  • I'm on the fence. I had more overall interest in Lilly as a character, but I was still disappointed that they never resolved Christa's disappearance.

  • I was so unbelievably pissed at Lilly after she killed Carley in cold blood for absolutely no god damn reason.

    But I'd still say her. An interesting character that you kind of hate is better than a boring character that you're completely ambivalent towards.

  • I'd really like to see both, but if I had to choose Christa.

    (Where's the Molly answer?)

  • edited January 2015

    Lilly.

    So I can kill her. :p

  • I liked Lilly since I met her, so her.

  • edited December 2014

    "Carver/Jane" You mean Jane in survival kind of way and not like Carver, right? Just so I don't confuse your comment.

    I'd rather see what happened to Lilly after what happened- if she's still the same or if she became more like Carver/Jane after losing Larry

  • Jane is a survivor yes, but when you dig deeper you find that she has a lot more similarities with Carver than you would think, and she definitely has more similarities with him than Kenny does.
    Just one example- Jane sticks around with Clem because she's useful and knows how to protect herself (she didn't do the same for Sarah, so it's nothing to do with the fact that she's a little kid), whilst Carver believes Clem is important to the future of his camp. Both see Clem as useful to their own goals (survival), unlike Kenny who's been with her since she was eight and almost got killed trying to save her.

    Deventh posted: »

    "Carver/Jane" You mean Jane in survival kind of way and not like Carver, right? Just so I don't confuse your comment.

  • Unfortunately I can't agree you there. One coming back would ruin the realism, so both of them?? I can't see that happening and I pray to God that it doesn't.

    Good suggestion though.

    MaconMajr posted: »

    If both are so desired to return I wonder.... Why not both? Just a suggestion.

  • What would be very interesting is if you chose to stay with Kenny and THEN you met Lilly again. I don't quite know how she would react: would she be glad to see an old face again and would she have changed? Or would she kill Kenny on the spot?

    I was so unbelievably pissed at Lilly after she killed Carley in cold blood for absolutely no god damn reason. But I'd still say her. An

  • edited December 2014

    Chrsita because finding Lilly would be a little too far fetched and also because I would like to see how she would react over AJ since she lost her baby and over Kenny since she thought he was dead. But honestly I would prefer them to focus solely on new characters because if they keep bringing back old ones it's just going to look lile a cheap attempt on Telltale's part to take advantage of season 1's great success. They should do something different if they want to remain credible.

  • Really tough choice, Lilly went through losing her father and a mental breakdown, Christa losing Omid and her baby. Yet, if they were on your side, they were extremely loyal.

    I'd go with Christa, because I did kill Larry, and I was justified, but sadly, Lilly didn't see this side.

  • Lilly, just so i can continue being an asshole towards her

  • Lilly and Christa are definitely some of the strongest independent survivors I've come across, Lilly was one a pilot in the army, if we find an air vehicle she might be very useful and she trained the group of season 1 with arms, not to mention she is someone who can't be fooled or duped easy, someone who has a sharp eye but she can be unstable sometimes, she's the type of person who prefers to stay in the same place and she lost her father, Larry, to Kenny and determinantly Lee who had no justifiable reason to do so and she is later called a murderer by the same man who murdered her father and she is determinantly left to die by the group. As for Christa, she is adept in independent survival, she can take care of herself and has been shown to be able to take care of others, also with compassion, Christa knows survival and she seems to know a bit about medical stuff as well, however, she doesn't fond large groups and she's been shown to hold a grudge, she lost her husband, Omid and her baby, she's gone through allot but has kept her mentality in tact.

    I'd choose Lilly because she was treated unfairly by the group in season 1 and I personally like Lilly, I'd especially like it if both appeared, I'd like to see how they react to one another during their first time meeting one another, Season 3 could be Christa VS Lilly.

  • I'm hoping both will return.

    The two of them interacting would make interesting development. Both women are as mentioned above "strong, independent women" plus both have lost someone they loved. I believe this theme would give them kinship. Plus both of them care for Clem,

    A trio of independent heroines...I like it.
    An interesting concept...
    In my opinion, but what will others think?

  • To think, both were only a few hours away from eachother when we leave Lilly and meet Christa. I wonder how they would have gotten along?

    I don't really see Lilly having a beef with Clementine, even if Lee can do/say some not so nice things to her. Although that still wouldn't change what the player thinks of her (funny enough that's kinda how the Kenny situation is).

    I guess I would want Christa back though. She and Clem have had their history and have spent a long time skip with eachother. Would love some insight on that if anything.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.