Comparing the stranger to Jane is like comparing apples to oranges. The stranger was a crazy guy who was stalking them and he kidnapped Clem. And even though the stranger went crazy because of their actions. You can't justify what he was doing to Lee and Clem. Remember Clem liked Jane and she didn't like the stranger. So to saying lee would treat Jane like the stranger is ridiculous.
When Clem was in trouble, Lee killed the Stranger. He didn't show any mercy then, when arguably the Stranger's argument actually made a bit … moreof sense (I don't agree with the Stranger of course). That's a determinant decision.
When Kenny thinks that Jane has killed/lost the baby, he reacts just as Lee did. So yes, Lee would have done exactly the same thing, regardless of the decisions you made as Lee (as killing the Stranger is determinant).
No offense, but by creating this thread, you just reignited the fire. I am beyond sick of people bashing Kenny every chance they get. The Kenny vs. Jane war will never end at this rate. 99.9% of the arguments I see are literally "my opinion is fact", plus the same recycled excuses (Jane never said AJ was dead, ect.). It's the epitome of immaturity, especially when these people resort to personal insults. It's like we're supposed to feel guilty for choosing Kenny.
Again, I'm not trying to scold you, but this thread was doomed to become a flame war from the very start. Saying "Lee would/wouldn't have done this" just reeks of bias because his actions were mainly left up to the player.
I actually don't hate kenny. The whole time I was trying to have Clem calm him down because I new that the group was going to do something a… morebout him. But obvisioulty you can't really change the story line in this game. Kenny was suppose to tare the group apart and make it difficullt for Clem to choose between the new people in her life and her old friend.
Clementine may have actually liked the stranger at one point. She talks to him over the radio through the course of S1 and refers to him as nice and trying to help her (even though we know it was under false pretenses, sound familiar?). I'm sure after the being kidnapped and the scuffle between him and Lee, Clementine knew she had to make a choice and it was Lee.
Comparing the stranger to Jane is like comparing apples to oranges. The stranger was a crazy guy who was stalking them and he kidnapped Clem… more. And even though the stranger went crazy because of their actions. You can't justify what he was doing to Lee and Clem. Remember Clem liked Jane and she didn't like the stranger. So to saying lee would treat Jane like the stranger is ridiculous.
first off I came in late on this discussion because I just finished the game. If I want to discuss this now or anytime I can. But I'm not the one that's insulting anyone. I've been handling my responses with maturity. And by the way you are trying to scold me. If you don't want to be a part of the discussion then don't click on this topic. Just change the channel.
No offense, but by creating this thread, you just reignited the fire. I am beyond sick of people bashing Kenny every chance they get. The Ke… morenny vs. Jane war will never end at this rate. 99.9% of the arguments I see are literally "my opinion is fact", plus the same recycled excuses (Jane never said AJ was dead, ect.). It's the epitome of immaturity, especially when these people resort to personal insults. It's like we're supposed to feel guilty for choosing Kenny.
Again, I'm not trying to scold you, but this thread was doomed to become a flame war from the very start. Saying "Lee would/wouldn't have done this" just reeks of bias because his actions were mainly left up to the player.
Well Clem was younger and as kid could be easily influenced by a stranger to appear as nice. The Clementine you see today wouldn't have be influenced by the stranger at her age now. But comparing them to each other is still apples and oranges.
Clementine may have actually liked the stranger at one point. She talks to him over the radio through the course of S1 and refers to him as … morenice and trying to help her (even though we know it was under false pretenses, sound familiar?). I'm sure after the being kidnapped and the scuffle between him and Lee, Clementine knew she had to make a choice and it was Lee.
Calm down, and please don't put words in my mouth. Like I said, no, I'm not trying to scold you. This is just a warning to look before posting from now on to avoid more catty fighting. I never said you were the one causing trouble, now did I? I guess you'll be glad to know I also never planned on sticking around anyway. I've said my piece and given you clarity, so I won't be coming back. Tootles.
first off I came in late on this discussion because I just finished the game. If I want to discuss this now or anytime I can. But I'm not th… moree one that's insulting anyone. I've been handling my responses with maturity. And by the way you are trying to scold me. If you don't want to be a part of the discussion then don't click on this topic. Just change the channel.
Or that AJ was grabbed by a walker while Jane was in the blizzard where anyone could easily lose anything, Jane could've tripped and lost AJ, Jane could've been attacked and the walker could've grabbed AJ and there was nothing she could do, thus meaning she didn't kill AJ but it was an accident on her part, Jane wasn't trying to kill Kenny though, she only acted in self defence after she lowered her weapon and Kenny lunged at her. If Kenny's last piece of hope is a baby he only just met a few days ago, then that means if Clementine did anything to AJ she'd probably get similar treatment and Kenny's done allot worse... just saying...
Jane said; 'I didn't kill him it was an accident Kenny!' Implying that she did kill him but it was an accident, I never said I was mad at Ja… morene for defending herself but her actions (of hiding the baby and implying that it had died) contributed to Kennys death. True he may have been going 'crazy' but to try and kill a man that has lost everything and pretend you have taken away one of his last pieces of hope, that's just wrong... Just saying.:P
Yeah an 'accident' that she never explained, it wasn't even an accident and AJ wasn't even dead yet she didn't say that, she missed out that part of the story. Jane wasn't trying to kill Kenny huh? So I guess her smothering her fingers on his face and beating him up doesn't count for that? I know that he was the one that tried to kill her first but that was all her fault, she provoked him and wanted a reaction out of him, when he says 'I'm gonna kill you' she says 'I knew you would' meaning she knew that Kenny wouldn't take the news well and who would? True you shouldn't kill someone over it but when it came down to the choice, I chose Kenny because none of that would have happened if it weren't for Jane hiding the baby, it was her fault so she has to live with the consequences. I can't say whether or not he would have done the same with Clementine but honestly, I don't think he would have since he thought that Jane killed the baby purposely since he knew she didn't really want the baby, that's why he killed her, he thought she killed the baby purposely to try to get rid of it. Kenny would know that Clementine wouldn't do that so I doubt he would react the same to her... just saying...:P
And this is why I don't like to get involved in the whole Kenny vs Jane thing!
Or that AJ was grabbed by a walker while Jane was in the blizzard where anyone could easily lose anything, Jane could've tripped and lost AJ… more, Jane could've been attacked and the walker could've grabbed AJ and there was nothing she could do, thus meaning she didn't kill AJ but it was an accident on her part, Jane wasn't trying to kill Kenny though, she only acted in self defence after she lowered her weapon and Kenny lunged at her. If Kenny's last piece of hope is a baby he only just met a few days ago, then that means if Clementine did anything to AJ she'd probably get similar treatment and Kenny's done allot worse... just saying...
Comments
Comparing the stranger to Jane is like comparing apples to oranges. The stranger was a crazy guy who was stalking them and he kidnapped Clem. And even though the stranger went crazy because of their actions. You can't justify what he was doing to Lee and Clem. Remember Clem liked Jane and she didn't like the stranger. So to saying lee would treat Jane like the stranger is ridiculous.
No offense, but by creating this thread, you just reignited the fire. I am beyond sick of people bashing Kenny every chance they get. The Kenny vs. Jane war will never end at this rate. 99.9% of the arguments I see are literally "my opinion is fact", plus the same recycled excuses (Jane never said AJ was dead, ect.). It's the epitome of immaturity, especially when these people resort to personal insults. It's like we're supposed to feel guilty for choosing Kenny.
Again, I'm not trying to scold you, but this thread was doomed to become a flame war from the very start. Saying "Lee would/wouldn't have done this" just reeks of bias because his actions were mainly left up to the player.
Clementine may have actually liked the stranger at one point. She talks to him over the radio through the course of S1 and refers to him as nice and trying to help her (even though we know it was under false pretenses, sound familiar?). I'm sure after the being kidnapped and the scuffle between him and Lee, Clementine knew she had to make a choice and it was Lee.
first off I came in late on this discussion because I just finished the game. If I want to discuss this now or anytime I can. But I'm not the one that's insulting anyone. I've been handling my responses with maturity. And by the way you are trying to scold me. If you don't want to be a part of the discussion then don't click on this topic. Just change the channel.
Well Clem was younger and as kid could be easily influenced by a stranger to appear as nice. The Clementine you see today wouldn't have be influenced by the stranger at her age now. But comparing them to each other is still apples and oranges.
Calm down, and please don't put words in my mouth. Like I said, no, I'm not trying to scold you. This is just a warning to look before posting from now on to avoid more catty fighting. I never said you were the one causing trouble, now did I? I guess you'll be glad to know I also never planned on sticking around anyway. I've said my piece and given you clarity, so I won't be coming back. Tootles.
How exactly is shooting someone equal to controlling them?
Or that AJ was grabbed by a walker while Jane was in the blizzard where anyone could easily lose anything, Jane could've tripped and lost AJ, Jane could've been attacked and the walker could've grabbed AJ and there was nothing she could do, thus meaning she didn't kill AJ but it was an accident on her part, Jane wasn't trying to kill Kenny though, she only acted in self defence after she lowered her weapon and Kenny lunged at her. If Kenny's last piece of hope is a baby he only just met a few days ago, then that means if Clementine did anything to AJ she'd probably get similar treatment and Kenny's done allot worse... just saying...
Yeah an 'accident' that she never explained, it wasn't even an accident and AJ wasn't even dead yet she didn't say that, she missed out that part of the story. Jane wasn't trying to kill Kenny huh? So I guess her smothering her fingers on his face and beating him up doesn't count for that? I know that he was the one that tried to kill her first but that was all her fault, she provoked him and wanted a reaction out of him, when he says 'I'm gonna kill you' she says 'I knew you would' meaning she knew that Kenny wouldn't take the news well and who would? True you shouldn't kill someone over it but when it came down to the choice, I chose Kenny because none of that would have happened if it weren't for Jane hiding the baby, it was her fault so she has to live with the consequences. I can't say whether or not he would have done the same with Clementine but honestly, I don't think he would have since he thought that Jane killed the baby purposely since he knew she didn't really want the baby, that's why he killed her, he thought she killed the baby purposely to try to get rid of it. Kenny would know that Clementine wouldn't do that so I doubt he would react the same to her... just saying...:P
And this is why I don't like to get involved in the whole Kenny vs Jane thing!