who would win in a fight lee and clem vs rick and carl?
what do you guys think? and when i mean Clem i mean the older Clem from season 2
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
what do you guys think? and when i mean Clem i mean the older Clem from season 2
Comments
Carl wouldn't come to the fight because he'd be too busy NOT BEING IN THE HOUSE!
and rick would be to busy eye fucking the camera lol
tv
Wait is it tv Rick and Carl or comic book Rick and Carl? Because their is a difference.
Carl can suck it. Clem and Lee all the way.
Carl will probably be yelling at his dad for something while Rick is starring into space somewhere.
Carl wouldn't be a big help, he'd eat pudding all the time. And Rick would be interrupted by a urgent phone call by his dead wife.
So sadly, the battle can't take place.
Funny topic.
If it was an MMA cage battle royale, Rick & Carl.
If it was set in an open terrain where you can use your surrondings, Lee & Clem.
I feel comic rick would own, no offense.
I gotta make a gif of this holy shit.
Lee and Clem. Just because they work together better.
Clem would shove her foot up Carl's ass and beat him till CORAL says sorry for insulting Clems hat, and Rick vs Lee could be a close fight but Depends if you cut off Lee's arm or not and if this is Comic Book Rick...
Lee over Tv Rick
Comic Rick over Lee
Clem over tv Carl
Clem/ comic Carl would end in a draw.
I think people have it wrong. Comic rick gets destroyed. He has one hand..... Well you can put one handed lee but still lee... And TV Rick vs lee slight edge to lee
If just fight with nothing c'mon. Carl. But with terrain Clem, cuz she's sneaky as hell. Both comic and show. Now using a gun Carl TV.
Carl would just run and hide behind his father SECONDS after telling him that he doesn't need him and can take care of himself. Lee and clem would annihilate both of them seconds after. End of story.
Rick, from the tv show, would beat Lee.
Have you noticed how brutal he is in a fight nowadays?
Like, Damn!
I also think Carl, from the show, would also win.
He's stronger.
Older: 14 years old to be exact.
Bigger.
And he's actually killed someone in cold-blood.
I think Clementine could kill Carl even though hes way bigger, Carl is really over confident and that would bite him in gluteus maximus
Clem and Lee would win. Because Carl would be busy eating puding and Rick doing stuff and things.
idk..Carl, as much of an angsty child he can be, is a very good shot. And Rick..well, he ripped a guy's jugular out with his teeth. If that's not beast mode then I don't know what is. Sorry Lee and Clem, gotta go with the Sheriff and his son on this one.
Do you mean... Rick and ....
CORAL?
LOL jk jk, I just love this meme.
Hmm, well, I haven't read the comics or watched the show. So, I really don't know.
depends which versions of rick and carl we are talking about here
i'm going to say that the hard honest truth is that comic rick would beat lee any day simply cause he has more experience s2 clem and comic carl would have a draw imo
but clem and lee would beat tv show rick and carl any day
Can someone explain how clem and carl can have a draw?
Rick and Carl would beat the shit out of Lee and Clem.
If TV show Rick and Carl: Clem and Lee FTW
If comic Rick and Carl: Rick and Carl would hand them their asses on a silver platter with a side plate of shame.
But since the video game is in comic universe... Sorry Clem and Lee.
i think lee from episode "no going back" and season 2 Clem would beat rick and Carl from the comics and tv show. lee is pretty tough because if u choose to cut his arm off, he is still able to kill his way threw a herd of walkers and kill the stranger with all hand to hand combat.
Lee for the win! ... and Clem!
Depending on how you play the game Lee can get owned by clem's kidnapper, he can get his ass kicked by Kenny and Molly. Lee needs Carly and lilly to help him when he fights Andy. How is Lee even proven in combat?
Rick on the other hand drew in a fight with Tyrese(an ex American football player and the group's muscle), nearly beat Thomas to death, bit a chunk out of the neck of a bandit that tried to rape his son, defeated Paul Monroe despite only having one hand and seeing him defeat Abraham (the group's new muscle) and Mischonne at the same time then he defeats Negan, the most dangerous villain in the walking dead universe so far.
Clementine has killed about 2 dudes as a last resort, If the player sucks and gets defeated by the little league coach and with the season 2 finale which is optional. She pretty much runs from every other confrontation with living hostiles and evades them. How is she really tested in combat?
Carl sneaks away from his group and sneaks on to one of Negan's convoy trucks to find his base and assasinate him to get revenge for him killing Glen. When he's discovered he takes out a group of Negan men with a machine gun despite not knowing where he is or if he will live or die beyond his actions and Carl had killed living people before and after that moment.
Based on what the 4 characters have done during their journeys I would say that Rick would own Lee and Carl would own Clem. Rick and Lee are more skilled in combat and are more comfortable with killing the living.
I'm sorry, but I just have to call you out on one thing. Rick vs Tyreese (comics) was not a draw. Tyreese beat the fuck out of Rick. And Rick only took out Jesus with a sneak attack after he agreed to follow him. Jesus is THE best hand to hand fighter in TWD. Other than that I agree, Rick and Carl would probably stomp out Lee and Clem, if only because they're both batshit crazy and willing to do anything.
Lee and Clem would kick their asses if we're talking about the show. If we're talking about the comics, it would be pretty close so I would say a tie.
Lee and Rick would start fighting and clementine will kill carl right away and right before rick is about to kill kenny clementine kills rick.
This would pretty much happen
How about when he slaughtered the leader of the remaining Terminus group?
I mean, holy crap!
It's almost like the show's creator is turning Rick Grimes into Jack Nicholson's character from the 1980 film: The Shining.
"Heeeeeeeeeerrres Joooooooohhhhhnnnnyyyyy!"
Rick would beat Lee.
Clem would beat Carl - especially if they're both older.
Then Clem would beat Rick because Rick would hesitate.
Clem FTW.
Rick also got beaten to heck by the Governor, and only survived because Michonne saved him.
But all in all, I still think Rick's tougher than Lee. But Clem is way tougher than Carl. And a better shot. And quicker thinking. And more agile.
I wish that were so, but I suspect the only one who would survive that fight would be JUST Clem
Have the games taught you nothing? 
Why would Rick hesitate to kill Clementine after she killed his son?
Clem is able to kill a Walker in an enclosed shed, while sick from an infected arm, after stitching herself up without any painkiller, while initially unarmed AND caught by surprise, after a day of continually passing out, getting knocked around in a river, starving, and getting mauled by a dog.
In Howes, she takes out two zombies, again, while surprised and while unarmed.
Carl, on the other hand - well... killing a bunch of people with a machine gun isnt exactly 'proven in combat' - it just means he had a better weapon and the element of surprise on his side.
I pretty much think she's proven in combat.
Rick WOULD own Lee - he's better trained, a better shot, and better with a melee weapon. Also more vicious.
Without the machine gun, Clem would take him out. Not to mention Clem uses the fact that people underestimate her to her advantage every time.
But Clem would definitely own Carl. She's been shown to be an incredibly good shot with even just a pistol. Or with melee weapons. Or unarmed and using the environment to her advantage. And is extremely agile and quick. Carl? wow - he used a machine gun after being discovered. Clem wouldnt have been discovered in the first place
1) You're assuming Rick would have seen Clem kill her son, rather than be busy fighting Lee.
2) Clem is still a child, and Rick still might hesitate before shooting and killing an 11 year old girl. Despite often being vicious, he does still have a conscience.
3) Even if it's a momentary hesitation, that can often be enough.
My money is on Rick beating Lee. A well trained cop vs a history professor seems a little unfair lol. Lee is no Indiana Jones, but what both are good at no matter what is zombie killing.
I believe my Clem can take on Carl and win. She has proven nothing but capable since we've met her (except for that one time...). Carl only seems to be adequate in a brawl when he has a lethal weapon.
After the fight they would lick their wounds and swallow their prides.
Fair point.
Is it the rick from issue 127 and up? If it is he would lose easily. He has a busted leg from his fight with negan and on top of that is missing a hand.