What if these 2 groups of survivors ran into each other?
What do you think would happen? I know a lot of them are dead at this point in time, but imagine if they were all still alive and they formed into these two groups of survivors.
Group One is what you can consider the good guys, in my opinion I think that these characters are the main protagonists of TWDG, I know that Lily and Kenny both go off the rails at different points but they are still good at heart. Lee is the leader of the group:
Group Two are a handful of antagonists in the game, in this case they are like a group of marauders. Roman and Danny don't do that much in terms of evilness, but Roman does come across as a tough guy and will do bad things to protect his group, Danny is a convicted rapist and we know that if he survives the prison bus he remains a threat to females. The Stranger was a good family man once, but since he lost that he went psycho and wound up with these guys instead of dying alone. Carver is the leader of the group and they all respect him:
So how do you think it will go down?
Comments
All out war.
Why is that then? Do you not think that the two groups would get along with each other?
Not at all. Carver and Luke have a history and wouldn't get along. Carver is the reason Kenny lost his eye, so Kenny doesn't like him. The Stranger kidnapped Clementine so Lee and Christa don't like him. Both Troy and Carver have hit or threatened Clementine, which would probably get Lee angry at them. I just don't see them getting along.
I think the antagonist group falls apart when Carver gets killed. The stranger dies because he's useless anyway, Troy fights with Carver until the end. Nate runs away after Carver dies and doesn't care about pursuing the group. Danny doesn't really fight in the first place but makes an inappropriate advance at one of the girls. You have the choice to kill him for it, or let him go. Roman surrenders and apologizes, saying he was only with him because he had no other way of surviving. You can either allow him to join Lee, let him go, or kill him anyway.
Agreeing with @LRats, although I think it would fall apart even with Carver in it. The Stranger may be a bit off in the head, but I don't think he would team up with assholes or other crazies, maybe even not get along with them. Roman seemed actually like a level-headed person just trying to be in control and making tough decisions, so probably not get along with the assholes in that group, also butt heads with Carver in terms of leadership. I guess what I'm saying is that this group would fall apart the second they try and do anything.
This entire video sums it up well.
django
They´d calmly discuss an alliance.
y
y not
cuz iz rong m8
u dun no anythng
i no u cant just put a gurls hed on a boi's body wtf is rong wit u?
i did n id do it agn ok
u can nevur do et aaign or u wil n0t get icecreem.
u tink i cre bout icecrem cuz i dun so ha rekt
nu icecreem = nu freindz
HA LOOOSIER!!!!1111
u shut ur mouf >:(
A whole lotta stuff, and a whole lotta things, Lori.
haha git rekt m8
i wuldv gtn away wit it 2 if it wrnt fer u meddlin kid
sht up shrek u leik hedghgs
so wat? ourr luv is reel!!!!111
u left him
nu he left me
u ned to mke up
A lot wrong with this post. Roman, Danny and Nate are not "villains" and should be taken out of team Carver. I highly doubt Nate or Danny could respect Carver since they seem like guys who follow their own rules. Carver wouldn't have someone as mentally weak as the Stranger working for him and Carver killed Roman, remember. Add the St. Johns instead. I wouldn't classify Lily as a "villain" nor "hero" you could have added Omid, Pete, Molly or Carley/Doug. Aside for Carver wanting to get even with Clem, Kenny and Luke for killing him and destroying his community nothing would really happen. I do like the idea though
weez alredyz did, wer gettin married
Opinion.
Oh, boy. A villain or antagonist is someone who presents a direct threat to the protagonist. I don't think any of these three qualify or would willingly swear their undying allegiance and loyalty to someone like Carver
I don't know man, Danny raping a girl sounds pretty evil.
Statutory Rape is consensual. Still rape though. We don't know the details of it he does seem like a bit of a prick but not a villain.
As for Nate I've already addressed this several times he's more broken or misguided. He helped Russell and cared about him to an extent opposed to just killing him. His reason for trying to kill Wyatt and Eddie is understandable.
Roman just seemed like a person who lived by rules. He cared about the gas station group and had decent and understandable intentions for wanting to kill Stephanie. He can't have any regard for others he needed to care about his group and he did.
ths iz beutiful n i wil cri evri tiem
That doesn't exclude him from being a villain.
Yep, and I consider it "villainous" and how do you know it was consensual?
How I see it, it seems he let all the power go to his head. So I'd consider him a villain.
wez even hadz kidz
Nate only presented a threat when he was chasing down Wyatt and Eddie after they killed his friend. It was more defense. He was very decent to Russell and saved his life on two occasions.
Like I said its a possibility that it was consensual so I don't know. Statutory Rape is consensual but we don't know if that was Danny's case.
Roman just seemed nervous at worst. It was likely that Steff could have brought people back seeing as how bad of a mess she was and he wasn't willing to take another chance after just losing Boyd
I definitely see why Nate chased down Eddie and Wyatt, I think that's justified, but in Russell's story I saw him more of a freak.
There might be, but doesn't he deny it ever happening? Doesn't that make him more guilty of his crime?
I never lost Boyd in my game so.... He still goes crazy.
I agree with you on Roman and Danny. I don't really think Roman was a villain at all, just was the unfortunate leader of a bad situation. Like so many others had to be in TWD universe. Danny is definitely shady, but not necessarily a villain. I chose to leave him behind because he didn't see anything wrong in raping that girl, statutory or not.
Nate I completely disagree with. He might have cared somewhat for Russel, but he was still insane. Murdering that old man put him in that "bad guy" category for me.
I respect your opinion but I'd like to think that we have at least reached the understanding that none of the three are deserving of villainy than the St. Johns.
Let's change the subject, why do you think any of these men would respect Carver and be another one of his puppets?
I think the ST. Johns are the biggest villains.
I think Carver's men are just afraid, or they just want power, kinda like Troy.